Re: NExt Batman Villian (comic book nerds only j/k
I have to disagree with you. I think Catwoman comes before the Penguin.
We're just going to have to agree to disagree with this one.
I would rank most famous as:
1) Joker
2) Penguin
3) Catwoman
4) Riddler
5) Two Face
... which coincidentally happened to be the the same order we saw them appear in the Burton/Schumacher films.
And your idea for the Penguin is a smart approach but I feel like it is stripping the character of everything it really is other than his name.
The problem is that so many fans have, for whatever reason, turned on The Penguin and essentially put him in the lame villain category. I never hear explanations why they feel this way. They just do.
I can only assume that they don't view him as a threatening enough villain. I do think the bird-obsession has got to go. In the comics, most of his crimes revolved around the bird-theme.
I enjoyed DeVito's version. I thought he pulled off a brilliant Penguin. But it seems like most of today's fans would like to see The Penguin back to basics and back to his mob roots.
With that being said, I would like to see the basic trademarks of the character .... dressed in black, obviously the umbrella, the monocle, and the top hat ... but today's fans crave violence. They like "darker" versions of the villains portrayed then their portrayals of year's past.
Most sites I see, people want to steer far away from the Jim Carrey portrayal of Riddler, and go the route of John Glover's version from the Animated Series. I agree with this route 100%. There seems to be a lot of people that want to see Hugo Weaving in the role.
So with that in mind, I think Phillip Seymour Hoffman would give us a fantastic portrayal of The Penguin that today's fans want to see. I would love to see the tip of his umbrella go through someone's throat ... an officer, or detective who his perhaps tracing him, and then captured.
Give the public what they want.
There's an intrigue value of how a man his size got to be so dominant in Gotham's underworld. But we need to see scenes like that, or perhaps him torturing someone with a flame that comes from the tip of his umbrella. By treating the character as a serious threat to Gotham, and involving him in intense scenes like this, his credibility should be restored in the eyes of fans.
But other than that I really think we will see a female villain in this next movie and I think Catwoman or Taila Al Ghul would be perfect because of their romantic connections to Batman and the sudden loss of the romantic interest in the Dark Knight.
As I said, I think we are down to The Penguin, The Riddler, and Catwoman as possible villains in the next one. I think you can kiss Talia goodbye. It may be someone hardcore fans want to see, but she just isn't mainstream enough to be featured.
I think The Riddler is definitely in. The question is who will the second choice be?