surge said:
I don't think Andrew and Justin were bad portrayals of gay people. I love that there can be a bad boy non stereotypical gay character.
They also did make Andrews character good from season 3 up.
I agree, and anyone who uses Andrew or a couple other gay characters on a show as proof that Marc Cherry is a "self-loathing" gay man whose portrayals of gay men are doing a great amount of harm to people are focusing too intensely on Andrew's mistakes (he's a teenager, for crying out loud!) and are clearly in a cave during the scenes with so many of the other characters. The pharmacist George killed Bree's late husband, the aforementioned Carlos has been known to be violent, Paul Young murdered one of the neighors. Susan accidentally burned down Edie's house, the same way as Andrew's incident with the car and Gaby's mother-in-law was also an accident. I could go on and on, but honestly people need to get over their problem with the gay characters on this show. There are far worse shows, and far worse gay Republicans, like Chris Crain, for starters.
I might have agreed somewhat about Andrew and that creepy neighbor (who I don't consider "gay", and I don't think as many people think he is as some here fear) 10 years ago, when we had very few ongoing gay characters on TV and every gay character had to be so perfect, perfectly written, etc., but I think we're safely past that.
I remember when Mike Delaney and Kevin Sheffield first debuted on AMC. They were non-stereotypical, etc., etc. After that people would point out after that every time there was an effeminate gay man on the show, but only because Mike and Kevin's characters brought attention to the way every character was portrayed, because otherwise, they would know that effeminate gay characters were nothing new to AMC (showing up in minor roles
long before we had the pretty masculine Mike and Dr. Brad, and not overtly effeminate Kevin and station worker Rudy), and in case they hadn't noticed (hello!) there are actually effeminate gay men in real life.
It almost turns into a demand on TV shows that come off as saying that effeminate gay people aren't deserving of representation.
Well, all I can say is lighten up a bit, and those are my two cents.
P.S -- I just checked out your profile, Surge, and I totally agree -- Shawn Ashmore is
HOT!! Although I'm not so sure he'd appreciate being the head on those photo manips, although I'm sure he knows it happens... ehehe
