Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happen.

[roguehunter]

well, ive been thinking about this for a long time, i know this has probebly been thought of before by a billion people, but i think that harry is goin to die in the last book. i think he has to. for he was never the chosen one, neville longbottom really is. the only reason that everyone thinks harry is is because he survived that spell, but what if that spell was not even put on him, what id harry was made into a horcrox or whatever they are called. that would put some of Voldemorts soul in harry, and that would explain why the sorting hat said he would do well in slytherin, why he uses voldemorts wand, why he speaks parsletounge.

also, i dont think dumbledoor is dead, that whole book was about teaching harry you can say one spell and mean another. the killing spell, people die instantly, but doesnt dumbledor float in mid air before dying. and isnt snape on that unbreakable promice to protect draco, i think snape is still good, and he was protecting draco.

there are many other theories but i have thougth of but ill have to re think of them. post some imput if you care to share your ideas or illaberate on mine.

 

[Corny]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

i hope he dies. so that this hype has an end.

 

[PabloZed]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

You are correct that your theories have been floated before. You should know that JK herself has shot them down. I think the previous books answer your first suggestion that Neville is the real heir. I seem to recall that Harry told Dumbledore that perhaps the prophesy was not for him but Neville and Dumbledore replies that that may have been true if Voldemorte had not assumed it was Harry and tried to kill him. That too was part of the prophesy so by choosing Harry Voldemorte made Harry the one.

As for whether Dumbledore is really dead, I too thought that perhaps he was still alive but JK has said publicly that part of the path of the hero is that the mentor must die/pass the batton so that the hero can proceed alone.

I am not sure what the last word on Snape is. I think perhaps it fits into the hero storyline in that Harry as the hero always knew Snape would betray Dumbledore, but Dumbledore's blind faith/love did not allow him to see the truth. So in a sense love and faith was his undoing and I suspect in the final book Harry will have learned this lesson and will not fall victim.

 

[starlight70]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

i think he has to. for he was never the chosen one, neville longbottom really is.

Did you notice that the latter books had been silent on the role of Longbottom being the alt 'chosen one'? It may indicate that Rowling realized that plot led nowhere.

Here's my theory.

Rowling created HP.
Rowling surprised herself with the success.
Rowling happy with the success.
HP success grew.
HP became more famous than Rowling could bear with.
Rowling got jealous of Harry.
Rowling decided to play down HP's fate.
Rowling had a second thought.
Time changed.
Rowling decided not to be nasty with HP.
HP continued.

Seriously, it was entirely up to her to decide. Trust me - from what I could see, I think she's another wacko - wanted to adopt Daniel Radcliffe just because he looked like HP, and got Daniel all caught up - to say no, and offended her.

Is HP gonna live?

It's in that woman's hand.

Whatever she would choose to end it, there could be an article in the future to state that she regretted her action.

Just a theory.

 

[Ohiospeedo]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

When is the next book supposed to come out anyway?

 

[star-warrior]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Maybe they turn everyone gay and then we'll have a wonderful world of magical fairies. Rahter like JUB

 

[starlight70]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Just read from Leaky website. Date is not finalized yet. Maybe 7/7/07.

Anyway, love how the net got HP and RW all gay up. Remember 'UrAnus'?

 

[kurtwild]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

i dont know,i think harry is the chosen one but mabe he ll die in the end.
the book is already sad,i mean serious black is dead
i think the headmaster is really dead,but snape is good.

j.k rollings once said that the last book will end with "the scar on harry head"or something like that,but then i think she said she is not sure bout that.

 

[kurtwild]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

i dont know,i think harry is the chosen one but mabe he ll die in the end.
the book is already sad,i mean serious black is dead
i think the headmaster is really dead,but snape is good.

j.k rollings once said that the last book will end with "the scar on harrys head"or something like that,but then i think she said she is not sure bout that.

i cant wait to read it.
maybe it wants to show tahat there was no chosen one,just 2 kids and voldemort turned harry into the "chosen one" by being scared of him.
we'll see.

 

[kurtwild]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

oh and i really hope that harry wont end up with ginnie,i hate ginnie.
and i hope hermione wont be with ron in the end.she is too good for him.she should become something really good.
and malfoy shouldnt be with anyone either.
i dont like lovestories in harry poter books.

 

[bagley]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

I don't think Harry will die. Perhaps, Harry is the horcrox and will defeat Vodermorte by the sacrifice of his [Harry's] magical power. This would be truly heroic. I think Rawlings has used a lot of "Tolkien" and if you remember , "Frodo" was redeemed in the end by the sacrifice of his ring finger. In the great Northern myth Odin sacrifices his eye for the Runes. Harry Potter will become a shattered but wise human being.

I actually cried when Dumbledore died.

 

[craziwranglerman]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

i came across this site. even though its kinda old it give details (rumors) about the movies and books.

http://www.geocities.com/yl1086/index.html

so far its been accurate.

 

[Kuja]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Half-Blood Prince just turned me off to the series completely. They whole thing felt too easy. Didn't like it at all.

Oh, and Ginny + Harry = My Death. Really. I vomited all over the book when I read the part where Harry kisses Ginny. Grossness. Same for Ron and Hermione. Urgh. I sold all my HP stuff after that. I'll read book seven, just to see how it ends (?). I'll probably just get it at the library or something though.


Harry + Hermione 4EVER!!! Fuck you Rowling!

 

[BigDestiny]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Harry + Hermione 4EVER!!! Fuck you Rowling!

I was hoping I could find someone to explain this to me, because I've looked at the books, and I've looked at the movies, and I don't get where people are getting Harry/Hermione from.

I briefly had a theory that the people supporting this 'ship were all teenaged bookish girls with crazed hair and bad teeth banking their future happiness on saying 'See! Hermione got the hero, so can I.' But obviously, that isn't you (you're clearly over 18, if nothing else), so I'm not sure what's going on.

This isn't meant as a flame, or to be hurtful. I just don't get it. Honestly, I could see Harry/Draco before I could see Harry/Hermione. Hell, I can see Harry/Snape happening first.

 

[Kuja]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

I was hoping I could find someone to explain this to me, because I've looked at the books, and I've looked at the movies, and I don't get where people are getting Harry/Hermione from.

I briefly had a theory that the people supporting this 'ship were all teenaged bookish girls with crazed hair and bad teeth banking their future happiness on saying 'See! Hermione got the hero, so can I.' But obviously, that isn't you (you're clearly over 18, if nothing else), so I'm not sure what's going on.

This isn't meant as a flame, or to be hurtful. I just don't get it. Honestly, I could see Harry/Draco before I could see Harry/Hermione. Hell, I can see Harry/Snape happening first.

Hermione and Harry...they just mesh well together, damn it!!

Ok, there's a difference between the people you're talking about (Shippers) and me.

Those people are convinced that Harry and Hermione will end up together. They believe there is solid proof in the books or movies that proves it.

I on the other hand, know for a fact that Harry will probably end up with Ginny (Vomits), and that my Hermione will end up with Ron (Vomits again). I wont even fight it. But I love the idea of Harry and Hermione having a romantic relationship. I know it'll never happen, but I can still wave my H+H flag high in the air!

So...Harry + Hermione 4EVER!!!!!

I think H/H works a lot more than H/R does.
I know that H/R is the 'official' ship but I really don't see them fitting together at all. It seems kinda forced to me.
Whereas H/H have more of a relationship thats developed on its own.

I think that the movies seem to push this a lot more than the books do though.

I completely agree. Ron and Hermione don't go well together. They have nothing in common. My second choice (After Harry) for Hermione would be Viktor Krum.

 

[BigDestiny]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Hermione and Harry...they just mesh well together, damn it!!

Ok, there's a difference between the people you're talking about (Shippers) and me.

Those people are convinced that Harry and Hermione will end up together. They believe there is solid proof in the books or movies that proves it.

I on the other hand, know for a fact that Harry will probably end up with Ginny (Vomits), and that my Hermione will end up with Ron (Vomits again). I wont even fight it. But I love the idea of Harry and Hermione having a romantic relationship. I know it'll never happen, but I can still wave my H+H flag high in the air!

So...Harry + Hermione 4EVER!!!!!

Ah, so I need to continue my search then, since it was the 'shippers and their solid proof that I was looking for.

Thanks for your quick reply, though. And I agree that if Harry and Hermione ever made a go of it, they really would make a good couple. I think Harry needs someone who is his equal, which is why I like Harry/Cho better in the Goblet of Fire movie than in the Order of the Phoenix novel (which might as well have been titled 'be careful what you wish for'). Cho doesn't seem like she can keep up with Harry, whereas Hermione has already proven that she can.

So, do we have any 'shippers out there with proof they'd like to bring up?

 

[Kuja]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

If you're really interested, try the MuggleNet message boards. They people there can be brutal though.

 

[xyboyms]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

If you're really interested, try the MuggleNet message boards. They people there can be brutal though.

LOL I actually went on there a while ago once and haven't been back since! If anyone thinks people at JUB can get a little......em.....irritable.....they haven't seen anything.

 

[luminum]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Harry + Draco all the way.

But I feel like Harry cannot end the heroes journey as the master of both worlds. It's too strange. I feel like he has to end as a legend. either he disappears forever or he dies. One of the two.

I definitely think Snape's good. There's more to all of this than Snape actually being the evil everyone always thought he was. Or if he IS evil, she didn't do a good enough job convincing us that he was actually fighting for good deep down during the other books.

Half-Blood was kindof disappointing because Snape being the Half-blood kindof meant nothing and finding it out, and Harry's obsessionw ith it really meant so little.

We know that the locket has to be with Mundingus Fletcher since he stole all the stuff from the Black household (and I assume that locket Harry couldn't open was the missing horcrux). Could Nigiri the snake be one? I couldn't remember if they onfirmed that in the last book or not. I remember coming up with at least 4 horcurx theories, but I can't remember them now.

I really hope she can redeem Ron, because right now, he's gone from being bumbling and unsure to just being a plain jack ass int he Hermoine/Ron relationship.

And Harry and Gina came out of nowhere and I think it's a really poor choice if she was trying to match him up with someone.

 

[HarryPotterHimself]

Re: Harry potter 7th book theories, dont read if u dont want to know what could happe

Harry and Ginny was awesome... Harry finally saw something, it'd been there forever. As for the Horcruxes... I think Harry's one. Because----Harry and Voldemort have a connection like Voldemort and Nagini. You dont get that just because of a curse. Harry and Voldemort were in each other's dreams and thoughts, and their touch hurt one another. I think Voldemort fucked up the spell when he tried to kill Harry, "killing" himself instead and making Harry the Horcrux instead of the intended object that was probably close at hand. Also, Voldemort refuses to let his followers kill Harry. Why? Not because he has so much pride as to let that stand in the way of Harry's death, but because if Harry dies, there goes a part of his soul. That's why he wants to deal with Harry himself.