It is nearly impossible for me to select a single all-time favorite, but you guys have certainly listed many who should be in the conversation. I think a truly legendary bottom has to be the right blend of cute and hot/sexy, as has been mentioned here regarding Jeremy Jordan. It goes without saying he has to have a great ass. He also has to demonstrate a good mix of visible and audible reactions as to how much he loves having that cock inside him. A lot of open mouth ecstasy rather than expressions of pain, and just the right amount of dirty talk without sounding so annoying that the top wants to stuff a sock in his mouth. It is also critical that he stays hard or relatively hard throughout the process, and cums while the top is inside him. Soft dicks are a turn-off and generally indicate a lack of interest - so does having to jack off after the top has pulled out and cum on your stomach or back. Didn't that cock feel good enough for you to cum while your partner was rubbing your prostate with his cock? It's also nice if he has attractive, well-cared for feet & toes, as they are generally prominently featured in missionary and doggy-style positions.
Jeremy Jordan (there is a truly great scene in which he is a beer delivery guy that features some legendary action, terrific dirty talk, and amazing facial expressions. Forget the name of the movie.)
Josh from Corbin Fisher (a wide body of work with some totally hot CF tops; choirboy face)
Kurt Wild (amazing eyes; this guy is a truly animalistic bottom who seems to love a cock in his ass - shocking that he's straight)
Brent Corrigan (his beautiful cock always stays hard as steel when he's getting fucked; always shoots some wonderfully creamy loads)
One guy who I wouldn't have come up with on my own is Travis from Corbin Fisher. Not the stereotypical bottom - taller, lankier. But judging by the pics in this thread, the closed eyes/open mouth look of ecstasy, the impossibly erect cock, the toe curling, and the tongue sucking all indicate that he craves a hard cock inside him!
Here are a few others on my list...
Damien White (
Active Duty)
Kayden Daniels (Helix)
Ashton Rush (Southern Strokes, CollegeDudes247, Helix)
Nate from Corbin Fisher (tragic that he only did 3 scenes, one of them solo. He sure did seem to love getting fucked!)