Tom Frushour’s house was about four blocks from school, a large red brick Colonial with classy furniture out of a magazine, and he was an only child. His mother was relaxed.
“I’m just going to give you boys a twenty,” she drawled almost like a Southern belle. “You can order what you want from the pizza place.”
“How’s that sound, Joe?” Tom asked.
Joey nodded. “That sounds cool.”
“You know what I was thinking about?” Tom said while they were watching porn on his computer.
“When the pizza guy was here?”
“There was this one porn I saw, where this redheaded pizza guy comes to the door, and he just gets on his knees and starts just like, sucking the man off, like going at it like a fucking pump, just sucking him. And then the guy jizzes all over the pizza guy’s face. And I thought... fucking hot. That would be fucking hot. To do... You know?”
They watched a little porn where this body builder, who in a way reminded Joey of Tom, had this little watermelon. He was sitting there just smoothed over in oil, completely naked, completely hot, Joey thought, and there was a little hole in the watermelon, and so he started fucking it. He was doing it slowly, moving the fruit up and down on his dick, and his eyes went all stupid. His jaw got slack. And then he put it on the floor and slowly, he began to fuck the watermelon. Tom kept on rewinding it as the guy was about to come, as his hams went taut, and he shot into the fruit.
And then his hand was in Joey’s lap, and he started to stroke him. Joey had been waiting for this to happen, and Tom rewound the video to the beginning, to the naked man masturbating, and then getting down to fuck the watermelon, and then ejaculating inside of it. And then the man on the video was eating out of it, and digging out of the watermelon with his fingertips, licking his own semen. Now he was fucking the fruit again, and by then Tom had Joey’s shorts off, and his underwear around his knees and he was the same and then, just like that, Tom said, “I’m gonna fuck you now. Alright?” more like he was clarifying a fact than asking a favor.
He put Joey down on his knees, and then Joey heard a squirt of something, and a click from the computer and voices from a new porn. And then Tom caught him by the hips and he felt Tom’s penis at the crack of his ass. It felt so good. It pressed in and tried to find the hole and still it felt good and it felt good pressing in a bit, and then Joey gasped. Tom squirted some more... lotion he hoped, and slid in, making the walls of Joey’s anus burn. He wanted to catch his breath, he’d never felt such pain. But he moved around it, fitting Tom in, and then, with a rhythm, Tom Frushour began fucking him.
Once, Joseph Flowers had read a blog where a man was describing the first time he’d been fucked in the ass. When it finally happened to him, Joey remembered that it had been happening a while before he knew it was going on, and then it had been hurting a while before he knew that it hurt. Tom had gone further than he needed to, not knowing what he was doing, not using enough lube, not trying to hurt him, but not really knowing any better, enjoying the unexpected pleasure too much Joey imagined.
But then the truth was, even when it was uncomfortable, even when it was too much, in a way he not so much enjoyed it, as needed it. Needed the on-his-hands-and-knee-ness of being bent over and fucked in Tom Frushour’s room. He needed the right-now-ness of it. There was no past, no consequence, no reflection. Just the moment right there where Tom was pressing into him, harder and harder, and then the grunting, and Tom cursing, and Joey knew Tom had ejaculated inside of him.
When Tom pulled out of him, Joey went to his side on the floor, feeling a burning deep inside of him, squeezing himself together, feeling weirdly opened and strangely exultant about it.
“You all right, Joe?” Tom said.
Joey didn’t say anything. He just lay on his side, and Tom said, “I’ll jack you off. Suck you off. Make it worth your while.”
Apparently Tom felt guilty.
“I’m gonna suck you off, Joe, all right?”
And he did. Joey was already erect, and he was burning down there, a little raw. Tom’s mouth was on him, sucking him. He could hear Tom gulping and swallowing on his cock.
Joey was in the opposite place of Tom. Joey, who could admit that he had been afraid of many things, was afraid of nothing right now.
Here he was, on his side, jeans and briefs pulled down, Tom sucking like someone starving for that last bit of nourishment, and Joey was giving it to him in a body twist of orgasm, flooding his mouth. And how come it felt so good if it was a sin? How come this openness in his ass despite the ache and the burning, felt good too?
For that moment there was only feeling, throbbing, aching, pleasure without consequence or question, future or past. Just being.
There was a limit to Thomas Frushour’s love. Tom had no interest in being sodomized, and didn’t offer his ass up to Joey. Once Joey asked, and Tom said, in a gentle way, “I don’t know if I want to do that, Joey.”
“But you do it to me.”
“But you enjoy it,” Tom said.
Joey wanted to protest, but realized that he did enjoy it. Even that first time when there had been discomfort and pain. When it was over, Joey kept sitting on the toilet waiting for something to come out. Still, he thought there was some lack of logic in Tom’s argument, only he couldn’t point it out.
Meanwhile, for the rest of that year, up until Joey was fourteen, he continued to have a relationship with Tom Frushour. It left the equipment room and went into Tom’s house at sleepovers, or sometimes when his parents were away. It never occurred to Joey to have Tom over to his house. The fact that Tom wouldn’t let Joey fuck him sat in Joey’s head, a ghost of the knowledge that things were not equal between them. But Tom was two years older, after all, and in everything else, sexually and otherwise, Tom was equal, or at least as equal as Joey could have expected him to be.
One night Tom called Joey up and asked him if he could come over.
Between the old house and Tom’s house was a stretch of pine lined road where the northern end of town was yet to be developed. Next came the slightly larger and newer houses of East End where Tom lived.
“Just come on in,” Tom had told him over the phone. “My folks are gone.”
Joey parked his bike on the new black asphalt driveway, and he did just come in. He called Tom’s name, but Tom didn’t answer. He went into the kitchen, which was built over the garage on a bridge connecting the lower level to the top level of the house, and he poured himself a glass of orange juice, drank half of it, and then went up to Tom’s room.
He heard noises, but they didn’t make any sense. Not because he didn’t know what they were, but because he knew exactly what they were. It made no sense for them to be coming from Tom’s room if Joey wasn’t there with him. They were loud and whimpering, Tom’s voice was at least.
And then he must have gathered up his nerve, and he went in there and there was Tom who wouldn’t be fucked, wild hair tousled and pulled, being fucked, by a slightly older guy, a guy with a little diamond stud earring, and slick sweat, like someone from one of the twink porns. His eyes were spaced out with the joy of fucking, and Tom’s red face looked out and saw Joey, and there was no shame. There was just this desperate motioning with his hand.
Joey came into the room, half dizzy. The guy fucking Tom stopped. The world seemed to have stopped. Nothing made much sense, even less sense than usual.
“You Joey?” the guy said.
He nodded.
He pulled out of Tom, and Tom whimpered while this guy sat on the edge of the bed with beautiful thighs and chiseled chest. He must have been seventeen or eighteen, and Tom was lying on his side, curled up and not in control. He said, as the guy took out a lighter and lit a marijuana pipe:
“This is my cousin, Cage.”
Without any explanation of himself, Cousin Cage, letting smoke leak out of his mouth and nostrils said, “Tom says you like to fuck. I’d been telling him I’d like to try out a three way or somethin’ like that.
“You cool with that?”
Joey thought that this boy with the buzzed body, with the light brown hair on his face and brown lashes, with his hazel eyes and the smoke leaking slowly out of his nose was the most beautiful guy he’d ever seen, that he definitely wanted to have sex with him, that this was so cool, like something he’d seen in movies,.
But when he looked at him, Joey realized with complete clarity that this definitely was NOT cool with him. That he did not want to have sex with two people at once, who were related to each other, who were.... there was something wrong with all of this.
But he did not say no.
The next day was the first time that Joey ever felt like he was a horrible person. During the whole dizzying affair with Tom Frushour he never felt guilty. He had the sense not to run around telling everyone or anyone for that matter, but he never felt like there was something at the root of him that was bad, that was tainted. But that night they had seen the same porno clips he had seen and, apparently, had imagined him as the boy in the middle, the one who was being fucked in the ass by one, sucking the other, while they talked over him and smacked his ass and said, “You like that, bitch. Don’t you? Bitch likes to suck that dick.”
That was something he didn’t live down. He didn’t live down the fact that he hadn’t been forced into being disgraced, but he’d consented anyway.
What was he to Tom? He felt betrayed. He was angry, but the anger was directed toward himself. Who would have done what he did? Who would have let it happen? Who would let their boyfriend do that to them. But then Tom was not his boyfriend. When had Tom ever said, “I love you, Joey,”? Or when, in all the times when he was down on his knees, sucking Tom’s dick, had he ever thought of asking, “Do you love me?” Had he ever asked for some type of assurance? Even now, a few years later, Joey didn’t know what to call Tom. He had imagined that things were equal between them, but when he was seventeen Joey looked back and saw it differently. Tom, latently gay and unable to admit it, had seen someone a little younger he could experiment with, and this person, Joey, had offered no resistance, had let Tom do everything he wanted, and had done to him everything he wanted with no messy questions, no, “Are we gay?” or “Are we a couple?” just simple capitulation to all of Tom’s sexual whims.
There was no reason, Joey realized, that Tom should have told Joey, “I like to have sex with my cousin,” or that, “me and my cousin talk about you and having a three way with you.” In fact, knowing Tom, there was no reason Joey should have been surprised by anything about him. What Joey was surprised about, though, was the level of his own stupidity.
After it was over, and Joey was lying there almost bored by the sight of Cage’s dick, thick and magnificent as it was, Cage offered him a toke that Joey refused.
“I’m not gay,” he said. “I just like to do this now and again.”
Tom was chuckling behind Joey. Joey could almost see Tom, naked, reaching across him for the pipe. He had moment upon a moment upon another moment of clarity.
This Cage was a sad person and so was Tom, and so was he if he kept this up, this skulking. If enjoying having sex with your male cousin on a regular basis and being a seventeen year old having three ways with a fifteen year old and a fourteen year old boy didn’t make you gay, what did?
And what was Joey to Tom? Certainly any hazy idea of being a boyfriend was dead right here on this bed.
One of the Frushour cousins lightly farted, and it left the earthy smell appropriate to Joey’s discovery.
That was the end of Thomas and for high school he ended up at Calverton, where Scott had graduated eight years earlier. He joined the football team and when Molly Taghon introduced himself to her, he was so convinced that guys were a bad idea that he never thought he would be with one again. He was sure the experience of Thomas Frushour had burnt him and so, Homecoming weekend, when he was fifteen, he fucked Molly on the football field after the game and entered the world of proper sex, the world where boys went with girls and didn’t end up with the things happened to them that had happened to him. That old memories and desires would assert themselves, that he would eventually seek out the attention of other boys now and again he had not foreseen. Molly wore his jacket, and by junior year she wore his ring. Things did not work out with them, and this left him free to meet boys. Once, when he and some guy in a trailer park were sitting up naked on his sofa, the guy asked him, “So, how does this whole bisexual thing work out.”
“It’s like the best of both worlds. Why limit yourself?”
He’d been with this guy a year before, the same time he’d broken up with Molly, and the sex had been so hot, so passionate, so UNSAFE, he had refused the guys calls and not answered his emails ever afterward. He couldn’t go back to the feelings that had opened up. And then, one day, after he had been hired at the Marion Arms, he was laying out a white tarp and spray painting the walls of a corridor when Felix came walking down the hall and he apologized, “You can come around. Just let me move this right out your way.”
“It isn’t necessary,” Felix said, “I’ll just walk downstairs and come back the other way.”
“Are you sure?”
Felix had stopped, because he knew the boy. He had to think a while and get up close to him and then he realized he had seen him naked, on Adam4Adam with the screenname: Orange Hat and the tagline: When you see me, say you know what the Orange Hat is for.
“Absolutely,” Felix said, and when he came back around, Joey said, “I’m Joey,” and Felix said, “Felix. Pleased to meet you,” and doffed his fedora.
He wasn’t going to bring up orange hats today.
When Max was fixing the drain, Felix came into the kitchen with its black and white check pattern and saw Max’s legs hanging out of the sink.
“Joey not here?”
“Joey’s downstairs,” Max said, his voice echoing from under the sink.
It had been a month since Feli met Joey, and he had hoped to see him again.
“Um,” Felix said. “Well, that’s too bad. Tell him I saw him the other night.”
“Where?”
“Just tell him, Felix said, “I know what Orange Hat means.”
By the end of the day there was a knock at the door and Felix wasn’t surprised when Joey was standing there looking jumpy and amazingly hot.
“Whaddid you mean by…. Orange Hat.”
“I mean I saw you on the net. I saw your—”
Joey put a finger to his lips and pressed inside the apartment, closing the door behind him.
“You can’t say shit like that?”
Felix raised his eyebrow.
“Were you trying to make me feel weird? Or embarrassed?”
“No,” Felix said. “I was trying to tell you I want you.”
WE WILL RETURN AFTER EASTER