Scenario: You and your ex split up. Neither of them cheated and both know this. You run into a person you met 4 years ago and haven't seen him in 3. Did not run into the guy in the span of those years. The relationship lasted 1.5 years.
The first question is
"Who is (person's name). "
--The answer is, class mate i met 4 years ago, have seen in 3 years.
The second question is.
"Have you "been" with him?"
The first question is
"Who is (person's name). "
--The answer is, class mate i met 4 years ago, have seen in 3 years.
The second question is.
"Have you "been" with him?"

