Please Henry, May I Have The Straight Guy

[JRandell69]

I suddenly found myself in a nightmare. But I'm wide wake I thought. I'm really here. I'm really here chained to a metal chair with both my hands handcuffed behind me. How could this be? My young innocent friend Trey was sitting right next to me. He too was in the same terrible situation, bound to a metal chair. We were in a somewhat dark room with brick walls all around us. To our right sitting at a table in the corner was a large muscular black man wearing a mask. He was sitting there quietly reading a book. A few candles were burning on the small table he was sitting at. The place was quiet. We could hear nothing. Trey and I started to struggle hard to get loose, but had no luck at all.

"What the fuck is this shit," Trey asked looking at me? Of course I had no answer. He then looked over at the masked black man and shouted, "Hey man, what the fuck is this?! What the fuck do you want?! Let us go! We didn't do anything! Hey! You hear me?!"

The man just sat there without moving or anything and continued reading his book quietly. "Oh God, this is bad," I quietly said to Trey. "This is really bad." My heart was beating fast. Deep down I knew that people rarely get out of situations like this.... alive.

I had no idea where the hell we were. All I remember is sometime earlier I was at a bar downtown chatting with this really hot young girl I just met tonight named Bethany. I'm not exactly the monk of the month, you see, hooking up with girls and having one nightstands is a common thing for me, since I'm a fairly attractive guy or at least that's what I've been told anyway. Bethany told me I was hot and seemed very interested in getting to know me better. I told her my name was Chris. I was single, and I was thirty-one years old. I actually told her a great deal about myself, but she was a little evasive on telling me much about herself. She was somewhat of a mystery lady, but I didn't care. I was drawn to her. We danced for a while, laughed, and chatted together. I really thought I just might be going home with this chick tonight.

She kept on insisting on buying me a beer. Finally I said okay. Just as she was about to head off to the bar, my old college buddy Trey walked up and said hello to me. I introduced him to Bethany, and so she smiled and offered buy us both a drink. As she left to get the drinks I chatted with Trey a bit catching up on things. Trey was about the same age as me, well built with somewhat long messy brown hair, nice blue eyes, nice smile, and had some facial hair going on. For a guy, Trey was pretty hot and masculine. I thought he might even try to steal Bethany away from me, but I felt a little less worried when he told me he had a serious girlfriend, but she had to work tonight, and so he was just out on his own. "I started to not even go out tonight," he told me. "But then I thought ah what the hell." After a while, Bethany returned with two draft beers. The three of us sat there laughing and chatting with one another and then....well that's the last thing I remember. All I know is that Bethany must have put something in our drinks and here we were sitting in this strange room chained to these cold metal chairs. We could be in another freaking country for all I know.

Suddenly, the door to our left opened with a loud squeak. And to my surprise, what looked to be a young teenage kid somewhere around the age of 18-21 stepped inside the doorway wearing a nice comfortable looking gray bathrobe. He too had a mask on, which was covering the top part of his face.

"Hello gentlemen," he politely said to us. "Sorry to keep you waiting. My name is Henry. I'll be right with you in just a moment. Just make yourself comfortable."

Henry turned back around stepped outside the doorway with his back to us and begin to talk with some guy standing outside the room, that I could not yet see. "So that picture that I texted you of that guy named Chris, you said you were happy with him?"

"Yes sir," the guy replied.

"Well good news. We got him. He's here."

"Oh great. He's perfect. Just what I want."

"Okay, well no problem, but there is just one little thing. His buddy showed up out of nowhere, and well long story short, he's here too, and uh.....," Henry turned and looked at Trey and I for a moment and then back at the unknown man and said,"And I must say, he's not bad looking either."

"Well, I can only afford Chris, sir."

"Okay I understand. I just wanted to let you know why there's two men in there."

"But..... since this very unfortunate thing happened........ Can I have his buddy too, sir?"

"Hmmmmm."

"Please Henry....... Pretty please."

"Well uh..... Well lets step inside and meet them and see what you think. Come on in, David."

Henry stepped inside the doorway and made room for the gentleman to enter. A young gentleman who looked to be in his mid twenties stepped inside the room, looked at Trey and I, and smiled a little naughty smile. He however was not wearing a mask. He had green eyes, buzzed brown hair that was somewhat receding. He was a little overweight but not too much as of now. He was neatly dressed in a red dress shirt, black pants, and black tie. To me, he looked like he might be a rich college student.

He slowly followed Henry over to us. Henry stood there in front of us with his arms crossed. The young gentleman stood next to Henry looking at Trey and I like we were yummy dessert. "So David," Henry said. "What do you think of these two?"

"They're both very hot, sir. Older and masculine. I like that."

"That's Chris and that's Trey," Henry said pointing at each of us. "Gentlemen, this is my new friend David," Henry said as he placed his hand on the young man's shoulder. "David is still a virgin. He came to me not long ago with a simple request. He wanted to fuck a straight guy. So....here we are. And we're going to make David very happy aren't we? It's very simple. You do what David says or me and my friend Butch, who I'm sure you've already met, he's sitting right over there, is going to beat the living shit out of you. And we don't want that, do we? So just do as you're told and we will all have a great time. Understand? Great."

Henry then smiled at us. Even though the mask was covering his head and the top part of his face, I could still see his mouth, and I'll have to admit, Henry had a nice mouth. He also had a very nice smile when he smiled. "So," Henry continued. "With that said, David....which one do you want first?"

"Wow, I get both, sir?"

"You get both, my friend."

"Gee I don't know. They're both very hot."

"I'll tell you what, I'll flip a coin for you okay? Heads Trey. Tails Chris."

"Okay sir."

Henry takes a coin out of his pocket. He flips in the air and accidently drops it on the floor. "Ah shit, " he said. "Sorry about that. Let me flip it again." He bent down and picked it up. He was about to flip it again, and then he showed it to David and said, "Anyway, that's what it landed on. Are you happy with him or should I flip it again?"

"I'm very happy with him," David said smiling.

"Are you sure?"

"Fine with me, sir?"

"Well.... I'll tell you what just let me flip it again, cause I dropped the damn thing on the floor and I really didn't mean to. Anyway, heads Trey. Tails Chris."

Henry flips the coin again, catches it this time, slaps it down on the back of his left hand, peaks at it, and then shows it to David. "Well," he said. "That's who it's going to be."

"I'm very happy with him, sir. He's a bit hotter anyway."

"Wonderful," Henry said smiling again with his attractive smile. "Lets get this party started."

TO BE CONTINUED

 

[JRandell69]

Henry made eye contact with me and smiled. I lowered my head thinking Oh Fuck. He then said,"It's heads."

Trey started to struggle some. He looked over at Butch and said,"Lets get him down in the dungeon and get his clothes off, please Butch." Butch walks over to Trey, unlocks the chain that was holding him to the chair, grabs Trey, and begins to drag him off into the dungeon.

"No please stop," Trey said. "Henry please. Please don't make me do this. Please."

"Ah you'll like it," Henry said.

"Henry please no."

"Be quiet or you're going to get slapped."

Butch escorted Trey through a doorway that was to the right of me, down some stairs, and into a dungeon or basement. I wasn't sure what kind of room it was, because I couldn't see inside. Henry slowly followed them through the doorway. David started to follow as well. As David walked past me he said as he gently touched the side of my face with his hand,"I guess you know who's next, huh pretty boy?"

David then exited through the doorway. I was alone in the room for the first time looking
around not knowing what to do. I could hear some commotion going on in the dungeon. I assume the three of them were removing Trey's clothes. Poor Trey. I then heard Henry say, "Damn David, he's got a nice thick cock."

"He does," David said. "It's a good thing I'm going to be the one on top, cause that might hurt a little."

Gee... I thought to myself. Trey must a have a nice cock. I wonder what it looks like. What he looks like naked. I know he must have a nice furry body. David's probably touching him right now and running his hands all over him. All through his chest hair. But so what?! What's the matter with me?! Why am I thinking this shit right now? I need to be thinking about escaping. Not about Trey's naked body and cock.

After a while, Butch and Henry came back up the stairs and into the room with me. Butch returned to his small table in the corner and continued reading his book. Henry took the chair Trey was sitting in, placed it in front of the doorway leading down into the dungeon, so he could watch everything taking place with David and Trey. As Henry sat there, he lit up a cigarette, and began to smoke it. I wasn't sure what to say. I was pretty sure that Henry would tell me to shut the fuck up if I did say something so I just sat there quietly and waited for my turn with David in the dungeon. I then started to hear what sounded like Trey getting fucked by David.

"What is he doing to him," I then quietly asked Henry?

"What do you think he's doing to him," Henry replied. I sat there with my head looking down without responding. "And you know what," Henry continued. "It looks like your friend is enjoying it. Of course that's how it is. They always start to enjoy it once it all gets started."

"I know damn well that Trey is not enjoying that," I said.

"Doesn't look that way from where I'm sitting," Henry said smiling as he smoked his cigarette.

As I sat there listening to the sound of Trey getting fucked I started to get a little turned on imaging what he looked like as he was taking David's cock in his ass. After a moment, I looked at Henry and said,"Henry look, I-"

"You're not talking your way out of this," Henry quickly said back to me. "So forget it."

"No sir. I was just going to say that I think when David gets done uh......"

"Fucking your friend."

I nodded and said,"I think he may want to take a break before he has his way with me."

"Yeah so?"

"Well.... I thought that maybe Trey and I could..... you know, give you guys a show."

"What are you talking about?"

"Look.... I've never done anything with guy before. But ever since I knew Trey in college, I've always had this hot fantasy about being with him. Lying naked in bed with him. So, what I'm saying is that.... I want to fuck Trey. I'll even pay you double of whatever David's paying you. Only if you won't tell him it was my idea. Tell him you forced me to do it."

"Sounds interesting," Henry said taking a puff of his cigarette.

"Like I said, I'll pay you double on one condition.....I only want to fuck Trey. David's not to touch me."

"Hmmmm."

"Look Henry, he's paying you for only one of us. And you're letting him have both of us. That's not fair. He should be paying you double. Looks to me like you're the one getting fucked here."

Henry looks over at Butch for a moment. Butch says, "He's got a point.....sir." Henry looks back at me and I say, "And also you don't have to worry about letting us go. Cause I'm not going to tell anyone I paid you for this, it's kind of illegal anyway, and Trey.... he's got a girlfriend. I know he's not going to want anyone to know about this."

"Is this what you want," Henry asked after a moment?

"Yes sir," I said smiling a little.

Henry then reaches up and slowly removes his mask. He had a nice young face with blue eyes and long shoulder length blond hair. He runs his hand through his hair, and took a puff of his cigarette.

"Wow," I said. "You're a very attractive young man. Very attractive."

"Thank you."

"You're welcome. So, if a gay man wants to fuck a straight man, you're the guy to make it happen?"

"That's me."

"I see. So.... do we have a deal?"

"We got a deal."

I smiled at Henry and he smiled back and said,"What are you suppose to say?"

"Please Henry."

"Please Henry what?"

"Please Henry, may I have the straight guy? Who happens to be my hot friend."

"You may," Henry quietly said with a little smirk on his beautiful face.

David and Trey started to moan louder and louder.

"Ooooh fuck," Trey shouted! "Oh man, you're going to make me fucking cum! Oh yeah!

David then started to shout, "OOOOOH Yeah! Ooooooooh I'm starting to cum all in your straight ass, boy! OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHH!!!

I just sat there quietly with a little naughty smile on my face knowing it was about to be my turn..... Poor Trey.

THE END

 

[wilhem]

good imagination.

 

[Kyanimal]

"THE END"? You're kidding, right, Please?

I'm hoping MORE is in the works!

 

[Craiger]

THE END

Now that's what I call a real cliffhanger.......

Craiger

 

[Autolycus]

Great story - thanks for sharing it with us

 

[JRandell69]

Well guys thanks for reading the story and thanks for the comments.

Yes, I could have wrote a Chapter 3 and went into all the hot dirty details of what Chris and Trey did, but I'll just leave it up to you guys to use your wild imagination.

Several weeks after this happened, Chris, who is still single, did contact Trey by phone to see if he wanted to hang out and just talk. Trey was now married to his girlfriend and didn't want to see Chris or talk about what happened in Henry's dungeon. He just wanted to move on and forget about it. Trey also said that Henry is a disturbed lunatic who needs help. He then said he had to go and said goodbye to Chris. Chris hung up the phone feeling very sad and alone knowing that that's probably going to be the last contact he ever has with his friend Trey.

Henry is a 19 year old, who supports himself by arranging fantasies. His clients usually involve lonely gay men. The cost all depends on what your request is. He will try his best to make it happen for you, as long as it doesn't involve someone underage. Henry himself is off limits to his clients. He's actually straight.

However, his organization is very secretive. In order to get a meeting with him, you have to know someone who knows someone who knows Henry.

Butch works for Henry. He's also straight.

Well again, thanks for reading!

 

[Kyanimal]

I love the way your twisted mind works, Buddy!

 

[Craiger]

I seem to know someone who knows someone who knows Henry. If you're nice to me I'll put you in touch...... Thanks, JR, for a fun read.

Craiger