More from what non-deaders considered a good to great speech
Mitt likes the President - he has made a "concession" that he's a good man - and he is - he's just on the wrong path - and hit Hope and Change bumper sticker - well half is currently correct - "change" is in order - if the Pres. can resteer the boat well by all means
‘‘The president hasn’t disappointed you because he wanted to. The president has disappointed America because he hasn’t led America in the right direction. He took office without the basic qualification that most Americans have and one that was essential to his task. He had almost no experience working in a business. Jobs to him are about government. I learned the real lessons about how America works from experience.’’
I looked at the speech from the standpoint of someone who used to do speech competition.
Let's look at the piece you cited here:
"
The president ... hasn't led America in the right direction." That's falsehood by misdirection: we don't know what direction Obama would have led in, because the Republicans made a past to ensure that the country wouldn't follow.
"
He took office without the basic qualification that most Americans have and one that was essential to his task. He had almost no experience working in a business." Well, the businessmen we've had in the White House before have screwed the country pretty well, so that's not much of a qualification. America is not a business, and very few business principles apply to running any country. In fact the House Republicans have given a magnificent demonstration that America can't be run by a business -- no business would survive when part of the board decided they weren't going to let the company make any new decisions, to let the company ever change anything. If Republicans think government should be run like a business, they've disqualified themselves.
"
Jobs to him are about government.’’ Jobs to Romney are about government -- he made that plain in his speech, with the ludicrous assertion that he would create many millions of jobs. If jobs aren't about government, his claim is an obvious lie. In truth, though, jobs are about government -- Eisenhower, John Kennedy, and Lyndon Johnson proved that by constantly improving the country's infrastructure, and as a result business boomed and jobs were abundant. In fact, the record shows that if the government is significantly improving infrastructure, a tax burden of 3/4 doesn't stall the economy.
"
I learned the real lessons about how America works from experience." Well, no, he didn't -- he never worked for a business like most Americans any more than Obama did. Very few Americans are in the business of vulture capitalism. Very few Americans have made a company a "success" by blackmailing the federal government and a batch of big banks. Very few Americans have built a fortune by manipulating the law to suck cash out of companies and leaving the taxpayers holding the bag. Very few Americans have managed to lie to the IRS in order to get millions of dollars in benefits.
This part can only count as a "good speech" to the ignorant and shallow-minded. It's built on false claims and deception.