Best Musical movie?

[bryan1987]

What's the best Musical movie ever made?

 

[cumtasteit]

Those are all good choices, but the best, Cabaret, is not on the list.
XXX

 

[Txgoodoldboy]

First one, that came to mind, Cabaret!

 

[PreTTy PeTe]

from your list i would say West Side Story.

but my favourites are Grease and Hair



things never change eh?

 

[bigfun81]

my lesbian friend kim told me that she was gay by telling me about when she was a little girl, she had the biggest crush on Debbie Reynolds in Unsinkable Molly Brown. it is not bad I liked it.

 

[jsd62]

I voted for West Side Story but, my favorite is Guys and Dolls.

 

[richardPB1]

Cabaret has to be my all time favorite. But on that list I go with CHICAGO.

 

[Ginge]

You have missed so many good ones out, Grease, Cabaret, Oklahoma, Carousel, Gypsy and Oliver and a hell of a lot more

But from your list i couldn't really decide from West side story or the sound of music. although i did vote for the latter

 

[stevie402]

One of my all time favorites is Meet Me St. Louis. I also love Fiddler on the Roof, but out of the choices you presented, West Side Story is the best.

 

[lifeisamazing]

nothing beats the classics like "Singing in the Rain" and "Beauty and the Beast" but however, beauty beat the rain by a tiny bit.

 

[crakker_jakk]

'chitty chitty gang bang'.. i'm obsessed with the child catcher..

 

[richard_pista]

You left off Mame, staring Lucile Ball and Bea Arthur. A great musical and a great cast. My favorite line is when Auntie Mame tells her nephew Patrick, "Life is a banquet and most poor suckers are starving to death!"

 

[Kuja]

I listen to the music from Chicago often...but I like Moulin Rouge better.

 

[bryan1987]

I'm sorry I missed some great movies, but I could only choose ten!
My personal favorite is Chicago. I just love Renée Zellweger.

 

[Angelfan]

Chicago is one of the worst movie adaptations of a musical ever. The cast were awful. The choreography wasn't a patch on the stage choreography. They cut half a dozen songs from the score and lost all the humour of the stage show.

 

[josher]

1) Singin' in the Rain 2) The Band Wagon 3) Gigi for original movie musicals 1) Cabaret 2) West Side Story 3) My Fair Lady for movie musicals adapted from Broadway.

 

[Blueboy369]

Dude,
Here are some Classic shows to add to the list!

 

[BINOWGAYLATER]

there are so many good ones - but you can't mention West Side Story, The Sound of Music, and My Fair Lady without incuding THE KING AND I !! Deborah Kerr (even if she didn't do all the signing) is a class act.

 

[The_Reaper]

I love all of them....

But Singin' in the Rain is the best...followed closely by My Fair Lady, with Moulin Rouge gaining ground quickly behind it...

 

[Michael Luc]

That's a tough list to put together. But I opted for The Sound of Music.

<Cue the music> "The hills are alive...."