Worst Top 12 American Idol's

[torontoguy22]

Whaaaat?! Chris was an awesome vocalist, and he was oh so pleasant on the eyes. I agree with you on Jasmine though.

 

[RACERX71]

Chris was one of the best ever to come out of that show ! well i know for sure you dont work in the record industry

 

[Ohiospeedo]

You are crazy if you think that Chris is one of the worst.

What about:
Season 1
AJ Gill
Jim Verraros
Ejay Day

Season 2
Corey Clark
I looked at the list and couldn't really remember anyone else

Season 3
George Huff
Jasmine Trias
John Stevens
Jon Peter Lewis

Season 4
Scott Savol

Season 5
Bucky Covington
Kevin Covais
Elliot Yamin - I don't get it. I thought that he was horrible.
Ace Young - Alright we get it, you can do falsetto.

 

[xyboyms]

Christina Christian's voice was so fucking annoying to hear every week. Her vibrato was horrible! And I really never liked Justin Guarini.

 

[naturist]

Check out Chris Daughtry's new CD. The boy's got it going on. Excellent! Only AI alumn to beat him in sales the first time out the gate was Aiken. This CD rocks and showcases his vocal skills at the same time. Anybody who says this guy is one of the worst AI contestants definitely needs their hearing checked. I'm glad he didn't win the big prize. There would be a certain stigma attached to being an AI for a rocker like Chris.

 

[iflookscouldkill]

Season 1
Justin Guarini
Nikki McKibbin

Season 2
Corey Clark
Carmen Rasmusen
Josh Gracin

Season 3
Jasmine Trias
John Stevens
Jon Peter Lewis
Leah Labelle

Season 4
Scott Savol
Constantine Maroulis
Anwar Robinson

Season 5
Katharine McPhee
Ace Young
Lisa Tucker
Kevin Covais

 

[RUTGERSpaul]

Season 1:

Nikki McKibbin
Justin Guarini

Season 2:

Corey Clark
Vanessa Olivarez

Season 3:

Fantasia
Leah LaBelle

Season 4:

Scott Savol
Anthony Fedrov

Season 5:

Katharine McPhee
Kevin Covais

 

[RACERX71]

I dont think chris was hot at all ... but he is by far an amazing vocalist .. maybe you guys just like dance music !

 

[JesseNYC]

I think Fantasia has the most annoying voice in the entire world. Out of all the people on that show Ive only liked Kelly, Carrie, and Kat.... oh and ofcourse PARIS!!!!!!!!!

 

[RACERX71]

Hey anyone notice where Chris's new cd has been listed on billboard for the last few weeks ?

 

[GayBoyKellyCfan]

^4-3-1 I think.. It hit #1 after 9 weeks on the charts, selling an amazing 66,000 copies. It's such a sad day in album sales when the past 3 weeks the #1 album has been in the 66,000 range.

 

[breatheH20]

I didn't understand the fasicnation with Katherine McPhee, and how she made it to the top 2. I thought Elliott was way better than her.

And that weird jazzy redhead from Season 3 I think, he was annoying.

 

[Rookie047]

I didn't watch the first two seasons...

Third Season-
John Stevens (His style just wasn't for American Idol)
Jon Peter Lewis (Even though he was def. a cutie in my book)
Jasmin Trias (I'm not saying she was awful, but she didn't deserve the top 3 like Latoya did)

Fourth Season-
Anthony Fedorov

Fifth Season-
Kevin Covais
Katherine (She just annoyed me)

 

[reinventedboy]

Vonzell was my fav out of all of them. SHE was the bomb and i loved every song she did.

 

[iflookscouldkill]

Josh Gracin was Perfect. He was hot, he had a really good voice and he never missed a note. The only thing bad is he went country. Even Simon said he should've won. Watch this clip and you'll have to change your mind.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=UcJ7BOPUoZM

And this one:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=K7egSETc7x4

I can't believe you think Clay is better than him.

Josh irritated me for several reasons, everything he sang he sang like a country song...Disco songs should not have twang in them. His stupid military sob story was played up too much and made him even more irritating and I just didn't like him. And for the record I don't like Clay Aiken at all but he has a better voice than Josh and did belong in the finals.

 

[martyj]

Katharine McPhee. You can tell a lot about her personality when she's singing and when she's not, that whole diva 'tude she already developed prior to auditioning. She came to the judges with a great lack of confidence, and longed for an ego boost. She can sing good, yeah, so the judges fed her compliments and that was what she wanted. Getting all that, her ego just started inflating and shone through in her song choices, her oversinging, and her snappy remarks like "Simon, it's okay - you don't like country music!" and "I didn't pick the song!" whenever she got critiqued. And obviously, she must think highly of herself now that she's doing R&B/hip hop-lite with the good girl image she's worked to give herself during the show. I'm sure if a music video surfaces, which I'm sure would, we'll get better visual aids to support my argument - pretty close-ups of Katharine in pretty outfits with pretty make up. Katharine is all about the ego, man. It overpowers her singng, which is actually very nice when she doesn't let her pride get into it.

An "idol" doesn't necessarily have to be confined to good songs and a good voice, a message the show has somewhat tarnished. An "idol" is a voice of a certain generation or society, or so I would define one. I wouldn't want my generation represented by ego.

 

[boysmile]

well,I admit Bucky is not the best,but I really really like his smile,so sweet

 

[MCsNo1Fn]

WORST:
Justin Guarini - did we get punk'd?

Kimberley Locke - bitch, ya can't sang. move on.

Diana DeGarmo - while shes a good singer, you dont turn into a whore at 16 on national television. just because aguilera and madonna did it didn't give you permission to do so. youre not them. nobody cares about you. shut up and go back to Georgia.

CHRIS DAUGHTRY - why people like him is beyond me. He's a biter of everyone elses ideas and hes nothing special. And my ass looks better than him, and that's pretty sad.

Taylor Hicks - um, where's the talent, exactly?

Elliott Yamin - why was he even on the show? i wanted to shoot myself in the eyes everytime he came on screen, and I swear my ears were bleedin a few times...

FAVES:
Carrie Underwood
Fantasia
Katharine McPhee
Paris Bennett
Jennifer Hudson

 

[bluedragon4]

I couldn't even name all the winners let a lone any of the finalists!

 

[Boywonder89]

Top 5 that should have been REJECTED: (No particular order)
Scott Savol (S4)
Bucky Covington (S5)
Mikalah Gordon (S4)
Kevin Covais (S5)
Melissa McGhee (S5)

Top 5 that should have made it FURTHER: (no particular order)
Mandisa (S5)
Christina Christian (S1)
Jennifer Hudson (S3)
Amy Adams (S3)
Lisa Tucker (S5)