Our relationship is different from any other guy friend I've ever had. I don't know if that is just because we had sex, or if there is an emotional component there. We've only gotten together the two times and really haven't done anything yet like go to a movie, sporting event or dinner - just haven't had time, but we are going to. But we've talked and neither of us want a "gay relationship". He's going through a divorse and that is kinda messy right now. If we are seen together in public we'll look just like two friends together, we won't be holding hands or kissing in public.
First off, I dont like the idea of holding hands in public either. I'm not really high on showing my love and affection in public. Straight people do it, gay people do it, its not for me.
But when you both say you dont want a "gay relationship", that suggests to me that you guys are possibly both very inexperienced in this area. You have a wrong idea of how and what gay relationships are.
If he were to tell me he met a girl or wants to get back with his wife and doesn't want to have sex with me anymore - I think I could be fine with that. (I'd miss it and miss him) and I don't know if I could just be friends with him and hangout with him, and not want to have sex with him.
But if he were to tell me he met a guy and wants to start a relationship with him, I'd be crushed - I'd say well what about me. I don't want him to have sex with another guy. My other guy friends, I'm not sexually attracted to, but with this guy I am - and it's not just his looks, but the way he acts and the type of guy he is.
That there does show that you are more then fuck buds. If you would be jealous if he did something with another guy, you are emotionally connected to him.
Having said all this though, it doesn't feel the same as it has with my past girlfriends - can't really describe the difference, but I guess the emotional closeness isn't there, but I think it might come.
We both want to continue our relationship, I'm just afraid of getting in too deep, deeper than both of us really want to at least right now.
Well first of all, it seems both of you are in no situation to fall in love. He is going through a divorce and from what you said in the opening post, you dont have much experience. (or this is new anyways)
I think you guys are in "un-tapped" waters. I think both of you are calm, cool guys that approach life one step at a time and thats probably why you like each other. You dont feel pressured into stuff and what you do almost doesn't seem gay because you take your time..it seems more natural that way.
But what you said above, that you would be jealous if he was with another guy, tells me that there is potential there. If you open up more, if he steps away from you, starts looking at other guys, you will then realize how much you might actually love him. Its just that the situation you describe, him being with a women, never really threatned you. So you guys were fine with your arrangment as is.
I think you guys felt so comfortable and happy with what you had going that there was no reason to make it more complicated. But maybe that time is coming now as his life is changing and more emotion will get into it.