vox populi
On the Prowl
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2006
- Posts
- 54
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
The left is not imploding. It simply can't. Imploding implies that an object caves in upon itself, and the American left has lacked for nearly 40 years now the sort of stable center that would allow for the creation of anything like a black hole. We've long been far more fractured and ad hoc than the republican right simply because we have no universal rallying cry (like money or propinquity) to galvanize supporters. It's much easier to tease people with the promises of riches or to segregate them from others by demonizing dissenting voices as immoral, profane, and ungodly than it is to convince disparate groups of people that their personal advancement depends upon their ability to temporarily bracket their personal concerns for the sake of more distant advances (like demanding a living wage for service industry and retail workers or insuring that indigent families get access to health care and education).
Some of the people who have responded to this thread are absolutely correct that Air America's biggest failure was to create a cartoon version of the sort of ludicrous inanities that people like Laura Schlessinger, Rush Limbaugh, and Don Imus piss forth daily on the radio. Al Franken, as much as I appreciate his sincerity, should have been far more straight-forward and far less a clown in order to sell his point of view. But Air America itself should not have depended as heavily as it has upon someone like Franken to put forward a counterweight to conservative oversimplifications and jingoist bullshitting if only because all that clowning diminshes the seriousness of the problems at hand for anyone who does not have a stock portfolio or even a healthy 401K plan.
Let's also not be so stupid as to identify the American left with the well being of Air America Radio. People like Amy Goodman and Greg Pallast are still ready and willing to muckrake and shame conservatives along with the sleazy underlings of our corporatocracy whenever they can. An American leftist media infrastructure is also coming to fruition through the work of numerous bloggers and watchdog websites like Media Matters, the Progressive States network, and the Center for American Progress among others. Leftist and liberal voices are beginning to take the same sort of Maoist approach to media that the republican right (and its parasitic evangelical offspring) has been bleeding dry for 20 years.
Sorry to disappoint anyone, but with or without Air America, the battle rages on.
Some of the people who have responded to this thread are absolutely correct that Air America's biggest failure was to create a cartoon version of the sort of ludicrous inanities that people like Laura Schlessinger, Rush Limbaugh, and Don Imus piss forth daily on the radio. Al Franken, as much as I appreciate his sincerity, should have been far more straight-forward and far less a clown in order to sell his point of view. But Air America itself should not have depended as heavily as it has upon someone like Franken to put forward a counterweight to conservative oversimplifications and jingoist bullshitting if only because all that clowning diminshes the seriousness of the problems at hand for anyone who does not have a stock portfolio or even a healthy 401K plan.
Let's also not be so stupid as to identify the American left with the well being of Air America Radio. People like Amy Goodman and Greg Pallast are still ready and willing to muckrake and shame conservatives along with the sleazy underlings of our corporatocracy whenever they can. An American leftist media infrastructure is also coming to fruition through the work of numerous bloggers and watchdog websites like Media Matters, the Progressive States network, and the Center for American Progress among others. Leftist and liberal voices are beginning to take the same sort of Maoist approach to media that the republican right (and its parasitic evangelical offspring) has been bleeding dry for 20 years.
Sorry to disappoint anyone, but with or without Air America, the battle rages on.



















