There was a special sauce story like that in my home town, growing up. I certainly hppe it wasn't true, either.
Eutropius Prynne, Abbot of the Monastery of Saint Mary of the Holy Angels, did not step down from the pulpit but turned the page in the dark chapel beyond the chapel. He opened his mouth and sang the first antiphon of the day.
“Blessed is the man who does not lose faith in me!”
The men in the stalls echoed it back and when he nodded to his right, there Prynne saw Herulian and Reed, yawning his head off besides Brother Gillian, their hands folded into their white robes as they sang:
How good God is to Israel,
to those who are pure of heart.
Yet my feet came close to stumbling,
my steps had almost slipped
for I was filled with envy of the proud
when I saw how the wicked prosper.
On the other side of the night chapel, the other brothers sang:
For them there are no pains;
their bodies are sound and sleek.
They do not share in men’s sorrows;
they are not stricken like others.
The abbot did not always lead, and tomorrow it would be Herulian’s turn and the day after, old Abbot Rodwin. The first time Prynne had led them in prayer he was twenty eight years old, and now he was forty-four. He had started out nervous novice with a voice who had been commanded to sing. But the nerves had not lasted long. He had as much confidence in his voice and his ability to lead as he had in the knowledge that his place was in this abbey.
He had come as a boy, very much like Swann and Doug, but he was the first Black border and black was something it took a long time to get people to call him. He remembered when Herulian was just Benji, and he had a mop of that orangish hair in his face. He had frowned and said, “Black. That doesn’t sound very nice. Are you sure?”
The newer school quarters weren’t up then. The whole place seemed like an old castle and Abbot Prynne, then Tommy Prynne, had asked, “What’s his story?”
“That’s Andy Reed?”
“Does he ever smile?”
“Does he eat is what you really wannna know,” Ben had said. “He’s thin as a rail.”
Abbot Eutropius Prynne waited for the east side to finish the last verse, and then they all sang together:
“Blessed is the man who does not lose faith in me.”
Andy Reed, now Father Paul AndrewReed, always had that slightly nervous, lip licking look to him. He had been a track runner. Tall and rawboned with eyes blinking through his wide spectacles, the principal of Saint Francis had never been able to sit still for long, not even now. As Prynne moved to the next psalm, he was sure his old brother was tapping his foot furiously behind the stall.
On that first day, while they both sat on a cot in their dress pants and white shirts, Ben had whispered, “He’s an orphan.”
“Oh,” Tommy Prynne was embarrassed by the sound of his pity and hoped no one could hear him and that Andy Reed wouldn’t look back.
“They say his mom is the abbot’s neice.”
“The abbot,” Prynne murmured, sucking on a tooth. “I haven’t met him yet.”
Ben said, “You will.”
Thirty years later, Chris Navarro hung off the rooftop, supported by Swann and Pete Agalathagos, coughing up smoke from the cigarette he’d tried to smoke.
“Are you?” Pete began, but Chris kept gagging up phlegm.
“Fuck!” Chris swore, and finally they pulled him back up.
“It’s an acquired taste,” Swann said.
“Maybe I’ll just not acquire it,” Chris decided.
“You guys good?” Pete asked, rising.
“Yeah,” Swann said for Chris, “No one’s falling off a roof tonight.”
“I have an idea,” Chris decided, “why don’t we all just leave the roof.”
“Why don’t we all just leave the part that slopes?”
Swann loved a good roof The best things happened to him on roofs.
“We could all camp out here.”
“I’m not camping on a roof,” Pete said, decisively. “My parents pay too much money for me to sleep on a roof. Goodnight guys.”
“Well, I don’t mind a roof,” Chris said. He had a broad voice, almost like someone off TV. “I could look at the stars all night.” Once over the parapet and off the slope, the tar roof was long and broad, “Safe as a house”, Chris would say, and now the tall white boy in the numbered jersey sat down, stretching his blue jeaned legs in front of him, and slowly took off one sneaker and then the other. Swann, in his shorts and tee shirt, already shoeless—his feet didn’t mind the roughness of the sloping roof tiles beyond the parapet, sat down beside him, then lay out, stretching his arms past his head. He looked up at the stars where he could almost name constellations, almost tell what was what, and then gave up only to treasure the beauty of white and blue and some red points in the almost black sky.
“I’m so sorry about your dad,” Chris finally said. Chris had stretched out and lay next to Swann. For a long time neither of them spoke.
“I know that’s stupid. I know it isn’t much, but I’m sorry. If it was something I could do… I would.”
For some reason that meant a great deal. Chris’s finger’s touched his and Swann felt suddenly strong. He didn’t know he’d needed to feel strong. Lying there under the breeze, suddenly the stars were a little brighter, the breeze not colder or stronger, but more itself. Tears sprang up and he shook a little while something held together broke, something that needed to break. That was all. There was no sobbing, no loud wailing, just the touch of Chris Navarro’s fingers.
“You can’t see these stars in Chicago,” Swann said. “You can see some of them, but not really.”
“Benton’s no Chicago,” Chris said, “and you can’t really see them there, either.”
Chris had turned over on his side, so Swann could feel the other boy learning over him, halfway see his pile of blond curls silver in the night.
“I think as much as I like stars I would still miss Chicago.”
“I don’t know if I’ll miss my father,” Swann said, suddenly.
He sat up and he faced Chris.
Chris’s face was serious. Most of Swann’s life he had preferred the company girls, and he had found boys awkward, but since he’d come here, especially in the last year or so he’d found boys to be something different. Not that they were all great, no, but there was a sadness and a seriousness to them. Like, at this moment, Swann felt that somehow Chris’s face, set and sober, was even sadder than he was.
“I don’t know that I liked Dad. I keep looking back at things he did, how he was. I have a few nice stories, but…. He was always very busy. Always a little too busy for me.”
“I know,” Chris said, pressing his foot over Swann’s, pressing his toes to Swann and leaning a little closer. “Half the time I feel like my parents are too busy for me too.”
Chris raised an eyebrow and his face was so close to Swann’s, Swann could feel his breath. He had felt so separate from everyone, like he had to be separated, and now Chris’s hand, his toes, the closeness of his face, his breath, unfroze that separation.
“Remember last year… The end of last year?”
“Yes, I do.”
“And after the funeral?”
Swann nodded.
“Things were about to happen, right? Something was about to happen.”
“I guess so,” Swann said. Then, “Things did happen. I mean, we said… Yes.”
Then Chris said, “Are you going to stay up in that old nurse’s station tonight?”
“I don’t know. Why?”
“Just asking.”
“Swann!” a voice hissed out of the dark. “Swann!”
The two boys parted, looking around, and Swann, with a vague irritated feeling saw his cousin walking across the roof to them.
“Pete said you guys were up here.”
Doug sat down between them. They made room for him.
“You couldn’t sleep?” Swann said, rubbing his cousin’s shoulder.
Duck shook his head.
“You can’t stay on the roof,” Chris told him, nudging him in the side.
“I know.”
“In ten minutes you’re going to bed,” Swann said. “We’re all going to bed.”
“Me and Mike went exploring,” Doug said.
“And?” said his cousin.
“We were in the old nurse’s station. We thought we might live in it.”
“That’s crazy,” Chris said.
Swann said, “Whaddid you decide?”
“That we’d rather stay on the first floor in our rooms.”
“Good choice—” Swann began, then said, “The nurse’s station!”
“Huh?” Duck and Chris said.
“The nurse’s station,” Swann said, pointedly, leaning over Doug and looking at Chris.
The other boy opened his mouth in a surprised O, and then said, “Yeah. Uh,” he nodded again and again, “Yes.”