Re: I Thought I Knew
Chapter 29 – Part V
From Billy’s viewpoint
It was decided. Now I suddenly felt really awkward. I was going out there to have sex with my best bud. To fuck him. Take his cherry. To show him what it felt like to have a hard cock up your ass.
It also felt really exciting. Because I knew how it felt when Justin buried his cock in my ass. How it gave me a certain power over him. The power to pleasure him. The power to get him hot and hard like nothing else could. The power to make him cum. Cum deep inside me.
Now I was going to let Jess know the power and the pleasure of being fucked. Only it was going to be my cock up his ass. He was going to have the power over me. The power to pleasure me. To make me cum. Cum deep inside of him. I hoped to fuck he loved it as much as I do.
Awkward and exciting. And weird, too. Weird after all we’d been through. It was like there was so much baggage between us.
I was so mixed up over what was about to happen, I wasn’t even hard when Justin and I stepped back into the bedroom.
But it was important to me that this be a great fucking experience for Jess. I saw that as my No. 1 job. Jess was my best bud. I wanted everything to be cool between us. I suppose that since I was gay, I really wanted Jess to be gay, too. I thought that if I could do a good enough job of making him really enjoy being fucked, it would help convince him he was gay. Help our friendship. Help him. Help convince him he really was gay.
I’m not stupid. I know some guys are tops and some are bottoms. But making this be a really great first fuck for him as the catcher . . . that’s what I was thinking just then. Maybe it wasn’t the smartest thing I ever thought, but, I’m being honest, that’s where my head was.
Jess was sitting on Justin’s bed when Justin and I walked back in.
“OK,” I said to Jess, “I’ll do it for you.” It sounded all wrong as soon as I said it. I didn’t want it to sound so much like I was doing him some huge favor. I should sound like I was excited to be having sex with my best bud. I mean, Jess is a hot guy.
“Ah, Billy,” Jess said, clearing his throat. “I don’t mean to hurt your feelings or anything, but I was really asking Justin. I’m sorry. I just think it would be too hard to relax with you and enjoy it. We’ve been through too much. But,” and Jess started to laugh, “I am flattered that you would say yes. That’s so cool.” And he stood up and hugged me. Hard.
“So you want Justin,” I said, trying to give it a little swagger or something to hide my disappointment. “He’ll show you a better time than I ever could have anyway. He’s really good at it. I can speak from experience. He’s a great fucker.”
What happened during the next few minutes is kind of hazy. Justin asked Jess some questions about how he wanted to do it – doggy style or whatever. Stuff like that.
And they decided not just to jump right into it. It started off with Justin giving Jess a massage. Naked, of course. Both of them. But Justin doesn’t give the best massages and so, of course, I offered to help. Before long, we were a naked pile of guys rubbing oils into each other’s bodies. Playing with each other’s hard cocks. It was amazing how fast the awkwardness melted away among friends. Real friends.
Finally Justin had maneuvered Jess on to all fours and was loosening up his asshole with a few fingers and a lot of fucking lube. His was using his own pre-cum, of course. Jess was obviously getting into it. Groaning and tossing his head around. Pushing his ass back toward Justin’s probing fingers.
Meanwhile, I was massaging Jess’ shoulders and soon was also nuzzling at his neck. Chewing on his fucking ear. Rubbing my head against his head, sort of like wild animals at play. It was very sexual. I was getting really turned on. I’d never done anything quite like this before.
I heard Jess make a strange guttural sound and looked down his back toward Justin. I was surprised to see Justin already had his nine-inch cock in hand and was pushing it into Jess’ ass. I don’t think he’d done more than a little probing, but Jess was already struggling.
I nuzzled in again and told Jess to relax. And once he relaxed, push his ass out. It would be easier that way.
Justin took his time. Slowed down. Worked Jess’ asshole with his fingers some more. Jess hung in there like a trooper. And soon enough, Justin had his cock in hand again and in no time at all his cockhead had popped in.
When it happened it was so clear in my mind what Jess must be experiencing. The feeling. The pressure. The stretched ass muscles. The heat. The same sensations were surging through every sensor in my sphincter. It was like Justin was fucking me.
Jess took it better than I thought and quickly the two were pushing Justin’s cock deeper and deeper into Jess’ ass. It was really happening and I was watching. God, it was fucking hot to see my boyfriend’s cock disappearing up my best bud’s ass. Watching Justin’s powerful thrusts. Hearing Jess’ guttural moans. The whole room seemed to fill with sex. Boy-on-boy sex. Cock-up-the-ass sex. Hot! Hot! Hot sex!
After they had a rhythm going, I was so turned on I needed some sort of something. God fucking damn. Something. Anything. I just need to be part of what was happening. And so I asked Jess if it was OK if I got under him and sucked his cock while Justin fucked him.
He didn’t exactly say yes, but the groaning sounds he made seemed to me to say it was OK. So I got on my back, my legs hanging over the side of the bed. My head under Jess’ groin. I raised my head toward his rigid cock. I licked the length of his shaft. Tasting his pre-cum. Smelling it. Smelling him. His heat. I opened my mouth and took in his hard cockhead. I started to suck.
It was awkward, sucking him from the side this way. It wasn’t what I was looking for.
Instinct took over. I told both Jess and Justin to spread their legs apart more. On my back, I scooted my head between Jess’s legs and Billy’s legs, too. I pushed my head into position to reach Jess’ cock and his nuts. I just sort of pushed the guys around until they each opened their legs wider so I could get even better access to Justin’s nuts, too. And then I just started slurping on their balls. Jess’ and Justin’s. Licking, Slurping. Sucking. Chewing. Going from one to the other. I could tell when I was getting it just right, because they would stop their thrusting and fucking to let me do my thing. To add to their pleasure.
As I slurped on their nuts, I was drawn more and more by Justin’s cock as it rocked in and out of Jess hole. My face was right there. The view wasn’t so good that close to the action. All just sort of a dark blur of cock and balls and pubic hair. But I could smell them both. The pre-cum. The sweat. The pure sex. I could feel the heat coming off of them. My nose was right there with my tongue and my lips and my hungry mouth. Right there with their cocks and balls and writhing sex.
I stuck my tongue out and started licking Justin’s cock as it pulled out of Jess’ ass. It was coated in with the taste and smell of Jess’ ass and Justin’s pre-cum. Justin must have liked having me lick his cock as he fucked Jess. He paused occasionally while I lubed his shaft with my saliva. I tasted Justin’s pre-cum smeared across the length of his enormous and beautiful cock. That sweet taste mixed with the tastes of Jess asshole. I was in heaven.
Soon Justin was shoving his cock back deep into Jess ass. Along with a bit of the saliva from my own mouth. Shoving it all in Jess’ ass. Leaving me to lick Justin’s nuts as his cock disappeared, forced deep into Jess. Pushing his cock in so deep that there wasn’t even a bit of his shaft exposed. He was buried to the hilt.
But that left Justin’s nuts nestled beside Jess’. Hanging there for me to feast on. And I enjoyed the fucking daylights out of them.
And so it went, as Justin pulled out and paused. And pushed back into Jess’ willing asshole. I licked and sucked cock and nuts. Even rimming Jess’ asshole as Justin’s hard, hot cock plowed in and out of it. I tried to force my tongue in beside Justin’s cock. Sort of double fucking Jess the way Justin always talked about. Only now it was Justin’s mammoth hard cock and my slippery tongue both probing Jess’ asshole. Together. This was so fucking hot!
Jess was groaning. Justin was groaning. I knew they were gonna fucking cum soon. I wanted to catch Justin’s cum flowing out of Jess’ hot, stuffed asshole. Into my mouth. Onto my face.
Justin’s hips were making a series of slow but determined thrusts, plowing his cock deep into Jess’ bowls. I was licking Justin’s balls when I felt them pull up tight. I knew it was almost time. As Justin pulled his cock out so just his cockhead remained in Jess’ butt, I ran my tongue the length of his bulging urethra, flicking the tip of my tongue at the sensitive base of his cockhead.
He groaned and plunged into Jess again. This time pushing and pushing and pushing to bury his cock as deep as possible. Jess was pushing back. My tongue was playing where the two met.
And then Justin came. With a deep guttural sound from within, he tensed and then shuddered and pushed deep one more time. I was wildly lapping at Jess’s stretched asshole. And soon I was treated to the first tastes of Justin’s cum. Leaking out from around Justin’s spasming cock.
The smell. The taste. The heat. The closeness of it all. I was right there partaking of the their fucking feast.
We stayed like that for a short time. But I knew what Justin would do next. What he would have done if he were fucking me. And sure enough, Justin straightened up with his arms wrapped around Jess’ chest, pulling Jess up with him. They were both kneeling now. Justin with his amazing nine-inch cock buried in Jess’ virgin ass.
Jess’s cock was now left jutting up straight in front of him. I scooted out from under them. Flipped over on my hands and knees. Jess’ hard, dripping cock was an easy target for my hungry mouth. I slid Jess’ cock deep down my throat. He gasped. Justin kept on thrusting. His hands firmly pulling Jess’ hips into him now so that he could leverage each thrust for best effect.
I could tell Jess was about to lose it. I started pulling on his nuts as I sucked his cock. I could feel his cock swell and get hotter. He was about to pop. I buried his cock even deeper down my throat, almost making me gag.
Jess groaned once again. He looked over his shoulder at Justin and said in a deep voice, “Oh, fuck! Thanks. Thanks for cumming in me. Up my ass.”
With those last words to Justin, Jess unloaded a huge surge of warm, slimy cum into my mouth. The taste was so strong. So sexy. So completely Jess. Some of his cum went straight down my throat, but I was able to pull back enough to capture a full mouthful. Some of Jess’s cum dripped out the sides of my mouth and down my neck. It felt so warm and slippery on my tongue, coating my teeth, dripping from the corners of my mouth.
With Jess still cumming in powerful blasts, I rose up on my knees so my head was even with his and kissed him with open mouth. Sharing his cum with him. His throbbing cock was still spurting cum, coating my chest and abs his with goo. His tongue ran wild in my mouth. Playing in his own warm cum. Inviting it into his mouth.
Justin was watching us. His cock still buried deep in Jess. Our kiss seemed to prolong Justin’s orgasm.
“Fucking hot ass,” he muttered and thrust deeply into Jess one last time. His breathing was a ragged effort. His hips now still. His cock deep in Jess’ ass. I could smell their cum. Sweet and familiar.
The sensation of it all was almost enough to trigger my own orgasm without anyone even touching my dick. But I wanted to hold on.
Jess, his mouth now full of his own cum fresh from my mouth, looked back over his shoulder. Justin leaned forward and kissed him deeply. Sucking in this load of Jess’ cum. From Jess’ cock. To my mouth. To Jess’ mouth. To Justin’s. The circle was complete.
Jess turned back to me and stared into my eyes. His face seemed almost ecstatic with the pleasure of it all. I felt really good about what we had just done.
Jess flashed me his special smile and said, “Now you.” Those were his only words.
It was enough. Justin and I both knew what he meant. Unexpected as it was, it somehow seemed quite natural at this very moment.
Justin pulled his still hard cock from Jess’ ass. I could hear Jess’ ass pop shut. I moved around to take Justin’s place. I needed no preparation. After Justin’s cock, Jess’ ass could easily handle mine. Hard and horny as I was, I just grabbed my aching cock and thrust all eight-plus inches of it right in as far as it would go.
I couldn’t believe the sensation. My cock encased in Jess’ really hot ass. Justin’s cum lubing the way. The thought that I was fucking this ass. My best bud’s ass. This ass still filled with Justin’s cum. My boyfriend’s cum. It was an amazing turn-on. And the fact that it was Jess’ ass. And I could still taste his fresh cum in my mouth. And see my boyfriend going down on Jess’s still hard cum-covered cock.
I wasn’t going to last long. The warmth. The squishy tightness. The smells. The sight of Justin sucking Jess cock down to its pubes.
Jess was groaning again. I was groaning again. Only Justin, his mouth too full of Jess’s cock, was relatively quiet.
Then I felt Jess’ ass muscles tighten. He was cumming again. I knew he was pumping his load into my boyfriend’s mouth. I couldn’t believe it. But his spasms were undeniable. And irresistible. As he came, I came. My cum poured into his ass. After Jess’ load, there just wasn’t room. Cum was flowing back out of Jess’ ass with every thrust I made. My nuts. My legs. All covered in cum. My cum. Justin’s cum. Mingled here in Jess’ ass. Flowing out in triumph. Our triumph. We had done this for Jess. Fucking how hot was this!
Now Justin was getting to his knees. Kissing Jess. Returning to Jess his own hot cum. Then Jess turned and shared his mouthful of cum with me. Jess broke our kiss and I swallowed his cum.
Jess he reached down and took Justin’s still hard cock in his hand and began to pump it. Three strokes and Justin was shooting cum all over all three of us. It was like it was raining cum and we were getting soaked in it again.
They had each cum twice in a matter of minutes and I had just had the cum of my life. We were each exhausted.
We collapsed onto the bed, our arms and legs and torsos intertwined. We lay as we fell for five minutes or more. No one moved. No one spoke. The mingled cum covering us was both slippery and sticky. Warm. But cooling. Our breathing still ragged. Our sweat covered bodies totally spent. I could feel the warmth of both Jess’ and Justin’s bodies pressing against mine. Could hear their hearts beating. Feel their heat. Their spent lust.
“Fucking amazing,” I finally said.
“I never would have guessed,” Justin said.
We both looked at Jess, waiting to hear what he would say. Hoping to hear him say . . . What exactly? I wasn’t sure. I was just hoping for the best.
Jess smiled at each of us, giving me that special smile he’d always saved for me.
He got to his knees and looked down at the two of us. “Thanks, guys. That was a lot to ask. You’re the best friends a guy could ever have. And thanks to you, now I think I know.”
With that he got up and started to dress, pulling on his jeans and shirt over his body still covered in gooey cum. On his face. In his hair. Covering his chest and abs. Soaking through his clothes in blotchy wet spots.
We each tried several times to ask Jess what it was he knew, but each time he turned our questions away, saying simply, “Not now, please. I need some time to think.” And as he finally reached Justin’s door to go, he turned to us and said, “I’ll always remember this moment. And you. Both of you. Each of you. Forever. Thank you.” And he left.
To be continued . . .
--
I hope you enjoyed this next to last part of our final chapter. I suspect some of you have a lot of questions and a little clean up to take care of. But you've got plenty of time for both. I'll post the last bit of the story later this week.
Be sure to let us know what you think of this project. The comments have been so good lately. And remember, if you haven't rated this story yet, now would be a good time to go to the top right of the screen and rate it. Thanks for reading. Until next time, stay happy. And stay hard.
HR... just when I tought I could figure the ending of this story, the twist came & cum BIG TIME! 
). I'm discovering myslef. At first my feelings kind of freaked me out, but after reading your story every night for what felt like hours at a time, I feeling more relaxed about it all now. It give me a feeling that I hadn't had before, I felt that I wasn't alone. Where I am, and at my school, there aren't a lot of gay guys that I can learn something from, but I have been learning something about myself from you. Your story has helped me a lot lately, but there isn't any one thing in paticular that I can put into words(besides helping me get my rocks off from time to time 
). 
