- Joined
- Dec 31, 2007
- Posts
- 60,798
- Reaction score
- 14,576
- Points
- 113
Just to make sure Dr Milton's comments are interpreted correctly: he's not disputing the WHO's conclusions ; he's saying that there's not enough research to make informed recommendations. That's "evidence-based practice" and it's a good thing....In a March 28th NPR article, Dr. Donald Milton, an infectious disease aerobiologist at the University of Maryland's School of Public Health, disputed the WHO’s conclusion that the COVID-19 virus was only/primarily spread through respiratory droplets.
The article that I cited from NEJM is just one source. Milton is spot on- we need more studies to figure out how this virus is transmitted and we need those studies so that we can make better recommendations to the public.
We have a lot of really puzzling data that is coming in very rapidly and it's creating more questions than answers. For example, why was northern Italy hit so hard but southern Italy wasn't hit proportionately? Or, why are Canada's numbers so low but on the other side of the border, states like New York, Washington and Michigan have escalating numbers?
Dr Zeke Emmanuel has been saying in interviews this week that he's begun to rethink the mask recommendation- not because it's going to protect the person wearing the mask but instead because it could protect the public from the person wearing the mask. Other public health officials are also beginning to have the same question of the mask recommendation. One thing hasn't changed- the public doesn't need to wear an N95 mask unless they are caring for someone at home who has coronavirus; the recommendation for the public would be a standard paper or cloth mask.
White House task force could soon recommend Americans wear masks [CNN]
Most members of President Donald Trump's coronavirus task force have come to agree that Americans should begin wearing face coverings in public and could issue formal guidance on the matter soon, people familiar with the matter said...
"Now we've learned about this disease -- and we've always said we're going to learn more, we're going to adjust -- and we've learned there's a fair amount of asymptomatic spread and so we've asked the CDC to take another look at whether or not having more people wear masks will prevent transmission of the disease to other people," US Surgeon General Dr. Jerome Adams said Wednesday on ABC "Good Morning America."
Not to drag politics into this but it's really not helping when the media keeps quoting Donald Trump in these recommendation articles. Trump has proven too unreliable on the issues of public health. The media should focus more on quoting experts when it comes to advice.

