MERGED: All things Gay Incest

[theworldwithout]

Just the thought of sex with my brother makes my skin crawl...
I've seen the incest porn out there, but I just can't watch it. It's just way too wrong for me.

 

[CGHJ]

Frankly, I doubt he really gives a damn. I think anyone who judges someone on something so irrelevant..

You are correct THA is totally entitled to his opinion, both of me and brother-on-brother sexcapades. But he is called TheHandsomeAsshole lol...and I don't think either one of us is gonna miss out from not having sex with each other. I think we probably move in different circles anyway. I do have to admit I'm curious what he could have said that would be so bad it would have got him banned, just because I'm sure it was creative

 

[denverbear42]

hence the name inhbis moniker "asshole" how pompous are you

 

[miaplacidus]

I don't have any brothers. However, I think that my cousin is really hot, and I would probably want him if he wasn't so full of himself.

I don't think sex between brothers is wrong. It is just that... sex.

 

[Paul-1985]

As someone pointed out in an earlier post, this topic comes up on JUB every few months.

The interesting thing is that views vary dependent on which forum the topic of "brotherly love" is raised. Here, on Hot Topics, everyone is disgusted with the idea.

Go over to the "Adult Area" of JUB (Twinks, Jocks and Hunks, for example) and there are quite a few threads where people are totally turned on by the thought of sex between bros (especially twins!) The views on that forum could'nt be more different to the ones below!

 

[lavacock]

That's a very... inconsistent viewpoint.

what can i say? i'm a complicated guy.

 

[fuzzy64]

OMG--- the responses to incest sex crack me up, especially the "ewwww gross" comments, it sounds like im back in school with a bunch of little kids--grow up..........

yes if I had some hot fratboy looking brother, (or any brother) and he wanted to fool around--sure I would, whats the big deal, its sex, nothing more-- and if both parties are consenting then what the hell does it matter.

---------------------------------------------------------

TheHandsomeAsshole ----- I think that many gay men have a form of mental illness that makes them think that aything is valid to satisfy their sexual urges. There are straight men who are like this too, but not as many as the gay guys. Having sex with the brother? Ok. Sucking of a drunken straight friend without his consent? Ok. Having sex with underage kids? Ok as long as you don't get caught. I'm seriously thinking of leaving because the lack of morality of many guys here is appalling.

here, let me hold the door open for you...........

 

[Eternaldarkness]

honestly, gay incest is a fetish to some. Like all other fetishes, some loves it, other dislikes it.

Thats basically it. If it not your fetish, then don't seek for it. It is okay to give your opinion and say you dislike the idea. It is NOT okay to say "that it is simply wrong" or people need to get their head examine if they do so. C'mon, grow up!

Respect other people's sexual interest, please! There are a lot of fetishes out there that I do not find any interest at all. What I try to do is not to look for it and avoid it, rather than questioning other's why and how come or calling them names. Even if its not my taste, I still have to respect others and try not to offend them.

 

[operafan]

I think it is hot in theory - at the Bartok brothers fucking each other is one of my favorite scenes - but reality is quite different.

 

[duroc5088]

For gods sake. there are men out there eating each others poop, and we are worried about brothers having sex??????

who are we to judge anyone?

 

[Eternaldarkness]

hehehe... duroc5088, that makes me laugh. yes, I agree.

 

[G-Lexington]

The very first gay video I ever got was a gift. It was a "compilation" video of scenes from a particular director's work. One of the scenes was from a video called Brothers Should Do It - to this day, a hilariously bad title. I quite liked that particular scene, which did in fact feature the supposed brothers having sex. I don't think I liked it BECAUSE they were brothers (or could have been), but simply because it was precisely what I like to see in a gay sex scene - they both looked horny as hell, and looked like they wanted nothing more than to fuck each other's brains out.

Were they brothers? No idea. My guess is yes. They were both tall, blonde, and a bit lanky, and had very similar facial features. Thank God one of them had a tattoo, or I wouldn't have been able to keep them straight (as it were).

Why do some people find sibling sex hot? For the same reason a lot of people find it unnerving - it crosses some boundaries. An element of danger (or "naughtiness") makes sex hotter. Having sex outside, or somewhere where you might get "caught". Going on the sly to have sex with someone you shouldn't, like an ex. Meeting up with someone for anonymous sex. All of these scenarios are common in porn, because they add an element of danger/naughtiness to the sex, and that makes it hotter to a lot of people.

Lex

 

[smile86]

meh, if brothers want to screw each other that's their business. i don't think i'd ever have sex with my brother even if he was a gay stud because it'd be wierd. in the same way i wouldn't fuck my best friend because we grew up together and to me the idea is not a turn on, even though he is bisexual and attractive.

 

[Eternaldarkness]

true. Porn do try to add these scenarious for fullfillment. Some of these things you don't dare to do in real life, so it is so much hotter to see someone else acting your fantasy out for you.

 

[MRMATTX2]

As long as they are both consenting adults, I see no problem with any two men enjoying sex - including brothers. Personally, I don't have a brother - and have never been in a 3 way with two brothers - but I'd have no problem doing so.

 

[Jay.Jay]

This thread is quite depressing - we've had some outrageously offensive declarations, like:

Having sex with the brother? Ok. Sucking of a drunken straight friend without his consent? Ok. Having sex with underage kids? Ok as long as you don't get caught

from someone who apprently can't tell the difference between consenual sexual activity, sexual assault, and statutory rape and / or pedophilia - a view which is apparantly not unique:

I'm waiting for someone to say that rape is OK as long as one of the parties involved enjoys it.

Then, we've had a whole bunch of "I find it gross so it's wrong" arguments, made in apparent blissful ignorance that this is essentially the argument for sodomy laws and much homophobia. We've also had "it's incest and that's illegal so its wrong" arguments - which also echo the sodomy law argument. On the flip side, we've had a whole bunch of live-and-let-live arguments, some sufficiently nuanaced to recognise that such a position is only tenable within boundaries.

As far as I can see, we have yet to have a rational, cogent argument put for the 'it's wrong' position - surely someone can offer a considered position, rather than a gut reaction?

BY the way, to pre-empt the questions: Yes, I have a brother. No, I wouldn't have sex with him.

 

[aadams990]

To each his own. I wouldn't sleep with a brother if I had one, but like I said. To each his own. We all disagree with many things, but who are we to judge? Really.

 

[G-Lexington]

Well, incest is illegal in most (all?) US states, partially because there are genetic reasons to keep siblings from reproducing. (Gotta keep the gene pool open or it goes stagnant, dontcha know.) These rationales obviously go by the wayside when it comes to same-sex siblings, so not sure what the rationale would be there.

Lex

 

[snoopydog]

I have 5 brothers. I have 1 younger brother. I am 1 of (so far) 3 gay male siblings.

And I have to say that, for me, brotherly love has it's limit...

 

[Ninja108]

Brotherly love has its limits. Incest is a big no no to me