PLEASE READ: To register, turn off your VPN (iPhone users- disable iCloud); you can re-enable the VPN after registration. You must maintain an active email address on your account: disposable email addresses cannot be used to register.
I think some of you all are overreacting...
There isn't a single homogeneous African-American culture either.There isn't a single homogenous American culture. There are many subcultures.
There are aspects of African-American culture that are different from other American subcultures, even if people who don't really know any African Americans may have an exaggerated image of the differences.
are you implying that they don't have weekly meetings wherein they all decide to like the exact same things?![]()
There are social conditions that give everyone a unique experience, not just blacks.
We are all individuals. Blacks are not one monolithic entity. There is no one "black experience"
So this idea of wanting a black friend is silly to me. Why black? How are you sure this black person is different from any other American? Do you see how just by making this request, one has already made the assumption that blacks are by nature different than other Americans?
The color of your skin does not change who you are as a person. Yes, it can affect the way you experience life, but it does not affect everyone the same and it does not make a difference for each black person.
It's generalizing and stereotyping an entire group of people. If you want a friend based off of this ONE attribute about them, let alone a minority status attribute, that's kind of fucked up.
So this idea of wanting a black friend is silly to me. Why black? How are you sure this black person is different from any other American? Do you see how just by making this request, one has already made the assumption that blacks are by nature different than other Americans?
What a fucking mess. I want to say something but I'm a bit speechless.
Italian American
Chinese American
Polish American
Mexican American
Pssssst.... now go to that other thread about a "down-low brotha!" and tell all of this stuff to the OP over there.
As I look over these posts, it seems clear that everything you said applies to you more than the OP here, who (to my knowledge) hasn't stated any specific stereotypes toward African Americans. Just vented that he'd like a Black friend and his small town doesn't give him the oppurtunity to make one.
I might have to agree with Travisevian here.
I never implied all black men were on the down low. But there's no doubt that more than a few are!
What would you learn from a black person that is identical in everything but his skin color? That sort of thinking is based on the assumption that color in itself creates a difference and it doesnt.
The one thing I hope the OP learns is that the color of someone's skin does not imply an inherent difference. I am a human being just like chace. Who I am is dictated by how I was raised, where I was raised and my own personal development.. not my skin color.
I don't follow your logic. You are arguing that African Americans shouldn't be called "African" because their heritage is not 100% African (ie, they are partly black and partly white). Yet at the same time you say they should be called black American, despite their being partly white.
Another weak argument against using the term.
He's right that you can't assume that a brown-skin person with curly hair must be American. Just like you can't assume that a pale-skin person with wavy hair is American, even if they are walking down a street in Dubuque or Seattle. They could be tourists or expats.
And you can't assume every black person outside of Africa is an immigrant (or has parents or grandparents who were immigrants) from Africa. Their recent ancestry could trace to Latin America or the Caribbean (although even these folks' ancestral lines lead back to Africa within the span of recent history).
But these are just arguments against applying the label African American too broadly without reflection. They don't alter the utility of the term for describing US citizens whose ancestors immigrated from Africa.
