“Badass. Awesome, Kenny!” Rob exclaimed as he moved through the apartment.
Brendan walked around, hands behind his back like a visitor at a gallery until Kenny, nervously, said, “Have a seat you guys. Let me get you something to drink. Give me your jackets.”
Kenny lived on the third floor of the building and his apartment was wide and sparsely furnished, but filled with paints and canvases. Brendan gave Kenny his jacket, and sat down in a low chair looking out onto Addison. A bus passed. Rob ignored both things Kenny said and followed him into the kitchen going on about their El ride and the bus they had taken.
“Yeah, always take the Blue Line, no matter how gross it is,” Brendan heard Kenny say.
A few moments later, Kenny came out, followed by Rob, and he had juices on a tray with crackers.
“We can get a little fancier if you want,” Kenny said, “Later.”
They sat around eating crackers and drinking, but Rob wasn’t a complete fool and it wasn’t long before he realized he was dominating the conversation.
“Look,” he said to Kenny, “if you can tell me something cool to see around here, I’m going to get up and give you and Uncle Bren some time to talk.”
“Uh, there’s a record store around the corner and an art store at the end of the block.”
Brendan stood up, pulled out his wallet and stuffed some money in Rob’s pocket.
“Go get yourself something decent, and don’t tell your mother we let you roam the city.”
“And take your phone with you,” Kenny reminded him.
Rob nodded his head and his hair bobbed in his face.
“I think I’ll get myself a hat,” he reflected, and making a salute, he headed out the door.
It was a few moments later, when they heard the door at the bottom of the stair close, and Brendan could see Rob heading down the corner that Kenny cleared his throat, rubbed his hands together and said, “And now, for us.”
Kenny had always been tall and athletic, sort of like a rugby player with his thick dark red curls, strong limbs and yes, excellent ass, the first thing Brendan had noticed when he had followed Kenny into the apartment. There was silver at his temples and Brendan thought, “We’re getting old now. Older at least. And Kenny is a year old than me.” He looked the same except older and the age looked good, like he’d grown into himself and the boy Kenny Brendan had known and loved and lain with for so many years was a shadow of this Kenneth McGrath.
“I know you, Brendan Miller. I’ve known you for years.”
Brendan blinked at the ceiling. His left arm was twined with Kenny’s right, the side of Kenny’s body was pressed to his. He’d always been the thin one, and Kenny had always had that athlete’s body, the sturdy flesh on beautiful thighs and rounded, dimpled buttocks, even his curly hair, well rounded, athletic hair, rugby playing hair.
“Well, then do you know what I’m about to say, now?”
“Do I want to hear this?”
“You’re going back to Rossford,” Brendan turned to him.
“What?”
“I’ve been working on this case, This isn’t fair.”
“What does fair have to do with anything?” Kenny said. “The only time we had a fair relationship was when we weren’t with each other. No…”
“Kenny.”
Kenny lay back in bed pulling the covers over him.
“No,” Kenny said.
Brendan sat in his chair, aware that today he’d worn the trousers and the dress shirt that Kenny always loved, even worn a tie as if he was going to work. Kenny always loved those things. And he looked Kenny up and down. Kenny in his tee shirt with his well muscled arms coming out of them, and then his eyes traveled, frankly, to the bulge between his blue jeaned legs planted wide apart. He remembered going into a honky tonkg in southern Indiana with Kenny and dancing with him delighting in hips that swiveled and moved about long before Luke Bryan ever got on a stage and did thing.
“You look so fucking good,” Brendan said, frankly.
“There have been times,” he told Brendan, “when I let you have the illusion of running things. And you may be a great attorney and everything. But this time I put my foot down. We stay together. Some people are okay single, but we’re no good apart. We’ll work out something, but whatever we work out involves us being together.
“And now I’m going to bed.”
When Brendan sat upright, his fingers linked, he heard Kenny say, “And you can go back to work.”
Brendan raised an eyebrow, looked at the form of Kenny covered in a blanket, and then climbed out of bed, reaching for his underwear and trousers.
He held that memory, tracing the form of Kenny’s body in those days before Sheridan, when Kenny McGrath was his only love.
“Why did you not want to see me?” Bren asked him. “Why, after writing, when I said I wanted to see you did you put it off?”
Kenny said, “Why didn’t you ever return my letters?”
“My questions first, though.”
“Fine,” Kenny replied. They were both speaking in almost whispers. “But in the end you had better answer mine.
“I wrote you because I always think about you,” Kenny said. “I think about you everyday. The thinking got to be too much.”
“What happened to Jonathan?”
“Nothing happened to him. We had some good years,” Kenny said. “But I don’t think I’m really meant for anyone. I would say I can’t make things last, but maybe I can make them last just long enough. You know? When things ended, I wasn’t sad about it?”
“Were you sad when things ended with Ruthven?”
“I don’t know that things were ever serious enough with Ruthven to say they ended, and as far as I know he’s still with Logan. Imagine that.”
“Well, then what about us?” Brendan said.
“You’re asking a lot of questions when you were just supposed to ask one.”
“Alright,” Brendan said, running a finger under his lower lip. “But answer me anyway. Were you sad when we ended?”
“Bren, I don’t even know when we ended. Did we end when I followed you to Chicago and almost died here? Or did we end when you came back to Rossford and we tried to live together.”
“I feel like we ended the night I came into the house and Ruthven was fucking you.”
“No,” Kenny said, nonplussed. “We were already over. We were over and I had already had an affair with Chad, and you already knew about it and, though you never talk about it, I’m sure you’d already fucked Sheridan a couple of times.”
Brendan opened his mouth and Kenny said, “But why fling mud at each other when the real point is I have no idea when we were ending, but I know when we were definitely over, and didn’t you feel a relief?”
“No,” Brendan said, and wondered if that was true.”
“I did,” Kenny said. “I was sad, but I felt like I’d been trying to hold us together for years.”
“I held us together.” Brendan insisted.
“Did you?”
“Of course.”
“How could you? You were always busy flying away.
“But,” Kenny went on before Brendan could say anything else, “you asked me why I wrote you and it was because I couldn’t stop thinking of you. And, I certainly did wonder if you ever thought about me.”
“Of course I think about you.”
“Maybe,” Kenny said. “But what was the other question you had for me?”
“Why you didn’t call me back?”
“Because what was the point in talking?” Kenny said. “And what was the point in looking back? I know why I was looking back. My present was gone. Jonathan was gone and it made me miss the past. And you are the past. So you were in my thoughts. I couldn’t stop thinking about you. And I realized, when we talked, that this was stupid. But now you should answer my question. Why are you here?”
“Because,” Bren began, then started over, “Because.”
“I’ve never seen you in a courtroom, but if this is how you are… I’m amazed at your career. And by the way, does Sheridan know you’re here? I mean, you brought Rob, so you’ve been to Rossford. Did you tell Sheridan you were going to Rossford, and then come up here?”
Brendan blinked at him and Kenny said, “Well, is that what happened?”
“Sort of,” Brendan admitted.
“Well, why didn’t you tell Sheridan?”
“I don’t know.”
“Sure you do.”
When Brendan said nothing, Kenny said, “The thing about you, Bren, is you’ve always been able to keep your own counsel when you want to. That’s how you and Sheridan are alike. You’re both very secretive. I wonder how many secrets you keep from each other.”
“Are you through?”
“Did you come here to fuck me?”
Brendan said, “I don’t know.”
Now Brendan realized Kenny had been looking at him like a cat with a canary, and Kenny had never been like that. Bren had always been the powerful one. But suddenly the look on Kenny’s face changed, and he said, “Well…. Do you want to?”
“Huh?” Bren blinked, looking instantly confused.
For a bit Brendan’s mouth was dry. He looked Kenny up and down.
“I was thinking about that time… at the gay honkey tonk. You had those faded black jeans on. I was thinking about a lot of stuff. I’ve been thinking about it. Since you wrote me. All the way up here. I wondered if I would feel the same way.”
Brendan didn’t speak, but Kenny looked at the floor and saw Brendan’s foot doing that frantic tapping—like Thumper from Bambi—that was a dead giveaway.
“If I told you,” Kenny began, “to go to bed with me… you would do it? You would look at your watch, think about how soon Rob was coming back, and then decide we would fuck in my bedroom?
“I always thought I had no power,” Kenny said. “The whole time we were together I always thought I loved you more than you loved me—”
“That’s not—”
“And it might be true,” Kenny said. “But I know that I always had the power in one way. And I’ve decided, that’s a power I’m not going to give up right now. We’re not going to have sex. I think maybe I wrote you because I wanted you. And I do want you, but I want you the way Chay still has Sheridan… Or Fenn has Tom. I was hoping that after sex and marriage there would be something left of us. Is there?”
Brendan had listened like one enchanted, his mouth a little open, passing a vague judgment on everything Kenny said, knowing that whatever Kenny wanted, he would indeed have given Kenny. And he had to catch up to Kenny’s question. It was a moment before he said, “Yes, Ken. Of course there’s something else left of us.”
“Great,” Kenny said. “Then why don’t we put on our coats, go outside and find out what it is.”
They walked up and down passing the tall brownstones and going in and out of shops and Kenny said, “Why are we walking around like tourist when we both live here?”
“But I thought you said you were leaving?”
“I got a job at Vine Tech in Gary in the art department. I was thinking of living in Rossford.”
“Or you could stay here?”
“For the joy of Chicago? You’ve got a point. When I was here for you I didn’t love it. But here for me, it’s something else.”
“For the joy of Chicago and for the joy of me,” Brendan said. “I like being with you.”
“Bren, do you realize we’ve never just been friends. That never really happened between us.”
“Are you sure?” Brendan said. Then, “I think you’re right. What does that mean?”
“Maybe it means we should try it and see what happens.”
“I’d like that,” Brendan nodded.
Both their phones rang, and they pulled them out of their pockets, but Brendan said, “It’s Rob.”
“I’ll pick up. Where are you?” Kenny asked him. “Alright. We’re actually around the corner. Come back with you tonight?”
Kenny turned to Brendan.
“Rob wants to know if I’ll come back with you guys to Rossford?”
“Why not?” Bren said. “Don’t you think those pictures can live without for one night?”
Under Kenny’s guidance they rode the Blue Line to Clark and from Clark they walked underground to the Randolph Street Station. They got tacos from a vender that Kenny pronounced as, “Overpriced and absolute shite,” and then they got their tickets and boarded the South Shore for Miller. Dena was there to meet them, and she said, “Oh, hell, which one of you bought Rob a set of paints?”
On the way home, Kenny sat in the front seat and Dena kept looking back at Bren, and he knew what her eyes were asking. After a while it was Kenny who said, “Nothing happened, Dena.”
“I don’t know what you mean?” Dena said in the most pleasant impersonation of a middle class white woman she could muster.
“He means they didn’t have sex,” Rob said flatly.
Rob looked at Bren and murmured, “And God knows I gave you time.”
They decided to eat dinner at Dena and Milo’s. Maggie was coming over with her husband Edward and their baby. Layla and Will would not be there because they were going out with her older sister Caroline. Kenny would stay in the spare bedroom they always kept for him, Brendan said he wanted to run over to Fenn’s real quick, talk for a moment and get a change of clothing. He loved living in Chicago, but it was energizing to be back among his friends in Rossford and still, he reminded himself, he needed to go visit his mother. He was reminding himself of this very thing when he stepped through Fenn and Todd’s kitchen door and saw, gun on the kitchen table, his black uniform still on, Sheridan.
Fenn looked from the gun to Brendan, to Rafe coming into the room, and as if it were nothing at all, Fenn picked up the gun and put it on top of the refrigerator.
“Are you surprised to see me?” Sheridan said.
“I thought you weren’t coming till tomorrow,” Brendan bent down and kissed Sheridan.
Rafe threw an arm around Brendan’s waist and he said, “Hey, little man.”
“Dad said we should come right away and see you.”
“That’s great,” Brendan said. “Sort of a surprise because I was on my way to dinner at Dena’s.”
“We could all go,” Sheridan said. “I’d love to see Dena.”
“I don’t know if its right to surprise her like that,” Brendan said. “I’ll just cancel.”
“No, no, why don’t we all go?”
“I have an idea,” Fenn said. “Since this is a surprise, and since you are here for the weekend a little early, how about Bren goes to dinner, and how bout you all stay here.”
“But I want to go with Dad,” Rafe said.
“Yes, but you have your father all the time,” Fenn said simply. “And sometimes parents need alone time just like you. You and your dad Sheridan can stay here, and Dad Brendan will go and talk to his friends and come back later.”
No one thought of questioning Fenn here, and Sheridan said, “Could we at least talk before you go to dinner?”
“Yes,” Brendan said.
Sheridan walked out of the kitchen, his hands shoved into his pockets and Brendan followed him out of the swinging door into the dining room.
Sheridan pulled out an envelope and Brendan saw Kenny’s address on it. It was the envelope to the letter and Sheridan whispered, “Where the fuck have you been all day, Bren?”
“On the train.”
“I know you’ve been the fuck on the train,” Sheridan hissed.
“Did I need to mention that I made a round trip to Chicago?”
“Don’t fucking lawyer me. Where did you go?”
“To see Kenny,” Brendan shook his head. “You told me I should see him.”
“But it seems like you sneaked off to see him, Bren.”
“How could I sneak off. I took Rob. Everyone knew where I was going. You knew I was going.”
“I didn’t know you were going today. To spend the day with him.”
“I’m not entirely sure where you get off,” Brendan began, “because I’m pretty sure everyone you ever climbed into bed with you still go and visit whenever you want to.”
“Yeah, you’re probably right,” Sheridan said. “But you also know I’m going. They aren’t writing me secret letters, and I’m not fucking them, Bren. In fact, you are. Remember last year. And I remember when you got in the shower after me, smelling like Casey because you’d been fucking Casey.”
“Really, Sheridan?” Bren looked at him savagely. “You’re really going to go back to that night.”
Sheridan turned his head.
“And keep your fucking voice down!” Brendan went on. And I’m not fucking anyone. But you.”
“Then why keep it a secret?” Sheridan demanded.
“I’m not fucking Kenny.”
“Then, again,” Sheridan said, “why keep it a secret?”
“If I’d really kept it a secret, you wouldn’t be standing her bitching and maybe the reason I didn’t tell you exhibits itself in the fact that my crazy husband left work, drove to Chicago and then greeted me with a gun on the table.”
“Or maybe, Mr. High Price Lawyer, the reason you didn’t exhibits itself in the fact that you’re plain, flat out, fucking guilty.”
“Are you guys fighting?” Rafe stuck his head out of the door.
“Yes,” Sheridan said while Brendan lied, “No.”
“Come back in the kitchen,” Fenn said, tiredly, and Rafe obeyed him.
“And I’ll tell you something else,” Brendan said, “I’m going to go upstairs, take a leak, splash some water on my face, get a hit of cologne and go out and—so you don’t think anything else is being hidden from you—Kenny will be there. Yup. He’s gonna be there.”
“Well,” Sheridan followed Brendan out of the dining room, into the living room and to the stairwell, “I hope you enjoy him sucking your dick.”
“Yeah, Sher,” Brendan said offhandedly, “I hope I do too.”
MORE SOON. TOMORROW, ELEGY