PLEASE READ: To register, turn off your VPN (iPhone users- disable iCloud); you can re-enable the VPN after registration. You must maintain an active email address on your account: disposable email addresses cannot be used to register.
Yeah, it is bullshit because I wonder to myself why do so many dwell on such trivial things like mannerisms.
^ Your avatar doesn't seem very feminine. Y'know, just pointing out.
Lex
It is surprising that they're so drawn to it that:
1. They'll continually debate with visible trolls
2. They'll have the same.exact.discussions. over and over again, ad nauseum, without accomplishing anything except spewing the same opinions each time
It's not just interest - it's a sign of psychosis.
If it were two guys arguing in the privacy of someone's home, I'd agree with you.
But we're on a public forum. Ask any forum administrator of any forum (gay, straight, bowling, bicycling, electronics, you name it), and you'll discover that the vast majority of people are lurkers.
And on a gay forum like this, I'd guess that a large portion of lurkers are curious or tentatively gay guys who are just discovering what it means to be gay.
For them, these discussions can be life-defining. And if the idiot/troll posters are never challenged, it might take lurkers a long time to figure out what's going on.
So, no, it's not insane.
For them, these discussions can be life-defining. And if the idiot/troll posters are never challenged, it might take lurkers a long time to figure out what's going on.
There are thousands upon thousands of terrified young people looking in on this site wondering what life 'outside the closet' might be, and you're telling them to grow some balls and get out of the closet already because anybody with half a brain can look at them and know immediately that they're fags because every gay man has easily-identifiable feminine traits.
Not trying to be an asshole but I think if any young person is reading this post JUB is certainly not the place for younger lurkers who are struggling with their sexuality.
You're just as bad as he is with these arguments.
And every time you show weakness like this, he pounces on it.
Just for my peace of mind, what is the definition of a forum lurker?
People need to come out at their rate. Sometimes gentle pushing is required, but lets not be so heavy handed. Sometimes the reluctance to come out isn't just internal. There can be potentially dangerous external forces stopping young guys (and girls) from coming out.
Just for my peace of mind, what is the definition of a forum lurker?
People need to come out at their rate. Sometimes gentle pushing is required, but lets not be so heavy handed. Sometimes the reluctance to come out isn't just internal. There can be potentially dangerous external forces stopping young guys (and girls) from coming out.

Most of us grew up with our masculinity being called into question, and usually in a rather harsh and possibly violent manner. And most of us eventually stopped spending time with such people, and the ones we did hang out with didn't mention our femininity - partially because they didn't care, and partially because they (perhaps instinctively) knew that it was a sore spot growing up, and perhaps it wasn't a good idea to dwell on that topic.
So as time went on, and people stopped mentioning our feminine ways, we grew to believe they didn't exist. Hey, nobody said anything, so they're not there, right? It's certainly easier on our still-fragile ego to think that we're 100% straight acting than it is to think that the thing we got bullied for as a kid is still visible for the world to see.
Part of my job involves playing back recordings of my voice, and watching video footage of myself. Doing this on a regular basis, it's hard to maintain the illusion in my mind's eye that I'm 100% straight-acting. Right there - that eye movement, that hand motion, the way I said that word - all effeminate. And each time I see and hear it, I fight those bullies again. Not by butching it up, but by having to convince myself yet again that yes, I'm somewhat effeminate, and there's nothing wrong with that.
Lex
Agreed.
Funny thing I've noticed on this board, how guys who claim they're repulsed at the thought of dating a guy less masculine than they are, usually share the some of the same (if not all of the) qualities they're criticizing effeminate men for. At this point, the queeniest thing a guy could write on this board is how masculine and straight-acting they think they are.
I just figured guys like that just don't want to get involved with someone exactly like them. They're attracted to guys who can counterbalance not compete against their softer mannerisms.

