Very timely discussion - I have been carrying on this search for a few weeks, comparing Plasma vrs LCD vrs LCD/LED, refresh rates 60, 120, 240 and even 480 Hz, 42,46 or 53 inch diag, features such as HDMI connections, internet compatibility, etc....and then brand... Sanyo, Samsung, LG, Sony, Panasonic, and, of course, price.
And..most importantly...many trips to the big box stores to compare how the pictures looked to me.
Simultaneously, my tech-savy friend was making identical comparisons.
At the end, my friend chose the 46" LED Samsung model with the 240 Hz refresh rate mentioned by MindBlast at the beginning of this thread, costing about $2,400. I settled on a 46" Sony Bravia 2 LCD with a "mere" 60 Hz refresh rate for $850.
I just could not see a difference between the two...even with fast motion and fast panning shots. And could not justify to myself the $1,500 plus price difference. My friend, on the other hand, is not one to "settle" and insists on the best and most current. We are both very satisfied with our choices. I find my Sony's colors to be brilliant, the picture incredibly sharp and detailed.
And..the tv speakers are remarkably good. But, I use an outside amplifier I bought via Craigslist and 30 y/o Radio Shack "Realistic Minimus 7" speakers from eBay that were goosed up with new crossovers and bass speaker cones....that are simply perfect for my setup. (I don't want "surround" sound...as I find it distracting). The sounds...voices, water, bird calls, car chase, etc.....are very "realistic". (I play my computer audio thru the same amplifier). (Someday...I will try connecting the computer's video also).
I also purchased online a "refurbished" Panasonic DMP-605 Blue-Ray DVD player for $89 (a Google search and comparison seems to indicate that *all* DMP-605's by Panasonic are refurbished (I wonder why..?). Nevertheless, the player is fantastic, can connect to the net for YouTube, firmware updates and for the soon to come Amazon streaming movies (but not Netflix), a USB connector, etc. And...it "upconverts" non-Blue-Ray DVD's magnificantly (with one exception "Bonnie & Clyde" which must be a poor transfer.) Thank goodness, in my pre-HD days, I always tried to get wide-screen versions of any DVD.
Sadly, a large DVD rental store nearby is going out of business and selling its entire inventory (including Blue-Ray's, foreign films, concerts, etc.) at low prices. I am sorry to see the store close, but this has been a good opportunity to buy movies that I would happily pay to see in a theater for less than a ticket would cost.
I had to have my cable tv company come and connect their digital converter box (I elected NOT to have DVR). Now I get more channels, and of course, the HD channels that really shine on this tv. The converter box, however, generates a LOT of heat. So....I have the whole setup plugged into a wall outlet that I can shutoff when I am through viewing. I figure if the converter box is throwing so much heat, it must be consuming a LOT of electricity, so I turn it off after viewing the tv.
In short...I believe I am getting maximum enjoyment from my setup at a cost of less than $1,000 for all components.
But then....next year will no doubt bring better prices, more options and who knows... But, in the meantime, I am having a great time!
