The Original Gay Porn Community - Free Gay Movies and Photos, Gay Porn Site Reviews and Adult Gay Forums

  • Welcome To Just Us Boys - The World's Largest Gay Message Board Community

    In order to comply with recent US Supreme Court rulings regarding adult content, we will be making changes in the future to require that you log into your account to view adult content on the site.
    If you do not have an account, please register.
    REGISTER HERE - 100% FREE / We Will Never Sell Your Info

    PLEASE READ: To register, turn off your VPN (iPhone users- disable iCloud); you can re-enable the VPN after registration. You must maintain an active email address on your account: disposable email addresses cannot be used to register.

  • Hi Guest - Did you know?
    Hot Topics is a Safe for Work (SFW) forum.

Who do you think is a 'gay music icon' (besides Lady Gaga)?

…Marilyn Manson could be considered a gay icon maybe…So does he count? lol


It's kewl by me! Actually, I think that's an excellent choice. Thinking of other skinny blonds whose names were inspired (in part) by Marilyn Monroe, I'd also add Michael Monroe (Hanoi Rocks). Who else? Trent Reznor… Lou Reed, Patty Smith, Debbie Harry, Laura Nyro… Kurt Cobain and Perry Farrell and Dave Navarro and several others whose names I just can't think of at the moment (I've been drinking wine since dinner).

If you wanted to post a vid of The Dope Show (I assume there's a good one on YouTube), that might help you make your point to anyone else who might not be as convinced as I (or perhaps might be totally unfamiliar with the track <cofffrankfrankcoff>). Though I didn't mention it in my OP cos it's become sort of second nature for me to post vids on this site, but I like vids – vids are good!

I did put Rob Halford and Henry Rollins on my my list, but it, BTW, was not meant to be all-inclusive by any means – really it was just a bunch of names that came to me the morning I made the OP (and I deliberately left off band names, like Queen and Alice Cooper and Pansy Division and the Queers, because the list already seemed too long) – and I since have become aware of many more names that deserved to be there (besides the ones other members already have cited, such as Diana Ross, Aretha Franklin and Patti LaBelle), but whom I absolutely would consider 'gay music icons,' as well. I'll post those later (with, I only hope, videos that come close to the marvelous ones unloadonme found for Freddie Mercury ..|). Cheers!

Here's just one, for now (the Oscars are on, and we have company – did Lisbeth Salander win anything for butt-fucking the judge who raped her in The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo?)…



[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMOolD0hm4s&fmt=18"]Star David Bowie[/ame]
.
 
My Gay Music Icons Are:

Kylie Minogue
Robyn
Roisin Murphy
Sophie Ellis Bextor
Janet Jackson
Beth Ditto
Mcfly
George Michael
Dave Koz
 
P!nk


The message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen your message to at least 10 characters.
 
Liza Minnelli
Bette Midler
Madonna


Others have just tried really, really hard to emulate their status as a Gay Icon. . .ESPECIALLY Lady Gaga.
 
An absolute shame that gay men mostly consider females to be gay icons.

Apart from that, I didn't understand the paragraph with the advertizing.
 
An absolute shame that gay men mostly consider females to be gay icons.

Apart from that, I didn't understand the paragraph with the advertizing.


Well, I don't know about the first part, though it is notable and certainly invites further discussion…

Sorry about the second part, though! I made the OP in a hurry, and that was the result. But the examples I used were just some things so-called 'gay music icons' have promoted (for profit) in the past and could do again in the future, as well as some companies that historically have viewed the 'gay advertising market' segment as being worth their while pursuing (but again, only for profit). And I don't mean to cast any aspersions on them for that either – that's just in the nature of capitalism, I think.

Let's see… Someone else mentioned Gloria Gaynor, I Will Survive… She was big once, too, I gather. I have to wonder, though… Did she survive?



[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBR2G-iI3-I"]Also, whatever happened to Roller Disco?[/ame]


On a more serious note, some formerly stalwart, 'gay music icons' have turned into frankly (no pun intended) homophobic, religious zealots in their later years – the most notable one being not Anita Bryant so much, as that other Darling of the Disco, Donna Summer.

What was that all about, do you suppose?

.
 
adam lambert (maybe too young to be an 'icon' but he will be)
freddie mercury
:p
 
The use of the adjectival noun ICON is being over generalised in this discussion, don't you think? It has religious origins where saints and deified images were /are held aloft and separate from the many, after a dedicated life of good works and helping improve things for others.

To apply this to a bunch of fly by nighters whom mostly disappear before all but the most dedicated domestic listeners learn their names is too much of a reach. Where is the application to gay rights, gay society, gay education, gay history/literature/art/culture? Most of these people do nothing specifically for gay folk, and those who do deserve our recognition and respect much more than the likes of Janet Jackson or Terry Reid! To be seen as an Icon is to have reached a status of definition that elevates one to the level where potency is absolute. To be a gay icon means that the person we label has worked hard and with determination to lead the advancement of gay people whether in good times or bad.

Now, let's be a little more realistic about the list. Or else ask for a list of people gay people don't find offensive.

PS. Even expanding the semiotics to the broadest reading would mean that the persons listed as gay icons would at the very least be quintessentially gay.
 
Nowadays, anyone with a mediocre voice and that dresses up like a drag queen 10 years ago and is a straight female but happens to be bisexual before an album launch is probably a gay music icon.

Even though that describes Lady Gaga, I still think she earned to be an icon to some gay men. Hey if she helps young gay teens survive another day, more power to her.
 
One of my personal favorites among the list in my OP is Cyndi Lauper

Here's a longish excerpt from the Wikipedia article I linked to:

Lauper recorded an album of all new material during 2007. The working title given to the project was Savoir-faire, but she announced at her Perth, Australia concert in February 2008 that the name of the album was Bring Ya to the Brink and that it would be released in the spring. In preparation for the album, Lauper visited England and France during summer 2007 to write for the album and wrote songs with dance artists like Axwell, The Scumfrog, Basement Jaxx, Digital Dog, Dragonette, Kleerup and others. She described it as a mainly dance album with good rhythm. Most of the album was recorded in Sweden. The first single released in Japan was "Set Your Heart" which gained significant airplay there and was used in the advertising campaign for the 2008 Toyota Car Model (Mark X ZIO) starring actor and singer Takeshi Kaneshiro. Lauper embarked on an Australian tour playing at the Kings Park Botanic Gardens in Perth, supported by Katie Noonan and Kate Miller-Heidke on February 22, 2008, and she was the headline and final act at the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras Party, on March 2, 2008. She sang "Same Ol' Story" followed by a newly remixed version of "Girls Just Want to Have Fun". "Same Ol' Story" was released as the album's first worldwide single and was released as a download only on May 6, 2008. Several remixes of the track were released to DJs. The album was released on May 27, 2008 in the United States.

The True Colors Tour 2008 debuted on May 31, 2008. Joining Lauper at various venues were Rosie O'Donnell, The B-52's, Joan Jett and the Blackhearts, The Cliks, Indigo Girls, Kat Deluna, Joan Armatrading, Regina Spektor, Tegan and Sara, Nona Hendryx, Deborah Cox, Wanda Sykes, among others. The MC was Carson Kressley from Queer Eye for the Straight Guy. Sarah McLachlan was also featured at the Burnaby, British Columbia show.

In August 2008, Lauper contributed an article titled "Hope" to The Huffington Post which encouraged Americans to vote for Barack Obama in the upcoming United States presidential election.[19] Lauper also performed alongside Thelma Houston, Melissa Etheridge and Rufus Wainwright at the 2008 Democratic National Convention.

David Byrne stated in his blog that he has collaborated with Lauper on a track for his upcoming Here Lies Love. He described her performance as "amazingly fine-tuned" and "very impressive."[20] Lauper recorded a special Christmas duet with Swedish band The Hives, entitled "A Christmas Duel", on CDsingle and 7" vinyl, in Sweden only, on November 19, 2008. It reached number 4 in the Swedish charts.[21]

In December 2008, Bring Ya to the Brink was nominated for a Grammy Award for Best Electronic/Dance Album. Lauper also signed a book deal for an autobiography that is scheduled to come out at the end of 2009 or early 2010.[22] Lauper also performed on the "Girls Night Out", headlining it with Rosie O'Donnell in the US.[23]

She appeared on many TV shows in 2009 including the American soap opera, As the World Turns, supporting gay rights, and promoting her True Colors tour and album, Bring Ya to the Brink. She performed "Into the Nightlife" and dedicated a rendition of "True Colors" to one of the show's characters; Luke Snyder. She appeared on the live finale of the eighth season of American Idol on May 20, 2009, performing a duet of "Time After Time" with top-13 finalist Allison Iraheta, accompanying the song on Appalachian dulcimer. She appeared on the 2009 TV Land Awards on April 19 dressed as the "Emperess of Evil" to perform the theme song for Electra Woman and Dyna Girl as part of a musical tribute to Sid Krofft and Marty Krofft. Lauper performed a duet with Leona Lewis on VH1 Divas on September 19, 2009 singing "True Colors" and also appeared along side hip hop artist Eminem for a comedy skit at the MTV VMA's in September 2009. In addition, Lauper played herself alongside Elvis Costello, Sheryl Crow, Michael McDonald, and Mary J. Blige on 30 Rock's third season finale. She also played Avalon Harmonia, a psychic on the Season 5 premiere of Bones.

Cyndi Lauper was also one of the celebrities who designed a T-shirt for the second Fashion Against Aids campaign in 2009, a collaboration between H&M and Designers Against Aids to raise HIV/AIDS awareness worldwide, particularly amongst youngsters.


What do you think about that (nominally straight, married) sweetheart? Is she beautiful or what?

The excerpt also mentions in passing three of the more progressive (for their sales purposes) companies of that era – Benetton, H&M, and Toyota – that I kind of had in mind when I made the OP.

And in the sense that it – more than 'gay rights,' or anything higher in this crass world – positively define Madonna and Lady Gaga (among many others – no blame, Nicki!)…



[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3aK-UjR3Oj4&fmt=18"]Money Changes Everything[/ame]
.
 
Pete Burns[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPvjX7ddZeA[/ame]
 
For me no one even comes close to Debbie Harry!
Still the hottest and coolest rock chick of all time and her music and style aren't cheesy, contrived and over the top like Cher, Madonna or other singers.
I don't consider her a gay music icon, just an icon in general, but since I'm gay and she does have a huge gay following then let that be so.
 
Madonna and Lady Gaga.

Why? Because to me, they seem the most gay friendly and have never been ashamed to talk about us and support us even when it looked like it would cost them a lot of straight fans.

To me a gay icon is a lot more than a catchy song or the way they look or an accidental gay anthem. They have to earn it.

I totally agree with elvin. Too many of the people mentioned here just sort of fell into gay icon status thanks to some songs that happened to click with a large portion of the gay community. That certainly doesn't mean they were all on our side for anything other than a paycheck.
 
Madonna and Cher helped me a lot when I was coming out. I'd run to the store and buy magazines to read their interviews and watch music videos and really felt helped by them both. I read an interview where Cher was talking about Chaz (that's what he is calling himself now?) and how much she loved her (him). I remember seeing Madonna on stage with all these drag queens...

Anthony Callea seems to be very popular in Australia as an openly gay artist... I really love his music.
 
jb.jpg
Although there is not much awareness of it yet in the comm, nor by the poser himself.
 
Katy Perry.
KatyPerry.jpg



At least I think she is.
 
Back
Top