it is much cheaper than, say, Hawaii with all the same benefits.
Online reviews say Sandals seem to accept gay couples just fine.
Bahamas looks really expensive.
Z, consider that you hope to do this honeymoon thing ONLY ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. I mean, isn't that the intention, right now, that you will both strive your best to stay together "until death do you part"? I don't think it's all that far-fetched, either - it's been my observation, in the past couple decades, that gay relationships are possibly MORE stable than hetero- ones, at least among those that I've been aware of.
What are you talking about; maybe a week? What's the difference between Jamaica, and one of the expensive places like Hawai'i or the French Riviera? Are you limited to a particular month or time-of-year? Choosing wisely can make a ton of difference - consider, for example, that going to Hawai'i in the summer can almost be an "escape" from oppressive Chicago, Washington DC, Dallas, etc. weather. Prices in the tropics are higher during northern winters.
OK, so you go to an expensive place for a week, and it costs the two of you a huge $1,700 more than Jamaica would have cost. (Even that is doubtful.) You've gone to this place that you really enjoyed, it was on your bucket list...and, for the REST OF YOUR LIFE TOGETHER, so OK, you've spent an extra $1,700 in your entire lifetime...you have this wonderful honeymoon experience you can share with each other (with the great memories even when not sharing) and maybe even tell your friends how great it was.
Do you really want to tell people for the rest of your life (while also remembering it, of course) how your one time in Jamaica was so horribly crummy because the concierge and other people at the American resort told you that you'd DAMN-better-not leave the hotel grounds, not go out and get a "feeling for Jamaica," and possibly that you DID dare go out and four guys suggested you must be gay and you just barely got away in your car? Flying to another part of the world just to be trapped in an artificial environment? I think not. You might as well just go on the cheap and book a week in a resort in Jamaica, Queens (a "cheaper" part of New York City). At least you'll actually be able to "get out and about" in reasonable safety.
You might even consider thinking "outside the box" and go someplace like Dubrovnik, Croatia - OK not like Croatia is entirely welcoming and embracing of LGBT, but there aren't laws against it, and it's a safe and beautiful country. Dubrovnik, Zadar, and Split are VERY highly regarded as European destinations and, from what I saw in the capital Zagreb (which, unlike these three cities, is inland), that country seems to have done a pretty decent job of getting their shit together, since communist Yugoslavia days. I liked Zagreb so much that RETURNING to it is on my bucket list.
Choose wisely. As I said, you will very possibly ONLY DO THIS ONCE.
I see that me being an engineer isn't going well with some people here, considering this is a constant point of attack.
I somehow missed that, Z, that you're being attacked just because you're an engineer. Whoever is doing that, PLEASE knock it off. There's nothing wrong with being an engineer. Yes, it's one-o'-dem "geeky" jobs, but IT'S ALL GOOD, and I assume it pays decently; and of course you also went into it by CHOICE. Assuming that the job is still working well for you, I applaud you for a good choice.
Provincetown, at the tip, is a nationally known gay mecca. It would be worth your while to rent a car to drive to P-Town.
ABSOLUTELY NOT IN THE SUMMER!!! At least, for the car rental and driving out part. It will take you a DAY just to get out there from Fall River or Quincy or whatever your point of reference is past Providence or Boston. It may take you half a day to get back out. It might be a little better if you're there in summer but not on any weekend. That place gets horribly jammed in summer. If you go in summer with a rental car, you may have to park miles away.
This is about 20-year-old news. Maybe it's not as intimidating anymore. Maybe they've upgraded U. S. 6 by now to accommodate the awful traffic. Though, I agree, "P-town" is wonderful...