Idols that never won who should have

[wrestling lover]

Which past idols should have won the competition
mine are as follows

Tamyra Grey
Treynce
Frency Davis
Latoya London
Jennifer Hudson
Vonzell Soloman
Daughtry
Kathrine Mcphee
Jason Castro

 

[sargeantassman]

I think they are probably better off not winning AI tho. At least they arent trapped into some bullshit. When was the last time Ruben Studdard did anything?? Scooby Doo?

 

[Tadaa]

Which past idols should have won the competition
mine are as follows

Tamyra Grey
Treynce
Frency Davis
Latoya London
Jennifer Hudson
Vonzell Soloman
Daughtry
Kathrine Mcphee
Jason Castro

Jason Castro

 

[Brian117]

The only one I can name is Blake Lewis. He has SERIOUS talent. I would of bought his CD instead of burning it, lol.

 

[martyj]

My PERSONAL list:

Melissa McGhee for Season 5.
LaKisha Jones for Season 6.
Amanda Overmyer for Season 7.

 

[martyj]

Hey, if Reuben, Taylor, and Jordin could do it...

 

[954dude]

Tamyra, Kimberley Locke, Latoya London, Jennifer Hudson, Camile Velasco, Mario Vazquez, Katharine McPhee, Elliott Yamin, Melinda Doolittle, Carly Smithson

 

[blakemason001]

Tamyra Gray
Kimberly Locke
Katharine McPhee
Chris Daughtry
Jennifer Hudson
Trenyce Solomon

 

[VaseFace808]

Obviously people like Daughtry & J-Hud are better off not winning

But I think Katherine McPhee should've def. won over Taylor...what the hell was America thinking that season...

Anyway she's the only I think should've won. Jordin Sparks has a decent voice, but she got lucky with "No Air"...Tattoo was a mess.

But Jordin still deserved to win over Blake lol

But I lost interest in AI after Fantasia's season, 3 I think

 

[Jared82]

Tamyra Gray
Kimberley Locke
Jennifer Hudson
Mario Vazquez (but thats his own fault)
Elliot Yamin
Melinda Doolittle

 

[Vanyel]

Jason Castro

Yeah I don't see that one either. Limited range. Even smaller stage presence. Had he won, Idol would have lost the last lingering, tiny bits of credibility it has left.

The only one I can name is Blake Lewis. He has SERIOUS talent. I would of bought his CD instead of burning it, lol.

Blake was talented in one area. That's it. Like David A. this season when brought out of his element he floundered. He was a breath of fresh air in last season's "competition", but it was right that he didn't win.

Off the top of my head I can only name three who should have won, Tamyra, Hudson and Frenchie.

 

[MaxMouse]

Trenyce and Vonzell Solomon, in my opinion, both had it all

 

[josher]

Melinda Doolittle.

 

[wrestling lover]

okay im totally in love with jason thats the reason behind that any updates on the future divas

latoya
vonzell
treynce
tamyra

where are these girls,i need there music