Re: How I Turned A Cute Straight Teen Into A Bisex
Chapter 6, Dedicated To:
skittles, LADIICROFT, DonQuixote, Israel321, Endlessnight500, dneumeier, jake99, lovaboitoy2, gaytxn09, jt1987, and soapin2000
Thanks for the nice feedback guys, and for inspiring me to write this chapter!
Age Of Characters: All of the characters portrayed in this story are 18-years-old.
I know it's hard to keep up with who the characters are when you're following a lot of different stories in this forum, so here's a recap:
Mike: My straight friend who I turned into a bisexual by pressing his dickhead through his pants while we were watching heterosexual videos, and then rubbing his whole dick.
Gary: My straight stepbrother who became bisexual after I finger fucked him while his straight friends watched.
John: The bisexual boy next door who is Gary's best friend.
Jason & Paul: Straight bag boys who are Gary's friends and work with him at the grocery store. They're brothers, and Jason likes to forcibly rub Paul's asshole because it gives him a sense of power. Paul allows him to have his way because he enjoys the anal stimulation. (Paul is the one who gave me a huge hard-on at the store when I saw his pants stuck up in the crack of his ass.)
Although Jason wanted to get a blowjob from me, he thought it'd be too gay to reciprocate by allowing me to finger fuck him. And he was attempting to leave when Gary, still completely nude, grabbed him in a bear hug and wrestled him to the floor.
Since Chapter Five is on page 1, here's the last paragraph of that chapter, which pertains to the expression 'payback is a bitch':
"Good, because I wanted to be the one who said it. It means you get back a lot more than you dished out. And since you finger fucked me for at least ten seconds, that means I get to finger fuck you for at least ten times that long. And to keep it simple, I'll just round it off to an even two minutes. I guess that's where the 'bitch' part of the expression comes in, because you get fucked like a bitch." Gary laughed.
----------------------------------------------------------
"Hmm, it sounds like you should add 'comedian' to your bag boy resume." Jason smirked.
"Wow Gary," John said, "Two minutes is a long time to finger fuck a cute boy like him. It might cause me to cum in my pants while I'm squeezing my dick. I've already got a hard-on just from visualizing him taking your finger up his butt."
"Lemme see." I said as I put my hand on John's crotch and started groping him. After feeling of his scrotum, I focused on just his penis, gently squeezing it through his pants. "Yeah, John clearly has a woody." I laughed.
"If he didn't have one before, he certainly got one after you started feeling him up." Mike laughed.
Smiling, John said, "Ron, I'm definitely looking forward to getting my cock deep in your mouth."
I then put my hand on John's ass and got a good feel of his crack, saying, "And I'm definitely looking forward to sucking it dry while I've got my finger deep in your anus."
John responded by quickly sliding his left hand down by sweatpants and feeling up my ass. This was pretty easy to do since I was shirtless and hadn't taken the time to put any underwear on. As he slid his fingers into my crack and made contact with my anus, I instinctively jerked away before he could penetrate it. My subconscious mind evidently doesn't like to have fingers stuck up my ass when I'm not expecting it. "Damn boy," I laughed, "You're just as horny as I am. Don't worry, you'll get your shot at my asshole after I finger fuck you."
Smiling, John replied, "I think we should just do each other at the same time to make it more interesting."
"That sounds good to me," I grinned, "And watching this straight boy take a finger up his ass is really going to get me in the mood to have one stuck up my ass."
"Damn, you guys need to get a room," Mike joked, "And I'll be a room service dude, standing by your bed in case you need anything, such as a cock to suck on while you're fingering each other."
"Hey Mike, that's a good idea," I said, "As I still haven't finished sucking you off. It looks like I'm going to suck more dicks today than I've sucked all month. It just goes to show that you have to be careful what you wish for, because I've been wishing for some fresh teen meat. And all of a sudden, I'm surrounded by cute teenagers who want to cum in my mouth. Fuck, I feel like I'm in a youthful offender prison! And by the time I check out all of your assholes, I'm going to feel like a prison guard." I laughed.
The four of us were now standing around the two 'combatants,' watching as Gary struggled to keep Jason pinned down. Gary's huge dick was still fully erect, and I couldn't help but reach down and put my hand around it. "Don't mind me Gary, I just need a quick feel of your dick, because watching it while you're in the heat of battle gets me all hot and bothered." I joked as I stroked it for a few seconds.
Laughing, Gary said, "Careful Ron, we wouldn't want to get my precum on the seat of Jason's pants, because when his mother saw the stains, she'd be asking him if he's gay."
As Gary tried to slip his hand down Jason's pants and underwear to get to his anus, Jason laughed and said, "You might as well give it up Gary, because these pants are tight as hell around my waist, and my belt is on tight as well. So there's no way you're going to get your fingers anywhere near my asshole."
As he forcefully pressed the pants into the crack of Jason's ass with his fingers, Gary laughed and said, "That's where my four helpers will come in handy."
"That's not fair!" Jason protested. "And seriously, I'm 100% straight. It'd be different if I was gay, but it's just wrong to hold a straight guy down and stick your finger in his asshole, and then finger fuck him!"
Laughing, Gary replied, "Since I'm getting payback for a finger up my own ass, anything is fair. And I'll use any advantage that's available in order to get access to your asshole, because I think it's only fair for you to feel what it's liked to be finger fucked. After all, you were extremely generous in using your finger to demonstrate to me what it felt like. And besides, I was 100% straight when you fingered me, because that was before Ron changed my sexual orientation. So don't expect me to let you escape from a well deserved finger fucking just because you're straight."
"Whatever," Jason replied, "If you're pervy enough to do it, go ahead and have your fun. Because I'm man enough to take what I dish out."
Laughing, Paul said, "Oh, listen to the poor little bag boy trying to use psychology on Gary in a lame attempt to talk his way out of getting his asshole fingered."
"Jason's right about one thing you guys," Gary said, "There's no way I'm going to be able to get my finger anywhere near his asshole without some help. I'm having trouble just keeping him pinned down. So do you guys want to see him get finger fucked for two minutes, or what?"
"Fuck yeah, there's nothing I'd like to see more!" Paul exclaimed.
"Hell yes!" John said.
"Sounds like fun to me." Mike grinned.
"My dick is already getting hard." I said.
"Cool." Gary replied. "First we need to get him turned over on his back so I can unbuckle his belt and get his pants loose. Mike, would you grab hold of his right leg please. Paul, you hold onto his left leg. Ron, you hold his right arm, and John, you hold onto his left arm."
"Hold on, I'm going to go wash my hands first, I'll be right back." I said.
After I returned and everyone had a secure grip on their assigned limb, Gary climbed off Jason's ass and said, "Okay, go ahead and turn him onto his back now." After thrashing around for at least ten seconds while being turned over, Jason realized he wasn't going to be able to break free, so he simply gave up trying. He had accepted the reality that he was about to be stripped naked and have his asshole finger fucked while everyone watched.
Laughing nervously, he said, "That's okay Paul, you can have your fun holding me down while Gary fingers my hole, but I'm going to have fun with your ass every day from now on. Because instead of just rubbing your asshole, I'm going to be sticking my finger in it. Just like Gary said, payback is a bitch. And even though you think you can prevent me from doing it, you know I'm stronger than you, and that I can keep you pinned down for hours if I wanted to."
"Well gee, thanks for letting me know that brother, because your disclosure justifies me getting my revenge ahead of time." Paul smirked.
"What do you mean by that?" Jason asked in a worried tone.
"What that means is that I'm going to finger fuck you after Gary's finished with you. And since you said you're going to finger me every day, that means I can finger your asshole for as long as I can persuade these guys to hold you down. Maybe even for an hour!" Paul replied.
"Whatever. Have as much fun as you can now, because like I said, I'll be having my fun with you every day. In fact, I'm giving you explicit permission to finger fuck the hell out of my asshole for as long as you want to." Jason said. "Because that'll give me more than enough justification to finger you every day from now on. Got that boy? What I'm saying here is that I WANT you to finger my hole when Gary's finished with me. And if you don't do it, that means you're just a pussy boy who only likes to take it up the ass."
"Wow," I said, "That sure sounds like a challenge to me."
"Damn Jason," Mike said, "You're making my dick hard as hell talking like that."
"Fuck, I can't wait to see this action!" John exclaimed.
Laughing, Paul said, "He's probably just trying to use psychology on me. He's pretty clever, and sometimes it's hard for me to tell when he's trying to con me. But just to be on the safe side, I'll definitely finger his hole when Gary's done with him. Because that'll guarantee that his little psychological scam backfires on his ass."
"It's NOT a scam my little perv brother, I SERIOUSLY want you to finger fuck me so I won't feel guilty about ramming my finger up your ass every day." Jason said.
Laughing, Paul replied, "I can assure you that you're definitely going to get your wish. And it sounds like you have a bad memory, because I already told you that I enjoy having you play with my asshole, and that it sexually arouses me. So you'll just be doing me a favor if you finger fuck my hole every day. In fact, I'll probably jerk off while you're doing it."
Laughing, Jason said, "It sounds like you're the one who's trying to use psychology on me. You think that if you can convince me you like it, I'll lose interest in doing it. But that's just not going to happen. If you REALLY want me to finger your hole every day, I'll get just as much satisfaction from doing it as I would if you hated it. It makes no difference to me one way or another.
And like Mike said, it's not incest on my part since I won't be getting any sexual gratification from it. So if it turns you on to have your brother finger fucking you, there's nothing I can do about that. I'm still going to do what I have to do to show you who's boss. And there's no better way to do that than ram my finger up your ass every day. In other words, you're my puppet, and instead of having my arm up your back, I'm going to have my finger up your butt."
Laughing, Gary said, "Okay, now that you boys have negotiated your finger fucking arrangements, I'll proceed with the unveiling of Jason's wiener." Gary then unbuckled Jason's belt, unbuttoned his jeans, and unzipped his fly.
"Hold on a second Gary," Paul said, "Unbutton his shirt first, and spread it open so his shirttail won't cover up his little pee-pee."
"That's a good idea. Hey Jason, you don't mind if I unbutton your shirt do you." Gary grinned.
"Yes, I mind very much." Jason smirked.
"Great! I was hoping you'd say that, because it makes stripping you that much more fun." Gary said as he pulled Jason's shirttail out of his jeans and started unbuttoning his shirt.
"Whatever turns you on, perv." Jason smiled.
"Oh fuck, that's a nice sexy teen chest you've got there." Gary remarked after pulling his shirt open. Then he got a good grip on the waistbands of his jeans and underwear and said, "Okay Jason, are you ready for me to show everyone your junk?"
"Go for it dude." Jason replied.
With that said, everyone briefly raised Jason off the floor at Gary's request, so he could pull the extremely tight fitting jeans over his ass. Just a few seconds later, Jason's pants and underwear had been pulled down to his knees, exposing his three inch flaccid penis, trimmed pubic hair, and low hanging balls.
Jason was now blushing, obviously feeling self-conscious that everyone was staring at his penis in it's flaccid state. Especially since the guy who just stripped him was also naked, and his foot long dick was still fully erect.
"Oh my," Paul grinned, "Just look at that cute little circumcised cock!"
"Fucktard," Jason replied, "Your cock is the same size as mine."
"That's a joke," Paul laughed, "Mine is almost an inch longer."
"Paul, you know the old saying about talk being cheap." I remarked. "Why don't you pull your dick out and let us be the judge. Jason has recognized the futility of trying to get loose, so Mike can hold onto both of his legs by himself."
Smiling, Paul replied, "No problem," as he relinquished control of Jason's left leg to Mike and unzipped his jeans. After digging around in his boxers, he pulled his dick out and shook it at us before letting it hang outside his fly.
"Hey, that's not fair," Jason said, "He got to shake his cock and loosen it up."
Reaching down and grasping Jason's limp penis with my thumb and fingers, I shook it briefly and let it flop back down. "Happy now?" I asked. That got a good laugh from everyone, including Jason.
"Fuck, that laughing makes me want to take an overdue leak, I'll be right back." Gary said as he headed off to the bathroom.
After looking at the brothers' penises very closely, I said, "Paul, it looks like your dick may be at least half an inch longer, but just to make sure I'm going to measure both of your dicks. John, hold onto both of Jason's arms while I look for my tape measure. And Paul, you come stand over here and be ready in case he tries to break free, because we can't take a chance on whether he's been trying to con us in order to escape Gary's finger."
"Sure." Paul replied. A few seconds later he was standing with his dick hanging above his brother's face, smirking down at him. As Jason stared up at his brother's penis, he said, "You better not start beating your meat above my face boy, or I'll cum all over your face when we get home."
As I was headed back to Gary's room with my tape measure, Gary stepped out of the bathroom with his dick semi-erect and smiled at me. "Hold up a second Gary." I said as I approached him. Putting my hands on his chest, I gently pushed him back into the bathroom.
"What's up?" Gary asked.
Without saying a word, I put my arms around him and proceeded to give him a hug that went far beyond stepbrotherly love. I held my body tightly against his with our dicks pressed together, and began to gently suck and lick his lips. He responded by putting his arms around me and kissing me back, and within a few seconds we were sucking each others' tongues. At this point I slid my left hand onto his bare ass and started feeling of it, and he immediately reached down with both of his hands and pulled my sweatpants down. Then he grasped my now erect penis and started stroking it, while sliding his other hand into the crack of my ass.
I then put my hand in his crack, and we inserted our fingers into each other's assholes at about the same time. Since both of our anuses were already lubed from having been finger fucked earlier, our fingers easily slipped all the way in. Then we started moving them in and out with the same rhythm. I was basically following Gary's lead, whatever he did to my asshole, I did the same to his asshole. And the whole time, our mouths remained pressed together as we continued sucking each other's tongue.
"Um, excuse me." Paul laughed as he stood in the doorway staring at my ass while Gary's middle finger was imbedded deep in my crack. "Sorry to interrupt you two lovebirds, but Mike and John were wondering what happened to you, and Jason keeps talking his shit. Now he's saying that Gary's too straight to finger fuck him, but I can see for myself that he couldn't be more wrong. And we're all dying to see his asshole get penetrated so he'll shut the hell up."
"Well," Gary smiled as he pulled his finger out of my ass and let go of me, "We can't keep the public waiting. Tell them we'll be right there, as soon as we wash our hands."
Chuckling, Paul said, "Okay, but please hurry."
"Um, Ron, you can take your finger out of my asshole now." Gary laughed.
"Oh, sorry, I just got a little carried away." I smiled.
As we washed our hands together while our dicks were fully erect and my sweatpants were still pulled down, Gary said, "Damn, sucking tongues is fun!"
"Yeah," I smiled, "We'll have to do it more often."
"Every night right before you massage my ass sounds good to me." Gary laughed.
"You won't get any arguments from me, at least not about that." I smiled. "And I like the thought of us doing it naked while I'm lying on top of you, with our dicks pressed together."
"I think I fucking love you, stepbro." Gary said.
"I think I fucking love you as well." I said as I leaned over and gave his sexy lips a quick lick.
"I never would have thought in a million years that I'd kiss another guy. And I never would have thought in two million years that I'd love it just as much as I love kissing girls. I don't want to sound lame, but you've opened a whole new world for me, and I don't know how I can thank you enough."
"I know a good way." I smiled.
Laughing, Gary replied, "Don't tell me, let me guess. By giving you a blowjob?"
"Hey stepbro, you're not only a good kisser, you're a good guesser." I smiled. "But all kidding aside, sucking dicks is a major part of being bisexual. And after I get you acclimated to having my dick up your ass every day, I don't think it'll be long before you'll want me to stick it in your mouth once in a while."
"Hmm," Jason grinned as I turned to the towel rack, "I think you may be right."
As I was drying my hands, I suddenly felt the unmistakable sensation of a tongue licking my left ass cheek. And I knew instantly that Gary was licking my ass, which surprised the hell out of me. With my dick throbbing, he then licked my right ass cheek several times. When I turned around, he was on his knees looking up at me with a type of horny expression that I'd never seen on his face before. With my eight inch erect penis just an inch from his mouth, he put his hand around it and started licking my dickhead while continuing to look up at me. Then he focused his eyes on my dick, and started licking the entire shaft as though he had a rapidly melting ice cream cone in his hand.
"That's feeling real good stepbro." I moaned.
Since this was an occasion where action speaks louder than words, he silently inserted my dick in his mouth and started sucking it like girls had probably sucked his dick in the past. After moving his mouth back and forth on it for several minutes, a finger was slipped into the crack of my ass and began firmly massaging my anus. After several minutes of this intense stimulation, my anus was slowly penetrated, and then the finger fucking of my hole began.
After a minute or so of being rhythmically fingered, I felt the unmistakable sensations of my prostate gland being massaged. "Oh fuck Gary, you're right on my prostate gland, that feels so fucking good."
As he pulled my dick out of his mouth, Gary opened his eyes and said, "Huh??" At the same time he let out a loud laugh because he saw John squatted down behind me with a big grin on his face. And he immediately realized that John had been finger fucking my ass without my knowledge.
Before I could open my eyes to see what Gary was laughing at, I heard more laughing behind me. When I turned my head around, I saw Mike, Paul, and Jason standing in the doorway laughing hysterically at me. I was wondering what the hell was so funny about being fingered while getting a blowjob, and that's when I noticed someone squatting down behind me.
When I looked down and saw John grinning up at me with his finger still in my asshole, I realized why everyone was laughing so hard. "Boy, you sure got me good!" I said. "I was 1,000% positive that was Gary fingering my hole. Unfucking believable! You should get some kind of booty bandit award for that. Sneaking up behind someone and massaging their prostate gland while making them think their sex partner is doing it is a pretty good trick."
Laughing, John said, "And I also arranged for our young audience to see the show."
"That's right Ron," Mike said, "Paul couldn't keep a secret and he told us what he caught you and Gary doing in here. So when you guys didn't come out after a few minutes, John slipped up to the doorway and peeped in to see if you were back at it again. Then he came back and told us that Gary was giving you a blowjob. We didn't believe it, so naturally we had to come see for ourselves. And of course, we had to bring Jason with us. He's been very cooperative though, so I think he really does want his brother to finger fuck him after Gary's done with him."
"Your absolutely right, Mike." Jason replied. "I definitely want Paul to finger my hole so I can remind him that 'payback is a bitch' every time he whines about me ramming my finger up his ass."
"Did you guys already get to see Jason's ass?" I asked.
"No," Paul said, "He's shy about people seeing his ass. He pulled his underwear and pants back up while he was still lying on the floor."
Laughing, Gary said, "Well, he's sure going to have to get over his shyness when we get his ass back in my room. I'll finish sucking your dick later Ron, or we can just do a 69 on my bed. Right now, I'm dying to get my finger up Jason's ass."
"I love 69's, and doing it with my cute stepbrother is going to be the best one yet." I said. "Okay John, you can remove your finger from my anus now and wash your hands."
"Alright Ron," John said as he started finger fucking me again while everyone laughed, but could you please bend over and spread your cheeks apart so I can remove it in a more professional manner."
Laughing, I asked, "Who do you think you are, a doctor?"
"Actually, that's exactly right. I've been fantasizing that I'm a perv doctor giving a cute teen patient a prostate exam, and a doctor would never pull his finger out of a patients ass while he was standing upright. So please bend over to avoid ruining my fantasy."
"Yeah Ron, bend over and spread those cheeks." Jason said. "I want to get a closeup look at your asshole since you're going to be seeing mine."
"Okay Jason, I'll do it for you." I responded.
"Fuck, I want to see this also." Gary said as he stepped around behind me.
"Me too." Paul said.
Within just a few seconds, everyone was sitting down on the floor around John. Then I bent over and spread my cheeks apart as far as possible to give them a good look at my asshole while John continued fucking it with his finger.
"Wow, that's a really sexy looking asshole," Gary said, "I sure wish my dick was small enough to fit in it."
"Damn, this is getting me hard." Mike said.
"Um, excuse me John," I said, "But didn't you want me to bend over so you could remove your finger from my asshole in a 'professional manner?' Instead, you've just continued finger fucking me."
"I'm just getting your anus loosened up so I can check your prostate gland one last time to make sure I haven't missed any pre-cancerous conditions." John said as he reached around with his other hand and started fondling my scrotum and throbbing penis.
"Oh fuck," I said, "Now you're getting my prostate just right again. Wow John, you really know how to turn a guy on. Oh fuck! That feels so good!"
"Just call me Doctor Perv." John laughed.
"This is unreal." I said. "Jason was the one who was supposed to be getting finger fucked. Instead, everyone is crowded around watching my asshole get fingered."
"And I'm loving this." Jason laughed.
"That's okay, your turn is coming." Gary laughed.
As John was jacking me off while he continued rubbing my prostate, Gary went back around and kneeled in front of my crotch, moving John's hand to my balls. Then he put my dick in his mouth and started sucking and tonguing it as John massaged my scrotum.
In between moans, I said, "Oh fuck, this feels unbelievable. I'm fixing to cum any time now, I hope you're ready Gary." Then I let go of my buttocks and stood upright, grabbing the sides of Gary's head and holding it firmly to my dick. I was determined for him to swallow every drop of my cum even if he hadn't planned on it. As I felt that he needed to be broken in properly so he'd know what it was really like to be bisexual. Then it happened, as my asshole tightened up on John's finger, my cum trigger was pulled and I started shooting one load of cum after another in Gary's mouth.
When I was finally finished cumming, I let go of Gary's head and he pulled my dick out of his mouth, licking the last drops of cum from my dickhead. Then he put it back to his lips and kissed it, saying, "Damn, that was nice, I really liked it. I can see now why so many gay guys are addicted to sucking dicks."
"Hey stepbro, we can do a 69 every night, and then I can butt fuck you in the mornings while you're bending over your underwear drawer." I grinned.
Jason, who had been sitting by Gary silently watching as he sucked me off, said, "That was quite a show Gary, you're a damn good cocksucker. You can suck my cock any time you want to. I'd love to shoot my cum down your throat."
"Same here," Paul chimed in, "You can blow me anytime."
"And you can rest assured that if you blow them, you're definitely going to have to suck me off." John laughed. "And since I live right next door to you, I can sneak in your window every night and fuck you in the mouth when Ron is finished with you."
"John, Ill be glad to loan my stepbro out to you every night if you'll let me butt fuck you while he's sucking you off." I laughed.
"Sounds hot as hell. But I've never been fucked before, so you'll have to break me in slowly." John said.
"Since I apparently love sucking off cute 18-year old males, I'll probably be taking you guys up on that offer." Gary laughed.
"Okay John," I said as I bent over and spread my cheeks again, "You can go ahead and REALLY remove your finger from my asshole now."
"Alright," John said as he pulled his finger out of my hole, "I've determined that your prostate gland is in excellent health."
As I turned around and pulled my sweatpants back up, I was surprised to see Mike standing there with his erect penis in his hand and a glazed look on his face.
Noticing my reaction, Paul said, "He was jerking off the whole time John was finger fucking you."
"Ron, I need you to pull your pants back down and bend over again so I can butt fuck you." Mike said. "I got seriously turned on while I was watching John finger you, and I need to stick my cock in your hole and pound your ass really bad, right NOW. Sorry to do this to you when you may not be in the mood to get fucked after having just gotten your rocks off, but at least we'll see how committed you are to being my sex slave."
