We've used minimally processed turkeys for years - Fresh or Fresh Frozen, but not injected w/ "up to 12% salt solution", which are the $0.49/Lb Thanksgiving special birds.
In our neck of the woods, the Fresh / Fresh Frozen run $0.99 - $2.49/Lb, depending on how "premium" you want. The more expensive are the "specially bred for more white meat" birds.
Since we like the Dark meat better, that's not an issue for us.
Like you, Neil, for years we added water and covered the bird, which does wind up steaming it. We've left the top off and roasted the past few. We passed the baton this year to our son and his GF.
As to gravy - they made a lot with their oven roasted turkey - they didn't do stuffing in the bird - they had fresh veggies in and around, like you'd do a pot roast - made for tasty gravy and the veggies were pretty good, too. We brought our wild rice and sausage "stuffing" as a side dish.
We haven't done gravy in our house for years because it tends to cause some indigestion w/ most. Instead, we've put all of the pan drippings into soup.
I wonder if the leaning toward leaner, "healthier" foods has resulted in some Turkey growers leaning out the bird feed, and that's what has affected both you and joshua's Turkeys? I know you pay a chunk more in Peterborough for your Turkey than we do on the South side of the lake.
We actually don't do a big meal at Christmas - Thanksgiving is a big Turkey dinner, but Chrismas is a buffet of finger foods - cut up fresh veggies - Carrots, Broccoli, Cauliflower, Peppers - Red/Green/Yellow/Orange, Celery, Zucchini, Summer Squash, then add Shrimp Cocktail, Spinach Balls, Mushroom/Bacon/Cheese/Rye "Rounds", rye Bread dip, etc.
Then everyone is serve yourself. Desserts later on.
It makes for a much more relaxed day that everyone can enjoy, instead of the cooks being wrung out and tired.
Merry Christmas one and all.