Alone- Heart, Celine Dion, or Glee Cast?

[jeffhardylover8472]

Heart
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Cw1ng75KP0[/ame]

Celine Dion
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6sA4R4AI8o[/ame]

Glee Cast
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUWf7Q5LFjI[/ame]

 

[PhoenixRising]

Hard to say. The original is a classic, raw and powerful. But Celine has lots of emotion in her version. She adds maturity to the song.

The Glee version, while nice, is a bit to polished and....well, plastic for my tastes.

 

[dsh122]

I was torn between Heart and Celine... In the end I had to go with the original, Heart!

 

[gingentleman]

None can surpass the original!

 

[QuinnRider]

I chose Celine because I just love her voice so much more, and the violin and everything is just so beautiful, but I think that Celine and Heart[Ann, yes?] both did amazing jobs, and are tied in my eyes.

 

[JetSetJake]

Celine's version is the best IMHO.

Glee's version is too teenage, Heart's version is classic 80s and the original, but Celine's version is a good update and has a slightly different arrangement rather than just being a karaoke version which many cover versions are. Then of course there's Celine's voice whose power and emotion add the finishing sparkle

 

[Nomenclature]

I can't stand Glee, because they Autotune and compress their vocals too hard. So even though they have good vocalists, they make them sound really robotic and shitty. I haven't heard a single track from them i've liked.

I voted Heart.

 

[thelaw18489]

Heart with out a doubt because the glee version is gross and I never was much of a dion fan

 

[chatolandia]

Heart,


Celine lacks the rawness and Glee, well, they are so very cute!

 

[Mellored]

Didn't like the song till Glee did it.

 

[matt1980111]

I voted for Heart. I love Celine's version but I think it lacks a certain raw spark that Heart's version had.

I love Glee but I don't think Matthew's voice meshes well with the song at all.