>>>To contextualize: I'm a huge Pixar fan. Ratatouille and Wall-E were my two of my favorite films of their respective years. Yet Up was...profoundly disappointing.
I hear ya, ff. Not that I agree, but I understand.
Several years back, "Hey Ya!" by Outkast was all over the place. And it seemed everybody loved the song. From age two to ninety-two. Everybody seemed hooked on the song. Except my friend Rob. He totally didn't get the song at all. He thought the supposed "think-y" lyrics of the chorus were at total odds with the "hey ya!" chorus and the "what's cooler than being cool" stuff. He found the music derivative and boring, and he just could NOT figure out what the rest of the world was thinking. I found that somewhat intriguing.
Then, last year, it was my turn.
I still don't get "I Kissed a Girl". I think the lyrics are clunky, trite and exceptionally pandering, and I think Katy's vocal delivery is utterly dispassionate and unsoulful. Meanwhile, the rest of the world still is playing the song to death. Straight guys think it's hot, straight girls think it's "naughty", gays think it's empowering, and I found that my conservative cousins in rural Wisconsin sing it to their three-year-old daughter. I just don't GET this song.
I don't think there's anything wrong with me. I'm just not connecting to something other people are connecting to.
Your points about Up are valid. Yes, the talking dogs are inessential and run somewhat at counterpurposes to the plot. Yes, the lifestory is intentionally tear-jerky and maudlin. All that. But speaking for me (and I think for most of the people who watched it), it worked. I realize they were manipulating me into feeling for this guy, but the fact is I DID feel for this guy. I knew full well what was going to happen in the first fifteen minutes, but I was pulled in regardless.
And I think that's what's so incredible about Pixar. Their ability to pull us in. I mean, they not only asked us to believe that a rat wanted to cook, but they asked us to believe he accomplished this by pulling the hair of a human to control his basic motor skills. But we accepted it. Because Pixar drew us in. Somehow, we let them get away with it. And that, in many ways, is kind of their genius.
I don't think you "missed" anything. I don't think you lack heart, or need to go back and watch it again. I just think the movie missed you. For some reason, it didn't click. It happens. Just rest assured that most people liked it, and so it looks like Pixar still has it. And look forward to Toy Story 3 next year.
Lex