The Original Gay Porn Community - Free Gay Movies and Photos, Gay Porn Site Reviews and Adult Gay Forums

  • Welcome To Just Us Boys - The World's Largest Gay Message Board Community

    In order to comply with recent US Supreme Court rulings regarding adult content, we will be making changes in the future to require that you log into your account to view adult content on the site.
    If you do not have an account, please register.
    REGISTER HERE - 100% FREE / We Will Never Sell Your Info

    PLEASE READ: To register, turn off your VPN (iPhone users- disable iCloud); you can re-enable the VPN after registration. You must maintain an active email address on your account: disposable email addresses cannot be used to register.

  • The Support & Advice forum is a no-flame zone.
    The members offering support and advice do so with the best intention. If you ask for advice, we don't require you to take the advice, but we do ask that you listen and give it consideration.

Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do?

onetimething

Porn Star
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Posts
387
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I wasn't sure whether to put this under Health and Well Being or Comng Out, so a mod can feel free to move this.

I met up with a guy off of Craig's List around two years ago and we hooked up several times. We would chat online and stayed in touch after I left the area. Over the past two years, we've become somewhat closer just through long online chats. We have a lot in common and I think for both of us, we are each other's sole consistent gay confidante in that we are both closeted (I'm bi, he is gay).

My friend is from India. He has been in the US now for around seven years, having come over for college and is currently pursuing his MBA while working full-time. He is of the age where his family back home in India have been putting pressure on him to get married. He tried to stall them, saying that he didn't have the money to return to India for a wedding or introduction, that he couldn't take the time off of work, that he'd get married when he finished his degree, that he just didn't want to get married, etc.; basically anything he could throw at them to buy him some time. They have really upped the ante over the past year and basically told him that they will find him a woman and he WILL get married by the end of the year. He had been terrified of coming out because he honestly feared violence from his family. I guess his mother had caught him when he was a young kid (around 12) in a compromising position with a male neighbor and tried to commit suicide. He didn't view coming out as an option as he was afraid of something similar happening, or of them harming him. So he would run through all these crapshoot ideas, such as even finding an Indian lesbian to marry for a marriage of convenience, but in the end, willed up the strength to come out to them on his most recent visit home.

He came out to them and the reaction was not good, but I suppose wasn't as horrific as it could have been, as it was not met with violence. However, the parents are convinced that he is ill and while he was in India, took him to multiple doctors and have forced him to undergo "negative reinforcement" training which is a fancy word for electro-shock therapy. To my horror, there are actual doctors here in the US who still perform this in an effort to "cure" homosexuality. My friend felt he had no choice but to agree. While he was over in India, before coming out, his parents brought over eight separate girls as potential brides. After coming out, his mother lost 20 lbs in two weeks from not eating out of sadness. His brother threatened his life telling him that if he did anything to make their mother ill, he will personally kill him. He took this as a legitimate threat.

My friend came back to this country wishing he had never come out. He was more depressed than ever before. Basically, they're convinced that this is just a sickness and told him that he has one year to "get better" or he will lose his family forever. My friend is a smart man and knows his homosexuality cannot be cured, but feels trapped by his family. He talks to them several times a day and they are forever questioning about his treatment and about a new bride and such. Basically, he feels stuck. He feels that losing his family is simply not an option, but by the same token, he can't see possibly marrying a woman and living a lie, especially as that just postpones the problem in that once he gets married, the parents pressure him to have children.

Since I am American, not Indian, when he tells me of the latest events, I find myself just baffled and not really understanding the situation. To me, someone who is not close with my family, I say "screw 'em" and can't understand how he could be so close to people who treat him the way his family does, the people who bring him so much pain and shame just for being who he is and do not understand why they claim to be concerned for his happiness in wanting him to get married, but clearly are not. I feel like they're in India and he is here for the indefinite future. He does not HAVE to answer to them. He is a grown man with a degree, his own place, a good job, his own money, etc. I don't see what bargaining chips they have over him. I do not understand why his family's desire for him to get married causes such consternation because from my American way of thinking, I say "just tell them 'no' and go on and live your life here" and expect that to be the end of it, but he always responds with "you don't understand, you're not Indian" and there's really nothing I can say to that.

Talks of suicide have been creeping into our conversations with much greater frequency than ever before, especially in the past week. He just feels hopeless. His family shows no reason whatsoever. This electro-shock therapy of course is dangerous, and not just that, but expensive. They don't care that he/they can't afford it. They want him to move to Portland where there are cousins who they feel will look after him (i.e. watch him like a hawk and won't let him do anything gay), paying no mind or care to his job or school or the economy. I try to hold my tongue as much as possible in criticizing them when talking to him, but honestly, they just sound horrible. I'm starting to get very scared for my friend's well-being, but really just don't know what to say to him anymore. He is somewhat alone down in Virginia where he lives. There are no family, he has few close friends, no boyfriend, etc. I really feel it would benefit him if he could somehow at least meet other gay Indians in the area who could perhaps understand and empathize more with his situation and offer better advice. It's to the point though where I'm just getting really worried, where for example now after having not heard from him in a couple of days, I found myself going to the local newspaper website to see if there were any stories about a body being found.

I know this was a long read, but is there anyone out there with any advice on this scenario?
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

I say "just tell them 'no' and go on and live your life here" and expect that to be the end of it, but he always responds with "you don't understand, you're not Indian" and there's really nothing I can say to that.

I try to hold my tongue as much as possible in criticizing them when talking to him, but honestly, they just sound horrible.

It seems your previous advice to him has been "soft" if you haven't told him the family is made up of complete assholes. He needs to realize he has his money so he has no need for them. None. Really, none.

Ask him to explain why he needs them. Ask him for a list or something specific. Don't let him off with the "you don't understand line." If he's a smart guy, he'll see he's only a slave to bullshit culture expectations.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

I wasn't sure whether to put this under Health and Well Being or Comng Out, so a mod can feel free to move this.

I met up with a guy off of Craig's List around two years ago and we hooked up several times. We would chat online and stayed in touch after I left the area. Over the past two years, we've become somewhat closer just through long online chats. We have a lot in common and I think for both of us, we are each other's sole consistent gay confidante in that we are both closeted (I'm bi, he is gay).

My friend is from India. He has been in the US now for around seven years, having come over for college and is currently pursuing his MBA while working full-time. He is of the age where his family back home in India have been putting pressure on him to get married. He tried to stall them, saying that he didn't have the money to return to India for a wedding or introduction, that he couldn't take the time off of work, that he'd get married when he finished his degree, that he just didn't want to get married, etc.; basically anything he could throw at them to buy him some time. They have really upped the ante over the past year and basically told him that they will find him a woman and he WILL get married by the end of the year. He had been terrified of coming out because he honestly feared violence from his family. I guess his mother had caught him when he was a young kid (around 12) in a compromising position with a male neighbor and tried to commit suicide. He didn't view coming out as an option as he was afraid of something similar happening, or of them harming him. So he would run through all these crapshoot ideas, such as even finding an Indian lesbian to marry for a marriage of convenience, but in the end, willed up the strength to come out to them on his most recent visit home.

He came out to them and the reaction was not good, but I suppose wasn't as horrific as it could have been, as it was not met with violence. However, the parents are convinced that he is ill and while he was in India, took him to multiple doctors and have forced him to undergo "negative reinforcement" training which is a fancy word for electro-shock therapy. To my horror, there are actual doctors here in the US who still perform this in an effort to "cure" homosexuality. My friend felt he had no choice but to agree. While he was over in India, before coming out, his parents brought over eight separate girls as potential brides. After coming out, his mother lost 20 lbs in two weeks from not eating out of sadness. His brother threatened his life telling him that if he did anything to make their mother ill, he will personally kill him. He took this as a legitimate threat.

My friend came back to this country wishing he had never come out. He was more depressed than ever before. Basically, they're convinced that this is just a sickness and told him that he has one year to "get better" or he will lose his family forever. My friend is a smart man and knows his homosexuality cannot be cured, but feels trapped by his family. He talks to them several times a day and they are forever questioning about his treatment and about a new bride and such. Basically, he feels stuck. He feels that losing his family is simply not an option, but by the same token, he can't see possibly marrying a woman and living a lie, especially as that just postpones the problem in that once he gets married, the parents pressure him to have children.

Since I am American, not Indian, when he tells me of the latest events, I find myself just baffled and not really understanding the situation. To me, someone who is not close with my family, I say "screw 'em" and can't understand how he could be so close to people who treat him the way his family does, the people who bring him so much pain and shame just for being who he is and do not understand why they claim to be concerned for his happiness in wanting him to get married, but clearly are not. I feel like they're in India and he is here for the indefinite future. He does not HAVE to answer to them. He is a grown man with a degree, his own place, a good job, his own money, etc. I don't see what bargaining chips they have over him. I do not understand why his family's desire for him to get married causes such consternation because from my American way of thinking, I say "just tell them 'no' and go on and live your life here" and expect that to be the end of it, but he always responds with "you don't understand, you're not Indian" and there's really nothing I can say to that.

Talks of suicide have been creeping into our conversations with much greater frequency than ever before, especially in the past week. He just feels hopeless. His family shows no reason whatsoever. This electro-shock therapy of course is dangerous, and not just that, but expensive. They don't care that he/they can't afford it. They want him to move to Portland where there are cousins who they feel will look after him (i.e. watch him like a hawk and won't let him do anything gay), paying no mind or care to his job or school or the economy. I try to hold my tongue as much as possible in criticizing them when talking to him, but honestly, they just sound horrible. I'm starting to get very scared for my friend's well-being, but really just don't know what to say to him anymore. He is somewhat alone down in Virginia where he lives. There are no family, he has few close friends, no boyfriend, etc. I really feel it would benefit him if he could somehow at least meet other gay Indians in the area who could perhaps understand and empathize more with his situation and offer better advice. It's to the point though where I'm just getting really worried, where for example now after having not heard from him in a couple of days, I found myself going to the local newspaper website to see if there were any stories about a body being found.

I know this was a long read, but is there anyone out there with any advice on this scenario?

I think you need to have him speak with a professional a.s.a.p!!! Call a suicide hotline and see what they advise you to do.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

It seems your previous advice to him has been "soft" if you haven't told him the family is made up of complete assholes. He needs to realize he has his money so he has no need for them. None. Really, none.

Ask him to explain why he needs them. Ask him for a list or something specific. Don't let him off with the "you don't understand line." If he's a smart guy, he'll see he's only a slave to bullshit culture expectations.

We have to be respectful of other cultures, or else we're no better than those who choose to dehumanize and demean our cultures (sub or otherwise) in which we participate.

I was once dated a girl who was Hindi and we weren't even allowed to be alone; we had to always been in a social setting or otherwise (they had eyes everywhere). The best thing to do is research LGBT resources for non-American cultures that place high value on family.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Maybe he feels he has no one else. Does he have lots of friends here or are all his friends in India? Maybe he doesn't want to live here and wants a life in India. If he only has 1 or 2 friends here then that's not really enough people, especially if he's not really really close to them. How many friends does he have here that he connects with on a deep level. He probably got along great with his family before coming out. Imagine loosing everything you have, everything you've built in your life for the past 20+ years. You said you weren't close to your family but think about loosing everyone else you're close to. Even though he's lived 7 years here, this country is probably still foreign to him since it's so much different than India.

Those were just things that might help you understand where he's coming from but I wouldn't know what to do to help either. You should deffinately ask for proffesional advice and see what they think as soon as possible. You're a good friend for trying to help. Let him know you'll always be there for him.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Tell him to come to this site and read the thread about him.
Get him to seek opinions from people on this site.

He is smart ... etc but weak if he can't cut off his family for a while, and tell his family to communicate with him via emails ONLY.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

I'd say tell him to visit this site, and to try and seek out a therapist who might specialize in (or at least be familiar with) his situation.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

We have to be respectful of other cultures, or else we're no better than those who choose to dehumanize and demean our cultures (sub or otherwise) in which we participate.

Not buying it. There are shitty cultures. One that abuses and threatens people for consensual activities is one of them. It's really that simple.

I was once dated a girl who was Hindi and we weren't even allowed to be alone; we had to always been in a social setting or otherwise (they had eyes everywhere). The best thing to do is research LGBT resources for non-American cultures that place high value on family.

Or since the guy doesn't need them for financial support, he can tell them to go fuck themselves. If I threaten to kill you, that's me acting like a shit. "But it's a different culture" is just enabling abuse.

Eating different foods is an acceptable cultural difference. Electro-shock "therapy" is not. Threatening murder is not. Dictating the sex life of someone in their 20's and 30's is not.

There are people who are so narrow-minded they cannot accept that they cannot control other people. It's ridiculous that families anywhere in the world are meddling with marriage and sex of people in their 20's and 30's. That's just totalitarian.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

^yeah cultures are different but human feelings are all the same.

Sex wise, the final result is orgasm, cum ... etc. ;)
So cut out the culture excuses bull shit.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Welcome to the rest of the world.

It's very difficult for the western world to understand eastern cultures and how family is everything in this part of the world. It's also difficult to understand that you are expected to marry even if you are gay and continue having a boyfriend on the side.

Your friend is in a difficult situation. In this mind, he's still an Indian living in the US and not an Indian-American. His family is forcing him into a difficult choice. It's something that he needs to seek professional support to deal with- whether that be a support group or individual therapy.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Exactly. It surprises me how hard it is for Euro-Americans to see that individuality isnt the most sought after trait in the rest of the world.

You are telling him to reject his family and be his own person. Imagine someone telling you to abandon your own identity and just be party of a large family. Most of you would refuse. That's because individuality is valued more in our part of the world. However, in the rest of the world, the community and the family are more important than anything. Yes, this is horrible that his family threatens and pressures this gay indian to conform. But it's a reality of many queers of color. One that hasn't been spoken of really in Queer discourse.

As easy as it is for us to simply say "fuck them!" we should really evaluate what we are saying. We are asking him to abandon everything that has mattered to him.

Welcome to the rest of the world.

It's very difficult for the western world to understand eastern cultures and how family is everything in this part of the world. It's also difficult to understand that you are expected to marry even if you are gay and continue having a boyfriend on the side.

Your friend is in a difficult situation. In this mind, he's still an Indian living in the US and not an Indian-American. His family is forcing him into a difficult choice. It's something that he needs to seek professional support to deal with- whether that be a support group or individual therapy.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Gee, sounds a bit like Prayers for Bobby...

Ultimately, if his family doesn't accept him for whom he is, they will cut all ties with him, and that's that. He'll just have to deal with it. It might not be "right", but that's just the way it is. In this case, there might not be a better alternative than cutting all ties, and being independent, even if it means "Westernizing" him.

As for the suicide issues...this is serious stuff. He needs to seek counseling NOW. You will probably need to do the legwork to get him an appointment, but you need to do it. Both for him and for you.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

I agree I think some people here are being very insensitive. Some people are thinking from a Euro American western perspective. In South Asian culture the family is EVERYTHING. The individual's happiness is SECOND to the family's social status. The family of this Indian man may be fearful that the rest of the community may find out and they will be SHAMED.

I know it sounds different for Western people but to suggest this gay Indian man should give up his family and just desert them does not make sense. It is obvious this gay Indian man loves his family dearly. This is a tough situation.

I have a friend that is in a similar situation he can't come out to his family at least he doesn't feel he can.
And his family is thinking about marrying him off in an arranged marriage in a few years. So it is very tough.
I think your friend needs to be find other South Asian gay men for support.

I suggest the OP of this thread look for a South Asian or gay people of colour counselling centre or go to the LBGT community centre in your community. Try to see if you can find a LGBT specialist that deals with coming out for gays of colour.

Also look for books by South Asian gay writers for your friend. Or suggest to your friend to look for these books by himself. Also, another suggestion of course is look for a Suicide hotline or one of those telephone distress centre phone lines for your friend. Your friend needs help and support ASAP.

Be there for your friend listen to him and just support him. I am sure it is very hard for you to deal with this but definitely suggest that he get some help.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

I'd express your concern to him about his well being and that he can't keep up living how he's living. Unfortunately the men in his family aren't even willing to have any sympathy whatsoever for him. If they are so close, he should use that to his advantage to at least try to reach some common ground with them, even if they totally disagree with him.

I would definately stress that he either seek help or tell him that if he ever feels out of control to always contact you no matter what. Good luck
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Spencer how do you know that the Indian gay man has not tried to reach out to his male relatives? Maybe he already has? Remember in South Asian culture being homosexual is taboo. I know it is hard for American people to understand but in different parts of the world being homosexual is just not acceptable. In fact, some gay Indians are lucky to just be excommunicated by their families. There are some gay Indian men that encounter violence or potential threats of violence.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

When I said the men in his family, I meant his immediate family members. I know they aren't willing to have simpathy for him because his father and brother want to disown him.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

There is no middle ground here. He has two options here. He can renounce his sexuality, go back to India, and get married. Or he can stick by his sexuality, and get disowned. It's a horrible choice, but there isn't going to be any compromise here.

Lex
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

There is no middle ground here. He has two options here. He can renounce his sexuality, go back to India, and get married. Or he can stick by his sexuality, and get disowned. It's a horrible choice, but there isn't going to be any compromise here.

Lex

Basically. Given his culture, either choice is going to be really difficult for him, but I don't see any way of resolving it other than choosing one of the other.
 
Re: Friend is suicidal over being gay...what to do

Actually there is a third choice and that's the choice most closeted men take and that's living on the down low. Sure this Indian gay man could get married to a woman to please his family. However, he probably will have same sex desires and he may have men on the side.

Of course the third choice isn't fair to the wife or girlfriend but it's the decision some closeted men take. I can't say that I agree with that decision but I can understand it.

People have to remember in different parts of the world being gay is simply not acceptable under any terms. Some gays can be murdered or excommunicated. It is very hard for these men and sadly many of these men are gay men of colour. I kind of wish there were more services available specifically for gay men of colour because gay men of colour have specific needs. There is an intersection of race, culture, class, and sexuality these men have to negotiate between these spheres.
 
Back
Top