Man, I'm in the same situation... almost *exactly* the same, really. It's tough when you're looking for a real connection, not just a hook-up. I just try to be patient, and keep an open mind. As stated before, it's almost impossible to find what guys like us are looking for on dating sites, or in bars.. which really seems cut down on the options. I guess it's true, you can't hurry love.
On a side note, with me, pretty much my biggest interest is cars, and it's really not that easy to find gay guys who are into cars as much as me. So, that always cuts out a couple hours of interesting conversation potential, haha. So with me, finding instant common ground to work with is a rare occurence. Therefor, in my profiles, I try to list as many interests as I can think of, even ones that I'm not *that* into, because if you know anything about a subject, it's at least something to spark conversation (and maybe even some quality time if the guy wants to teach me more about it

)
So don't get discouraged. Honestly, you're
absolutely adorable *and* you know what you want. That's never a bad combo.
BTW the mirror pic made me laugh my ass off
all the best,
SimpleMan