It's cool to see so many hits on this thread. Even though it might be at the cost of my JUB dignity, hopefully it will help others with the same problems.
Anyways, I thought I'd conclude this thread by telling the third craigslist hookup that transpired not more than a few hours ago. Though the 3rd guy is also 35 years old like guy #2, he has NEVER been with another guy before. The whole concept that he was experiencing a guy for the first time really turned me on.
Unlike my previous two flings, #3 and I talked frequently online. I can honestly say I trust the dude. After 3 weeks of just bullshit talking and getting to know each other, we nervously hooked up.
He was very gentle... a great kisser, which I have NEVER experienced in my life. Anyways, being with this guy was different than any of my previous sexual encounters, he made me feel hot... almost worshiped. So, after roughly 1.5 hours of sucking, groping and pinching, I
FINALLY had an explosive orgasm. (He eventually did as well moments later)
To sum things up, I really do think that when people hook up, it should be more significant than a mere fling. Sex isn't just a physical aspect, but holds emotional and mental value as well. I trusted this guy, he turned me on despite his not-so-fit body type, and most importantly we both see a potential for a good friendship or more.
Anyways, I'm just happy my bits n' pieces still work down there... I was getting scared for awhile. Thanks for reading guys.
- GoodbyeSobriety