~ Chapter 5 ~
One Month Later
Every exit is an entry somewhere else.
— Tom Stoppard
Sean awoke to the feeling of hungry lips fastened around his cock. With his eyes still closed, he smiled to himself, recognizing Zach’s customary morning greeting.
“I wouldn’t mind a slice of that action.”
Sean’s eyes snapped open at the sound of a strange voice. The ruggedly handsome face of the guy they’d picked up the previous night came into view. He was licking his lips appreciatively as he watched Zach’s head bob up and down on Sean’s erection.
“Get lost, Dan,” Sean snapped.
“It’s Ken,” corrected the guy, looking decidedly put out.
“Whatever,” said Sean, waving his hand dismissively at Ken. “Why’d you stop?” This last question was directed at Zach, who had paused in his blowjob.
“Don’t mind him,” said Zach, pointedly ignoring Sean. “He’s always a wet blanket the morning after. Now, if you ever want a repeat …”
“Of last night? Anytime.” Ken leaned over Sean’s body to kiss Zach on the lips. Sean felt something surge inside him.
“Can I take a shower before I leave?” asked Ken, breaking off the kiss.
“Sure. Just help yourself to one of the clean towels.” Zach waited till Ken was out of sight to round on Sean. “What was that about?” he demanded.
Sean gazed back innocently. “What was what?”
Zach narrowed his eyes at him. “You know exactly what I mean. Get your act together, Sean. No more of this jealous lover crap. You know I only call you back because you make for a good fuck.”
“Oh really? That’s the only reason you keep calling me back?” asked Sean cynically. He craned his neck to mash his lips against Zach’s. The blond stubble on his chin rasped against Zach’s smooth skin.
“You really need to get a shave,” murmured Zach. “You don’t pull off the scruffy look all that well.”
An unexpected surge of annoyance shot through Sean. “I don’t have to follow your opinion! You’re not my boyfriend,
remember?”
“Jesus! I was just
saying.” Zach looked hurt and Sean felt vaguely guilty.
“Okay, don’t get all sulky on me now. Come here.”
Zach still looked reluctant. “C’mon,” cajoled Sean, “I’ll make it worth your while.”
Zach grinned. “You’d better.” As he moved closer to the bed Sean grabbed him by the butt, digging both hands deep into the firm flesh. Their lips met and Sean’s fingers stealthily found their way to Zach’s asshole. He moaned as Sean probed his hole, still tender from having two cocks up it the night before.
“You up for another fuck?” whispered Sean sexily in Zach’s ear.
Zach grinned and didn’t bother replying. He climbed on top of Sean and sat down on his already-hard cock. Sean immersed himself in the experience, forgetting everything else – the twinges that had become increasingly common over the last month. There was a rational explanation for them, but it was not one he wanted to entertain. His eyes fell on the digital display of the bedside clock. In addition to the time, it also showed the date: December 1st. Sean sighed to himself; it was that time of year again. The merry season when people spent time with their loved ones, stuffed themselves with turkey and got drunk on eggnog. When they exchanged gifts under the tree, and kisses under the mistletoe.
Sean decided that, for the first time ever, he might actually hate Christmas.
* * *
“Wake up, sleepyhead!” Allie nudged Kyle, who was trudging alongside her with his eyes half-closed. “The cold, winter air is supposed to refresh you!”
Kyle opened his eyes wider to glare at her. “On the contrary, it makes me want to curl up in my nice, warm bed. Which is what I would have been doing if you hadn’t turned up at an
unseasonably early hour on a Saturday.”
Allie turned around to face him but continued to walk, backwards. “What do you mean – unseasonably? Can you think of anything more festive than Christmas decorations?”
Kyle sighed loudly. “Yes, but highly commercialized also comes to mind.”
“Oh come on, don’t be such a grinch!”
“I’m not; I’m just saying, if you want to volunteer for the library decorating committee, that’s fine. What I don’t see is why you had to sign me up as well!”
“Keep your holiday spirits up, you’ll see why in a moment!”
“Keep your holiday spirits up, she says,” grumbled Kyle, digging his gloved hands even deeper into his coat pockets. In front of him, Allie smiled to herself. A month had passed since Kyle had confessed his feelings for Troy to her. In all that time there had been no developments, other than Kyle falling more in love with Troy every time they had their tutoring sessions. Allie had planned for that to change today. Only she was not aware just
how it would change.
They rounded the bend in the avenue leading to the university library, and Allie heard a sharp intake of breath behind her.
“Got your attention now, huh?”
Kyle was staring at the handsome young man standing on a ladder, fastening one end of a Christmas garland above the library’s portico. Even in the dark green sweater he looked incredibly fit. As he bent down to talk to the guy holding the rest of the garland Kyle caught a glimpse of Troy’s trademark dimpled smile, and his heart beat faster.
Allie nudged her friend. “Well?”
“God, he looks … beautiful,” said Kyle dreamily.
He’s so in love with him, thought Allie.
Only he’ll never dare to tell him how he feels. Unless I do something about it. Aloud she said, jokingly, “A present you wouldn’t mind unwrapping?”
Kyle blinked to clear the fog that usually descended upon his mind whenever he first set eyes on Troy. “You set me up,” he accused.
“And you’ll love me for it,” replied Allie. “When I saw his name on the register I just knew I had to sign you up. Now this – this is the perfect opportunity for you to tell him how you feel.”
“Here?” asked Kyle incredulously. “In front of all the volunteers decorating the library? It’s a hell of a lot more private than the one-on-one tutoring sessions we have,” he said sarcastically.
Allie sighed and blew a strand of hair out of her face. “Of course I don’t mean for you to yell it from the portico for the world to hear. The library’s empty except for the volunteers. I’ll lure him to the storage room under the pretense of getting more decorations and leave you two alone, and then … who knows? You might even find yourselves under some mistletoe,” she said mischievously.
“Yeah, he’d probably sooner kiss a toad than me, mistletoe or not,” retorted Kyle.
“Oh come on, you’re not uglier than a
toad.”
Kyle, refusing to be persuaded, folded his arms across his chest.
“Okay, fine,” said Allie, exasperated. “If you don’t want to confess your secret love, you can just continue to be burdened by it into the New Year. You can – I don’t know – drown your sorrows in the gay bar or something.”
“I’m not going to be drowning – wait, there’s a gay bar?”
“Somewhere on Ross Street,” said Allie dismissively. “That’s not the point.
Are you going to tell him or not?”
Kyle looked back and forth between his best friend and the boy he was secretly in love with. “Al, you know I’ve tried. Every time I try to say something, like last week when I brought up Oscar Wilde, I – I just can’t go through with it.”
The look on Allie’s face indicated she had no idea how Oscar Wilde fit into the picture. “You have to keep trying. It’s almost Christmas – the season of love. What better time to confess your feelings?”
“And hope for a yuletide miracle?”
“Why not?” Allie smiled as she gave him a little push. “Go ahead, engage him in conversation and I’ll come by after a while with my request for assistance in the storage room.”
Kyle opened his mouth to protest, but she put a finger to his lips. “When I said go and engage him in conversation –
that wasn’t a request, it was an order. Go.” She gave him another push, harder this time. “I’ll be back in a moment.”
Kyle glared after Allie as she skipped up the library steps. He ascended them at a slower pace, grumbling to himself as he did so. “Confess gay love in the storage
closet. How ironic.”
“Hey Kyle!” Troy didn’t bother climbing down the last few rungs of the ladder; he jumped off instead. “I didn’t expect to see you here.”
“Erm … actually, it was kind of a last minute thing,” explained Kyle hesitantly. “My friend, she signed me up for it.”
“Well, I’m glad to see you here; we need all the help we can get,” said Troy, giving Kyle a friendly thump on his back that sent shivers up his spine. “As a matter of fact, I was roped into this by my brother.” He nodded towards the guy who’d been helping him with the decorations. “I don’t think you guys have met?”
Kyle shook his head, wondering how he hadn’t noticed Todd earlier. Then again, when he was around Troy, everything else seemed to fade into the background.
Allie had pointed Todd out to Kyle before that day. Kyle had realized that he’d seen him around the campus before, but never actually talked to him. It was strange considering how Troy made heads turn, that his brother was relatively unremarkable. Today was the first time he was seeing them together; the resemblance between the brothers was startling.
“Todd is one of our august library’s most faithful patrons.” Somewhat sheepishly, he added, “I guess
I should patronize it more often, then I wouldn’t need to pester you so much.” Kyle didn't mind being pestered in the least.
Troy turned to his brother. “You remember me mentioning Kyle right? My tutor for English Lit?”
Todd nodded. “Pleased to meet you,” he said in a low voice.
Kyle shook the proffered hand. “My pleasure.” Despite the similarity in their physical appearances, Kyle did not feel the same jolt of electricity at
this Madsen’s touch.
“So, which division are you joining?” asked Troy.
“We have divisions?”
Troy grinned. “Well, there’s a team doing the trees in the foyer. And then there’s us hanging the garlands around the portico. You could also put up the lights or –”
“Help get things out of storage?” Kyle was startled how Allie had managed to appear, seemingly, out of thin air. “Hi Todd,” she said. Todd blushed and mumbled a greeting in reply.
Troy looked first at his brother, and then at Allie. Kyle felt obliged to introduce them. “Oh, this is my friend, the one I was telling you about earlier, Allie – Alison Greene.”
Troy smiled charmingly at her as he offered his hand. “So it’s only Allie to friends?”
In spite of herself Allie found herself turning red. “Uh, no, you can use it if you want.”
“Alrighty then. It’s nice to meet you, Allie. I’m Troy –”
“Madsen,” finished Allie for him. Troy raised an eyebrow. Allie blushed again. “I’ve heard quite a lot about you.”
“Not all bad, I hope.”
“No, actually … most of it was good.”
“Oh?” Troy managed to make the single word sound so much sexier. “I do try to maintain a good reputation, but it seems I’ve been failing. If you were to hear some of the rumors about me …”
The color of Allie’s face matched her pink scarf as she recalled her comment to Kyle about Troy bedding the cheerleading squad. “I haven’t,” she said, a little too quickly.
“That’s good.” Troy continued to smile disarmingly at Allie. “Because I would hate it if such gossip were to reach the ears of someone as pretty as you.”
She gulped and tore her eyes away from his penetrating green gaze to look for Kyle, only to see him disappearing into the library.
* * *
Kyle leaned against the wall and sank slowly to the floor of the storage room. It was unbelievable. Allie, who had been intent on uniting him with his crush, was instead drawn into flirtation with Troy.
He had seen the look Troy had given her. He would have given anything for Troy to look at him like that. But he knew it was only a dream, and an impossible one at that. One he shouldn’t indulge in any further.
But he couldn’t keep it from his mind. Why? Why did the guy he had a crush on have to like, of all people, his best friend? Someone was playing a cruel joke on him.
A crack of light spilled into the darkened closet as the door swung open. Allie ducked her head in and spotted her best friend with his knees drawn up to his chest on the floor. “Kyle! I’ve been looking all over the library for you.”
He didn’t say anything. Allie let the door swing shut and sat down on the floor beside him. “Listen Kyle, it’s not what you think.”
“What did he say?” asked Kyle in a curiously emotionless voice.
“It doesn’t matter –”
“Just tell me, Al. The truth, please.”
Allie winced. “He – he asked me out.”
Kyle shut his eyes as if in pain.
“But I said no.”
“Why?”
Allie was astounded. “What do you mean, why? You’re my best friend, and you love him. I couldn’t –”
“Was he disappointed?” interrupted Kyle.
“Yes – no – I don’t know! Does it make a difference?”
“Yes,” said Kyle quietly.
“Kyle, I never meant for that to happen. I don’t know why I didn’t pull away as soon as I realized where he was headed –”
Kyle gave a crooked smile. “He got you, didn’t he? It’s something in those eyes, that smile – it gets you every time. I know from experience.”
Allie looked perturbed. “Kyle, I never meant to hurt you, and I’m sorry if I did. But you don’t have to worry, Troy isn’t the one for me.” She grasped both of his hands. “He’s all yours. I’m not going to – to
fight you for him.”
“I know you won’t. But … you have to.” His words surprised him almost as much as they did Allie. “You have to say yes.”
She stared at him in absolute bewilderment. “I – I can’t! Kyle, you
love him.”
“And he … he likes
you. Which is a lot more sensible than me loving him. So if you meant what you said the other day, about being there for me, you’ll do this one favor for me. Troy’s a great guy, one who deserves a fair chance. He shouldn’t lose it because of our friendship.”
If she had not realized it before, in that instant it dawned on Allie just how much Kyle cared for Troy. And she made up her mind. “Okay.”
Kyle looked up, slightly disconcerted that she’d given in so quickly. “Really?”
Allie nodded. “Just the one date.”
Kyle stumbled over his reply. “You’d better hurry then, before he takes your ‘no’ for granted.”
Allie hesitated for a moment. Kyle gave a weak smile. “I’ll be fine. Go quickly.”
She got up and opened the door. Her hand still resting on the doorknob, she gave a final glance backward. Kyle nodded towards the outside, a weak grin still on his face. And then the door swung closed, cutting off the light from the corridor.
Kyle finally gave in to the emotions that had been building up inside him. Why did letting go a guy to whom he hadn’t so much as confessed his love hurt so much? What had possessed him to be so fucking generous in the first place? Oh, it had seemed so noble at the time, sacrificing any chance of admitting his feelings on the altar of his love for Troy. But now that Allie had actually gone off to agree to a date with the guy he loved, he didn’t feel so noble anymore. On the contrary, he felt plain shitty.
Christmas was the season of giving. And he’d just given up the most precious gift of all.
* * *
Troy ran a hand through his exquisite brown locks in frustration. “I fucked it up, didn’t I?” he groaned.
Todd sighed. “It would have helped to not be so impulsive.”
Troy ignored him and groaned, “Of all the cheesy pick-up lines …”
“I don’t know; it could’ve worked for
you …” Todd heaved another sigh. “Forget it, we still have plenty of decorations to put up.”
The brothers worked for a while in silence. Then Troy shot his brother a sideways glance. “So, she’s been in your physics lecture all this while, huh? How come you never told me about her?”
Todd’s glare was quickly wiped off his face. He poked his brother sharply in the ribs.
“Wha-?” Troy started to say, when he realized what – or rather who – Todd had already noticed.
“Allison! Hi! Again.”
Allie smiled tentatively at him. “Allie … please. I was hoping … it isn’t too late to take you up on your offer?”
Troy blinked. “No. No, not at all.”
“Great!” Allie wondered if she sounded too eager. “Should I -?”
“No, I’ll come by to pick you up. Tonight? At seven?”
“Um, that sounds perfect. You know where I-”
“Actually … No,” admitted Troy.
Allie told him where her room was. “I’ll see you then? At seven?”
“You can bet on it.” Troy remembered to flash another of his dazzling smiles at her. Allie smiled back, nervously.
Troy wheeled around to face his brother once she’d left. “Did that really happen?”
He looked almost as awestruck. “Apparently it did.”
Troy shook his head in amazement.
* * *
Later that same day, Allie paced around her room anxiously, cradling her phone in the palm of her hand. Kyle was a push of a button away. But if she called him, she was sure he’d try to talk her out of it. And that simply wouldn’t do. She knew her plan of action, and she was going to stick to it.
There was a knock on her door. She almost tripped in her haste to answer it.
“Troy! Hi.”
“Hi.” He looked even hotter, if that was possible. He had clearly made an extra effort with his appearance tonight. Of course Troy looked sexy whatever he wore. But his obvious preparation for their date made Allie feel worse as his eyes scanned her casual jeans and fluffy pink sweater.
“Uh,” he said nervously, “you look wonderful but … the place we’re going to might need something a little more … formal?”
“Formal?” repeated Allie.
He gave a small grin. “Valentino’s.”
Allie’s eyes fairly popped out of their sockets. Valentino’s was one of the classier restaurants in town. It was also notoriously expensive, and probably quite difficult to get reservations in December. “You got us … a table at Valentino’s?”
Even nervousness looked appealing on Troy’s handsome features. “Too much for a first date?” Looking rueful, he produced a small bouquet of champagne roses from behind his back. “I guess these are, too.”
Allie was quite at a loss for words. Those beautiful roses – it was true that there were just a few stalks, but in winter! She was staggered by the lengths he’d gone to for the date.
He fixed his green eyes on her. “Don’t freak out on me, okay? I guess I might’ve gone overboard, but it’s sort of my first proper date and I wanted it to be perfect.”
It was a little unbelievable that someone as good-looking as Troy had made it to college without ever going on a proper date. But maybe his definition of a date differed from hers.
The way he shifted from one foot to the other, his puppy-like exuberance, was catching. She simply couldn’t say no to him. “I’ll – I’ll get changed. Just give me a few minutes. And … thank you.” She accepted the roses.
Closing the door after Troy excitedly agreed to wait outside, she leaned against it and raised her eyes heavenward. Kyle would have to forgive her.
* * *
In his room, Kyle mirrored his best friend’s actions as he paced in circles around his roommate. Mick looked up from his laptop after Kyle had completed a few dizzying round.
“Hey man, you’re like a caged cat today. What’s up?”
What’s up? Kyle felt like retorting,
I decided to be Mother Teresa, that’s what!
Aloud he said, “Nothing really. Just too much pent-up energy, I guess.”
“Go and walk it off, man.” Mick sounded almost eager to get rid of Kyle. In response to Kyle’s glare, he shrugged. “I’ve got a chick coming over in a bit and …”
Kyle groaned inwardly. He knew what Mick was trying to tell him. Usually he’d go to Allie’s room when this happened, but not tonight. She was probably out on her date. With Troy. Troy I-love-him-so-damn-much-but-he’ll-never-know-it Madsen.
“Fine!” He yelled suddenly, startling Mick so much that he almost dropped his laptop. “I’ll go for a walk.”
Kyle grabbed his coat and made sure to bang the door on his way out. He’d made it out of the building before he realized he’d forgotten to put on his scarf. He contemplated going back to get it, but he’d already made a dramatic exit and he didn’t intend on spoiling it. He shivered and turned the collar of his coat as high up as possible and tucked his hands back into the pockets.
He decided on a walk into the town. Find a nice place to grab a steaming mug of hot chocolate and wait there till it closed, and then take a leisurely stroll back along the riverside.
As he walked down the streets of the city one signpost in particular caught his eye. Ross Street. Why did it sound so familiar?
Then he remembered. A snatch of conversation from that fateful morning. He’d never been down that particular street, much less known a gay bar even existed in this town.
Out of curiosity more than anything else, he found himself turning into Ross Street. Not far down was the club’s blue neon sign. He wondered how he’d never noticed it before. Especially with a name that obvious – Gayer spelt backwards.
He paused outside the entrance. He shocked himself by even considering the thought of going in. What was he thinking? The only guy who’d ever made him feel that way was Troy. Troy who was on a date with his best friend.
He remembered why he’d been brought down to this level. Everyone had a fucking date except him. So to hell with it. He made the decision that would change his life, and the lives of several others, in the course of that one night.
He stepped into the bar.
To be continued …
And that’s it for my little Christmas present to you all. Chris, I hope the length of this chapter makes up for the previous one
. This chapter is great fun too! A bit depressing for Christmas Day, I know, but it can’t be helped. And also a last minute change in the chapter title. Is “Reversal” ever going to be the title of a chapter? Lol, I have no idea. I’m still looking for a title and an opening quote for the next one.
As always, your comments and feedback is greatly appreciated. 