People don't have to say what they're really thinking for you to know what they're really thinking. Just watch how they live their life, and how much they try to prove themselves one way or the other.
We had a guy here for awhile. His pet theory was that nearly every man was gay. Not "a little bi", not "maybe he'll let you suck him off after ten drinks" - gay. And of course, it was all completely obvious if you just looked for it. Why would any man be friends with a gay man unless he were gay himself? ("Like attracts like", as he enjoyed pointing out.) And why would any man NOT be friends with a gay man unless he were gay himself? (Scared of dealing with his own sexuality, you see.)
We started compiling a list with him of "signs a guy is gay and closeted" - assigning positive scores for "positive signs" and negative ones for negative. It was more a joke on his end, but he was quite serious about it. And guess what?
There wasn't a single trait we could come up with that he felt deserved a negative score. From the car you drive to the music you listen to, whether it's a gay stereotype or not, it's all a clear sign that you like-y the dick-y.
He began staging mini-interventions for his "clearly-gay-but-closeted" friends, begging them to break up with their wives and girlfriends and live "as they really were". He was pretty bummed, because "apparently they all choose the closet and fake-normalcy to facing the truth." And he got quite defensive whenever somebody questioned that hey, maybe some of these guys were actually straight. "Oh, so you think nobody lives in the closet? You jusr believe everything guys tell you? Cone on - I was there. I KNOW what they're doing."
I'm sensing a kinship here.
Do I care about how I'm viewed by others? Sure. Even when I buy my T-shirts with oddball cartoon characters on them, I'm hoping other people like them. And I spill ketchup on the one I'm wearing at home, I change before I go out. (If I truly didn't care, I presumably would leave it on.) But I think that's kind of par for the course for people in general, and I don't think it indicates a self-image problem on my part. Do gay guys have self-image problems more often than straight guys? Can't say. Yeah, I've seen some gay guys at clubs or the gym who seem to be doing some major over-compensating, but I could go down the block and see straight men and women doing the same thing.
Lex