Malick's impossibly lyrical meditation on misfortune, The Tree of Life. I love his films.
I've looked over some other viewers' reactions on IMDB and NetFlix and thought I might add another thought.
A great many people despise the film chiefly because they find it obtuse.
I don't believe they are noticing the very, very simple set up at the beginning of the film. (Maybe they were on their cellphone, talking or eating popcorn?) It's a few lines from the biblical old testament, spoken by god to Job, the faithful servant beset by terrible misfortune for no apparent reason:
"Where were you when I laid the earth's foundation? Tell me, if you understand...while the morning stars sang together and all the angels shouted for joy?"
Almost immediately, we learn the family suffers a misfortune in the death of Jack's brother at age 19.
And so the film begins to explore that misfortune...by going back, and showing it as fully as it can: the poignancy and heartbreak of all the family members involved, and then more and more, all the way back--as per the introductory insription--to the beginning of the universe.
How inexplicable is it that we suffer from such a traumatic event as the death of a brother, a son? What does such suffering mean? Malick gives us the context of the immediate past, and then the pivotal context of the mystery of being itself.
I think viewers may enjoy the film for the extraordinary work it is, with that in mind.
On the other hand, if such a theme (theodicy) seems boring or strange,
The Tree of Life might best be skipped.