The Original Gay Porn Community - Free Gay Movies and Photos, Gay Porn Site Reviews and Adult Gay Forums

  • Welcome To Just Us Boys - The World's Largest Gay Message Board Community

    In order to comply with recent US Supreme Court rulings regarding adult content, we will be making changes in the future to require that you log into your account to view adult content on the site.
    If you do not have an account, please register.
    REGISTER HERE - 100% FREE / We Will Never Sell Your Info

    PLEASE READ: To register, turn off your VPN (iPhone users- disable iCloud); you can re-enable the VPN after registration. You must maintain an active email address on your account: disposable email addresses cannot be used to register.

  • The Support & Advice forum is a no-flame zone.
    The members offering support and advice do so with the best intention. If you ask for advice, we don't require you to take the advice, but we do ask that you listen and give it consideration.

How to succeed with closeted guys

trikky

Slut
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Posts
246
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
uk
Ok so I have been noticing a recurring theme over the last month in the threads which is pretty much either a closeted guy (cg) who wants to make a move on another cg, or an out guy wanting to move on a cg. Same applies to curious guys.
So far the only advice anyone gives is come out to them and wait to see if they do the same. Whereas this may be the best option in the long term, some guys are not ready for that yet and so I thought this thread might give some alternative ideas. I'm thinking mainly of you college dudes. There is no rocket science here just common sense but that often gets overlooked where emotions are involved. I have found that these things work for me and I have tried to condense this into a few principles that might help. Remember though this is for situations where a guy has ALREADY shown interest by his actions and you want to take things forward without necessarily coming out at first until you are more sure about him or more confident yourself. This is not for those guys that hope a guy they fancy might be a CG. Please also no comments of just come out etc, this is not a thread for you guys it's for the guys that aren't quite there yet:

Discretion is the better part of valour -

If/When you were totally closeted and not ready to come out, would you be interested in a guy who was indiscrete in the way he flirted with you or reacted towards you, that would make his or your interest obvious to others? Would you be interested in the attentions of a guy who was blabbing to all his friends about you and his feelings and speculating on your sexuality with them? Often guys who are out forget what they thought when they were in the closet and don't give the CG the benefit of understanding his mindset, and don't act with discretion. If you're indiscrete with a closeted guy who is not ready to come out you'll get nowhere. Be discrete.

Silence is golden -

This is different from the above. This is about not confronting a guy with issues. There are plenty of guys out there who say, "yeah we both suck each others dicks but were both as straight as a die." A curious or CG may not have dealt with his issues about his own sexuality, and the last thing he is going to want is someone throwing those issues in his face. He might well be prepared to "fool around" with a guy as long as he can kid himself that he's straight so why burst his balloon? His issues are just that HIS. If he wants help with them later you can be there for him, but confronting a CG with issues up front will switch him off. This is why sometimes coming out to a CG doesn't help if he doesn't identify himself as gay yet.

Actions speak louder than words -

Sometimes I think people talk too much and analyse too much. Words can often be a huge passion killer. If the actions/ flirting show the guy is interested forget the talking about whether he is into you or gay or whatever and just let the actions speak. Just keep going in small steps until you meet resistance. The resistance is your cue that he isn't interested in going any further. The most important thing about this is that you are giving the guy a get out clause. He can go a long way with you and can always pretend that he was just joking/ fooling around if he gets nervous. If you say "I'm gay" your asking him to commit to saying the same which he may not be ready to do, and he can't fool around and pretend in that scenario. Less words more action.

Double or Quits

On the theme of get out clauses, get aquainted with the Double Entendre or innuendo. This is something we have a great tradition of in the UK. It is the art of saying things that have a double meaning, so you can say something suggestive whilst retaining an innocent get out clause. When used the right way it's very sexy. Try and keep them subtle though or they lose their appeal. Example: If a guy asks you if you wanna hang out you could say "yeah I'd like to see a bit more of you." If you get a funny look, keep a straight face. If he laughs or smiles give a slight sexy grin. Be subtle though.

Smart Casual

Lots of guys make asking a guy out too much of a big deal. Casual is the way to go. If you say "we should hang out sometime" you are more likely to get him to agree. You can then get specific about where and when once he's committed. Try and make any kind of plans etc casual when you ask then you are more likely to get agreement and if you don't build it up into a big deal in your mind you don't feel let down if he says no. Keep everything cool and casual between you.

Good luck guys and if anyone has anything to add please do.
 
Why would you want to "succeed" with a closeted guy, it's not gonna go anywhere. Guys with issues do not make for lasting relationships.

If you just want to fuck him, a six pack usually does the trick.
 
Yeah, I've always preferred making moves on guys who are already out. Sure, there's no "thrill of the hunt", but then again, you don't have to worry about keeping it down in the bedroom. ..|

Lex
 
Hey Tex a six pack only does the trick when you've already established your interest with the guy. You've gotta get there first. Also guys with issues resolve them, and your interest might be the catalyst for that. You've gotta stop seeing everything so black and white Tex.

Lex that's fine, but that's not what this thread is about. I enjoy the thrill of the hunt. The subtle flirting, the reactions, I don't want to make everything seem like a business transaction (I'm gay, you gay? yep lets go fuck. Not very sexy!)
 
your advice is awesome. thanks.

Actions speak louder than words -

Sometimes I think people talk too much and analyse too much. Words can often be a huge passion killer. If the actions/ flirting show the guy is interested forget the talking about whether he is into you or gay or whatever and just let the actions speak. Just keep going in small steps until you meet resistance. The resistance is your cue that he isn't interested in going any further. The most important thing about this is that you are giving the guy a get out clause. He can go a long way with you and can always pretend that he was just joking/ fooling around if he gets nervous. If you say "I'm gay" your asking him to commit to saying the same which he may not be ready to do, and he can't fool around and pretend in that scenario. Less words more action.

the other problem with this is that dudes often confuse actions for something more than they really are. for example some guys are naturally touchy feely and with these particular dudes, we can often think that a pat on the back or rub on the shoulder as a sign that he's into us when that is NOT the case at all. from here some guys take it to a level of fantasy where they truly believe that "affectionate dude" is in love with them or is a cg. i just don't like this kind of thinking but it happens all the time to people of any orientation.
 
Why would you want to "succeed" with a closeted guy, it's not gonna go anywhere. Guys with issues do not make for lasting relationships.

If you just want to fuck him, a six pack usually does the trick.

I agree! It's basically drama waiting to happen [-X
 
Hey Tex a six pack only does the trick when you've already established your interest with the guy. You've gotta get there first. Also guys with issues resolve them, and your interest might be the catalyst for that. You've gotta stop seeing everything so black and white Tex.

First off it's not being a stand up guy, going into a friendship with the intent of pushing some closeted guy into sex, that's being a user. Anyway we never know who is and isn't a closet case - because they won't tell you, they're in the closet. It's always a value judgment, gay men like to project closet status on some hot guy regardless of evidence, and reading most of the threads in here tells you how often the gay guy is wrong, and the other guy is straight. Just because we think someone is in the closet is no guarantee, and what happens when that hot guy you're trying to seduce freaks out and bashes your gay ass?

Second, I can do more for the closeted guy and his issues by being a friend whom he knows is a gay guy, whom he knows he can talk to, than I can by trying to fuck him and bringing all of his guilt and fear into the mix. It’s not fair to him to establish a friendship with the specific intent of fucking him, and it’s not fair to me to be some guy’s dirty little secret.

Third it’s not a black and white thing, it’s experience. Guys in the closet don’t have relationships; they have at best hookups. There is no relationship when one of you is hiding the other one, or both of you are hiding each other. I don't have much interest in playing a part in that kind of drama, I for damn sure am not going to get emotionally involved.

Fourth, it is being a stand up guy to respect someone’s boundaries and comfort level. If the guy hits on me, maybe I’d go for it, maybe not, depends on context, but I wouldn’t push. Never push. You and I don’t know what kind of demons closeted guys are carrying around in their heads, the chances for this to go spectacularly wrong are far higher than the chance of happily ever after.

So what do you do with a closeted guy? You make sure you’re living your life out, so he knows it can be done, you let him talk, you let him move at his own pace, you don’t confuse the issue, and then maybe, when he gets over his issues you can go for it. You definitely don’t put your sexual agenda ahead of your own peace of mind or his.
 
Lex that's fine, but that's not what this thread is about. I enjoy the thrill of the hunt. The subtle flirting, the reactions, I don't want to make everything seem like a business transaction (I'm gay, you gay? yep lets go fuck. Not very sexy!)

And what on earth makes you think you can't have "the thrill of the hunt" with guys you know are gay, and know aren't going to freak or run? I assure you you can, and if your thing is the unattainable guy, well, there are plenty of gay men you can chase that will have no interest in you.
 
>>>Lex that's fine, but that's not what this thread is about. I enjoy the thrill of the hunt. The subtle flirting, the reactions, I don't want to make everything seem like a business transaction (I'm gay, you gay? yep lets go fuck. Not very sexy!)

I find it extremely sexy. Simply because it cuts away the bullshit game. I like flirty banter as much as the next guy (as some people here will tell you), but that doesn't mean I have any need to play the game with closeted guys. I like to know the guy's on the team before making any overtures towards whether or not he wants to play. Maybe you like the "is he or isn't he lol idk", checking facebook, looking for clues game. I personally consider that a little lame even for high schoolers, and I can't imagine bothering with it in college. But hey, whatever floats your boat.

Lex
 
You know Trikky, and please don't take this as the wrong way, because I like your posts in here, and you're probably a really decent guy.

The things you're suggesting and the game your interested in discussing really sound like they're only relevant to a situation where both guys are in the closet and neither wants to get caught, or one guy is in the closet and doesn't want the other guy to know UNLESS, the closet guy can figure out if the other guy is gay FIRST.

Out gay men play games sure, all the dam time unfortunately, but not the ones above.

I love to flirt, but I want flirting back, you can be a subtle as you want, and I like the slow build up and a guy who makes it a challenge, but we both know the starting position of the other guy, we both know we both are gay. There is no ambiguity about that no matter how coy the other guy plays. That's a gay man's game.

What I don't like is all the subtext and ambiguity of first trying to establish if there's even a chance at interest, because he doesn't know I'm gay, and I don't know if he is, and I'm not willing to tell him, and he's not willing to tell me, then he tells someone else he's straight, then I don't believe him, and all the angsty drama that ensues when neither guy is willing to be honest. It's just not fun.
 
Quote "First off it's not being a stand up guy, going into a friendship with the intent of pushing some closeted guy into sex, that's being a user. Anyway we never know who is and isn't a closet case - because they won't tell you, they're in the closet."

Tex please read my post again here is the appropriate quote " Remember though this is for situations where a guy has ALREADY shown interest by his actions" I'm not suggesting forcing anyone or projecting onto guys.

Quote "Fourth, it is being a stand up guy to respect someone’s boundaries and comfort level. If the guy hits on me, maybe I’d go for it, maybe not, depends on context, but I wouldn’t push. Never push."

Tex you really haven't read my post with the stuff you are saying. this is what I said "Just keep going in small steps until you meet resistance. The resistance is your cue that he isn't interested in going any further." I'm not advocating pushing anyone.

Quote "What I don't like is all the subtext and ambiguity of first trying to establish if there's even a chance at interest, because he doesn't know I'm gay, and I don't know if he is, and I'm not willing to tell him, and he's not willing to tell me, then he tells someone else he's straight, then I don't believe him,"

Come on now tex I don't believe that you've half read my thread. You talk about establishing if there's even a chance and he tells someone he's straight etc where in my thread was any of that discussed? My thread made it clear that this is about when a closeted guy had established interest already by his actions, and you are treating it as if I'm telling guys to project on to everyone and push guys who aren't interested. This is so far from what I said. Please reread my thread.

quote "and what happens when that hot guy you're trying to seduce freaks out and bashes your gay ass?"

Again you're making the same wrong assertions that I'm telling guys to come on to people at random.

Quote "the other problem with this is that dudes often confuse actions for something more than they really are. for example some guys are naturally touchy feely and with these particular dudes, we can often think that a pat on the back or rub on the shoulder as a sign that he's into us when that is NOT the case at all. from here some guys take it to a level of fantasy where they truly believe that "affectionate dude" is in love with them or is a cg. i just don't like this kind of thinking but it happens all the time to people of any orientation.

Thanks for your input Jude. You make a valid point and it is a judgement call whether a guy is generally more touchy feeley or interested.

Ok guys if you've read this thread please post whether you think I'm totally off base with what I've said.
 
Tex, as I've said to you before I like reading your posts, and I know you have an uncompromising attitude when it comes to all things gay, but I sometimes wonder whether you always felt that way. I can see from your posts how you have embraced being out and proud, but I'm sure that there was a time when you were closeted and not ready to see the light. Being out is clearly the only way to go in the long run, but don't forget the guys out there who are in the closet and for whatever reason aren't ready to come out. Should they be written off just because they can't come out? Are they any less valid as gay guys just because they can't yet say I'm gay?

Most of the people who read these threads are closeted (my opinion) so your message of don't bother with closeted guys really means don't bother with the guys who are reading on this forum.

On a personal note I am currently getting serious interest from a guy who I know is closeted at least at work (where I met him.) I apply all of the above, discretion etc which is why I believe he felt comfortable enough with me to show his interest. I've no intention of shaking him out of the closet. In his own time he will get comfortable enough to make his descisions and until then I am quite happy with the situation.
 
Good points on both sides of the issue (as usual I take the middle ground because I still have one foot in the closet)

Though, I'm wondering if you can clarify this part: "Remember though this is for situations where a guy has ALREADY shown interest by his actions' I'm not suggesting forcing anyone or projecting onto guys."

What actions show interest? Eye flirting? Many closeted guys are extremely subtle about showing interests that it sometimes drives me and other guys insane trying to figure out if that was even a sign of interest in the first place. More irritating still many are afraid of "giving themselves away" in public.

This is an important thread though many gay/bi guys (dare I say even the majority) are still stuck in the closet. Darn homophobic American society! :grrr: That's for another thread.
 
erobert as regards "Interest" I was making the assumption that it was obvious that the guy was gay and closeted and interested in you in my original thread, which is why I suggested the above. Maybe you could start a thread on that question.

Quote "More irritating still many are afraid of "giving themselves away" in public"

Thank you for that observation, that's exactly my point. Closeted guys don't want /are ready to come out and you need to offer them a safe environment if you want to get anywhere with them.
 
erobert as regards "Interest" I was making the assumption that it was obvious that the guy was gay and closeted and interested in you in my original thread, which is why I suggested the above. Maybe you could start a thread on that question.

Quote "More irritating still many are afraid of "giving themselves away" in public"

Thank you for that observation, that's exactly my point. Closeted guys don't want /are ready to come out and you need to offer them a safe environment if you want to get anywhere with them.

But how are the closeted guys supposed to if the guy we want to show an intrest in is gay? Not all out gay people act super feminine and talk with a lisp, and personally those are not my type of guys. The precise reason they "don't want to give themselves away in public" is because they don't want to send the right signals to the wrong guy. And you've already said that just outright saying "I'm gay" to a suspected closeted guy is not the best way to go. For some it is.....for most it isn't. It all depends on luck really. And even if I was 100% out, I wouldn't go around telling random people I'm gay, only my friends and family would know, so do you see how this adds to the degree of difficulty? For example, if two out gay guys meet and are interested in each other, how are they going to go about expressing that interest if they don't know that the other is gay and out as well? As I've said, out gay guys don't just go up to you and say," Hey I'm gay!" And I'm sure they're friends and family don't go around telling random people either, so how are the closeted gay guys supposed to know who's out and how are the out gay guys supposed to know who's closeted? If you could be more detailed it would realy help a lot.
 
/\ you bring up some important questions and points such as all gay guys (in or out of the closet) don't act feminine and are just normal, everyday guys. Get the gay stereotypes out of your head because half of that stuff isn't true.

Secondly, gay men don't go around saying "Hi I'm gay." when they meet you, that usually doesn't happen. Unfortunately, there's no one way to tell if a guy is gay unless they mention it during your conversation or they drop small hints. Usually when I hear the word "girlfriend" (past or present) that's usually a sign the guy is straight or potentially bi. Just get to know them over a few weeks if you like them, you can get a better feeling after hanging out with them.

There's other ways to tell but they are very subtle and sometimes your splitting hairs. Out gay men are a bit easier to determine than closeted gay men on average.

Drop one or two flirty hints and watch his reaction carefully, if they respond with positively or get a bit flirty than you've probably got your answer. Flirting in public with people you don't know that well can be interpreted as confident or creepy so be careful.This is hard to explain and it comes from experience. You'll know when they're interested in you (out or not) Also, there are a lot of bi-curious and bi guys out there. Sexuality is not black and white but rather shades of gray.

Finally, just as a rule of thumb always use your intuition and think with your head in uncertain situations when meeting someone who strikes your interest, easier said than done when the guy is hot but still use your brain.

OK, enough blather for now.
 
Actions speak louder than words. I've recently had interest from guys who don't appear gay except for their actions. After a while you get a feel for whether someone is interested. The easiest one is eye contact. A guy who keeps making eye contact could be interested (unless he thinks he recognises you from somewhere) but this is why taking things in small steps is important in case you are wrong.
He makes lots of eye contact, so do you, and smile at the dude, and see if he smiles back. There are smiles and smiles. You know the difference. the eyes are the windows to the soul.
Keep eye contact as you chat. If the words my girlfriend come up back off.

Gentle touch is next. After eye contact gets returned the next step is a gentle touch usually on the arm which must seem natural. This will get a reaction. Either he's comfortable or not with it. If he gets jumpy or uncomfortable back off. If he's cool it still may not mean anything but the point is that you go through a sequence of gentle steps to see how comfortable he is. This cuts both ways because guys that are interested in you will use the same techniques, and you'll recognise them. There are various things people have tried on me but the third is when they don't ask outright if you have a girlfriend they make some vague comment that assumes you have a girlfriend and wait to see your reaction or whether you take the opportunity to correct them. I personally hate that one, and never really respond right on it unless I really like the guy. The alternative is when the gay subject suddenly gets introduced which can be done many ways. Maybe talking about your gay friend, or one guy told me he had been to the local gay festival and everyone kept asking him if he was gay or straight. I should have asked him what his answer was (hehe)
Again it's all about looking for reactions. The whole point of this is that you take small steps to effectively test the water and reactions without freaking out the other guy if you happen to be wrong and he's just friendly. A guy who's not interested will at some point give off those signals and then you back off.

If you smile at a guy when making eye contact his reaction will tell you a lot. I was smiling about something as I went into my gym and just happened to catch eyes with the young manager who I would say was 100% straight. He beamed back at me for a second then suddenly his face dropped. His reaction was an automatic human reaction of returning a smile, but then he must have thought to himself, shit that's a dude what am I smiling for. I wouldn't follow up on that or read that he was interested. But if you are a safe guy to be around, people will be more likely to be more open with you, that's my opinion. Small steps though.
 
I have to agree with Lex & Tex.

What's so silly about being closeted, is that we all think we're so clever and good at it.

But it's 2009, people, and friends and family (and even coworkers or fellow students) aren't dumb.

And the more you try to prove how hetero you are, the more embarrassing it is to everyone involved.

You closet cases are fooling no one.

Do you understand that?
 
"I'm too busy working to have a girlfriend": fools no one.

"I'm too busy working at school to have a girlfriend": fools no one.

"I just haven't found the right girl yet": fools no one.

Not discussing your personal life at school or work just clues people in that you are gay (or a child molester or something).

For some reason, closeted guys think that because they don't look like Liberace means that people automatically think they're straight.
 
Back
Top