Big Brother (All Stars 2) Who will you cast?

[wrestling lover]

Well Big Brother is done for this year and I think we have just enough characters for a second addition of All Stars. The first installment of All Stars was after season 6. So Ideally we would have to wait until after Season 13 to do another All Stars but why wait? We have alot of people that just need to be in a house together lol



Contenders from Big Brother 8

*Evil Dick(Winner)

*Daniele(Runner Up)

*Eric(America's Player)

*Jessica(6th Place)

*Amber(7th Place)

*Jen(8th Place)



Contenders from Big Brother 9

*Adam(Winner)

*Sheila(3rd Place)

*Crazy James(6th Place?)

*Chelsia

*Natalie(5th Place)

*Matty



Contenders from Big Brother 10

*Dan(Winner)

*Jerry

*Keesha

*Libra

*Brian?

*Jesse?



Contenders from Big Brother 11

*Jordan(Winner)

*Natalie

*Kevin

*Michele

*Jeff

*Russell

*Chima

*Ronnie



This season has tons of contenders so if you had to cast just 14 players from this line up. Who would they be?



I would cast



1.Dick(Hate him but cant have All Stars without him)

2.Eric(Let's see him play his own game)

3.Jen( Come on Dick's biggest rival must be in this)

4.Crazy James

5.Natalie(BB9) or Chelsia NOT BOTH!

6.Adam

7.Dan

8.Sheila or Renny(We need our motherly figure but only one can make it)

9.Keesha

10.Libra or Chima (We need our Diva but only one can make it)

11.Kevin (He has to be a definite, we need our token gay player (no offense) and he actually made it further than any gay player in BB History plus he's hilarious. He Must return

12.Jordan? Jeff? (I dont see both coming back but who knows)

13.Ronnie(Yuck! But he was hated so why not?

14.Natalie BB11 or Michele

 

[wrestling lover]

It has to be from BB8 and beyond... Kevin for AS2!

 

[wrestling lover]

You really think they wont invite Kevin? Really? He actually played a better game then anyone this season, was funny and that is needed in every season. And the most of all. He is the farthest making gay person ever. He has a great shot and since every season has a token gay, Kevin will be back for All Stars. They sure as hell aint asking douches like Dustin and Joshua back. Kevin is gay/black and japanese all rolled up into one. They will bring him back lol

 

[Lovegame]

Season 8:
Jen, Mike

Season 9
Alex, Natalie

Season 10
Keesha, Libra, Brian

Season 11
Michele, Russell, Laura

 

[wrestling lover]

IDK! Allison G likes him, I read that she pegged him as the winner in the F3. He was pretty popular despite being in with the "bad guys". Every forum I go too, he is usually number 4 behind Jordeff and Michele. Most importantly, they edited Kevin pretty positively. IDK I see him coming back for some reason, I mean I barely remember Dustin and Josh except that they were assholes. Hopefully DR Kevin makes his debut in the house lol

 

[slyfer]

Dream cast: Assuming there's 13-14 houseguests.

BB11: Russ, Ronnie, Michelle
BB10: Libra(hands down), Dan, Keesha.
BB9: Sheila, James, Sharon.
BB8. This is the hard one to pick from because i loved so many of them. Dick, Jen, Eric. And since dick probably wouldn't do it unless Danielle came back. I have to auto pick her even though she was pretty high in winning stuff. Tied Janelle's veto wins.

And I'm pretty sure Eric would win the game. He manipulates as good as or better than Dr. Will himself. He was just put in a terrible fucking position to win that game when he wasn't even playing for himself.

 

[slyfer]

No way is Eric in Dr. Will's league. I think Eric's gameplay is way overrated actually. A truly talented and agile player would have used the information America was giving him and worked around it to advance his own game. Remember, Eric was compelled to vote however America voted, but he was free to reject any of America's offers (the monetary ones) if it conflicted with his own gameplay. He was not compelled therefore to campaign for everyone America wanted out of the house, yet he always did it. And that's not because he always wanted the monetary pay-offs (because obviously $500,000 is much more), it's because he was imperceptive and lacked self-awareness (and he still does today, judging from his blog and online interviews), and he incorrectly thought that America was on his side, and that whatever they directed him to do was ultimately for his own benefit. Any insightful player would have picked up early on that America was only playing for the Donatos (ugh) and that they were willing to sacrifice Eric to get D&D in the finals.

I also couldn't stand Eric's personality on BB8, he was an annoying, fidgety hobbit. I'm sure he probably could get far in an All Star season given how stupid the average houseguest is, but I'd personally be rooting for his eviction early on.

I agree with you that he wasn't the most entertaining person from S8(I didn't like him that much but since I was also rooting for Jessica to win, I tolerated him), but thinking back on what a season of all stars entails I retract my statement about him being able to manipulate much in a season of AS since they all know what's going on at that point. In a fresh season where noone knew him, i'm sure he'd get further. He made it to what? Final 5? With america guiding him the whole way?

And where on earth did you hear that he could reject any of the tasks america set him to do such as lobby for someone to get nominated? I heard that he was basically forced to give a whole hearted try to accomplish any of america's tasks. I could be wrong but if he could simply reject a task then i'm sure he wouldn't have lobbied to take the donatos to F5. As by that time in the game he HATED those two. And at that exact time he realized america was rooting for the donatos and he still did it.

 

[slyfer]

No way is Eric in Dr. Will's league. I think Eric's gameplay is way overrated actually. A truly talented and agile player would have used the information America was giving him and worked around it to advance his own game. Remember, Eric was compelled to vote however America voted, but he was free to reject any of America's offers (the monetary ones) if it conflicted with his own gameplay. He was not compelled therefore to campaign for everyone America wanted out of the house, yet he always did it. And that's not because he always wanted the monetary pay-offs (because obviously $500,000 is much more), it's because he was imperceptive and lacked self-awareness (and he still does today, judging from his blog and online interviews), and he incorrectly thought that America was on his side, and that whatever they directed him to do was ultimately for his own benefit. Any insightful player would have picked up early on that America was only playing for the Donatos (ugh) and that they were willing to sacrifice Eric to get D&D in the finals.

I also couldn't stand Eric's personality on BB8, he was an annoying, fidgety hobbit. I'm sure he probably could get far in an All Star season given how stupid the average houseguest is, but I'd personally be rooting for his eviction early on.

Is there anywhere I can watch fucking season two. I know how good Will is as he himself set up Boogie to win the whole fucking season. I saw it, but I feel as though i'm missing something because I didn't watch season 2. No one will give anyone credit for being as manipulative as Will. Now i'll budge on Eric maybe not being as good as Will, but does anyone give Danielle(S3) the credit she deserves? I get that Will is ridiculously charming, good looking, but I haven't even seen anyone give any other players any kind of praise Will gets besides Janelle(who's my main bitch). Idk, i just really need to see S2 lol.

 

[Aratron]

Here slyfer.

Btw, which is better? 2 or 4? Why? Those are the only seasons I didn't watch (besides 1)

 

[wrestling lover]

Where would you rank Kevin in that list of F2 sentiments? He didnt make F2 but still lol

Excellent or Very good pleas

 

[Aratron]

I personally prefer BB4 though BB2 features the best player of all time (Will). Most fans don't like BB4 because they didn't care for many of the personalities, but I usually appreciate the game differently from most fans. Since you and I disagree on Janelle's merits as a player, and since you thought Sharon was less of a player than Jordan (Yikes! The mind boggles) my guess is you wouldn't enjoy BB4 for Jun & Allison's awesome floater gameplay. You might prefer BB2 then for the personalities involved.

I don't care much about gameplay, I care more about the personalities For example, in BB5, my favorite was Karen and she was one of the people that didn't have much game.

I actually watched a few episodes of both seasons and I didn't like BB2 much, don't know if it's because it's different

 

[Bidude117]

Honestly, Big Brother 13 or 14 will be another All-Stars. I can't picture BB12 being another All-Stars season.

 

[wrestling lover]

Fans Vs Faves? Sign me up with Kevin and we will do all kinds of things

 

[Jersey Domino]

This is a variation of people who I would cast.

BB8- Dick, Jen, Eric, Jessica, Zach.

BB9-James, Natalie, Sheila, Ryan, Matt, Chelsia, Allison, Alex.

BB10-Dan, Keesha, Libra, Memphis, Brian, April

BB11-Russel, Laura, Casey, Ronnie,Michelle, Jeff

 

[talesofabyssjade]

The only person I want to see in the house is Nick Starcevic from BB8. I just want him to walk around shirtless (or naked) and talk about his homoerotic tendencies

 

[HOT4MEN]

Jeff for sure!

Although, the UK's biggest show ever and the biggest thing ever in the UK - Big Brother - was canceled this year. I am sure the US version is not far behind.

 

[wrestling lover]

Not with the ratings they got this season