American Idol: Season 10

[Sgt Pepper]

It will be so unfair when Haley gets eliminated tomorrow after another good performance when Lauren, Paul, Casey, and Thia were all GOD AWFUL. And it's partly the judges' fault; they've been underrating Haley ever since her awesome pitch perfect "Blue" performance.

I still wish an anvil would fall on Lauren.

 

[aijalon18]

LMAO @ the latest idol getting no love tonight. I didnt even finish watching the DVR after Stefano got negative criticism from the judges. I cant stand that Lionel Richie song or the video with the blind girl. it's so annoying. My man made a bad choice. Of all the Motown songs, that's what he chose? Stefano was still so cute. Even J-lo is still tryin to throw her vagina at him. I hope he wasnt too hard on himself. I don't want my puppy to cry.

I'm finding the Music Exec involvement pretty annoying.

 

[Sgt Pepper]

I didnt even finish watching the DVR after Stefano got negative criticism from the judges. I cant stand that Lionel Richie song or the video with the blind girl. it's so annoying. My man made a bad choice.

I don't think it was a bad choice -- and he sang it well -- but they're right that he needs to work on connecting with the song and the audience. He still closed his eyes too much for example.

The only thing I don't like about the judges criticizing Stefano is that their otherwise accurate appraisal is EVEN MORE TRUE for that cow Lauren and the insufferable Casey and Paul. Yet the judges never go there with those three yahoos.

Casey and Paul were absolutely terrible tonight, and have been for weeks now, but the judges keep praising them for being "real." Ugh. If that's "real artistry", then give me fake manufactured studio production any day!

 

[aijalon18]

I don't think it was a bad choice -- and he sang it well -- but they're right that he needs to work on connecting with the song and the audience. He still closed his eyes too much for example.

The only thing I don't like about the judges criticizing Stefano is that their otherwise accurate appraisal is EVEN MORE TRUE for that cow Lauren and the insufferable Casey and Paul. Yet the judges never go there with those three yahoos.

Casey and Paul were absolutely terrible tonight, and have been for weeks now, but the judges keep praising them for being "real." Ugh. If that's "real artistry", then give me fake manufactured studio production any day!

Lauren was actually ok, for Lauren. She is still the biggest ham and cow. She sashays around the stage like Aretha Franklin. And she is def not.

Casey was so bad today I thought, "They are finally gonna let him have it for that shitty mess." But nope they loved it.

I heard James from the kitchen and he sounded good. But he also is his own biggest fan.Have any of these assholes heard of humility?

I hope Stefano is safe. But I think J-lo will using her save for when he is in danger. She better....

 

[knobby]

Casey sucks!!

 

[charmed12345]

I hope Stefano is safe. But I think J-lo will using her save for when he is in danger. She better....

You know she will lol

I hope he is safe though, even though his performance wasn't his best. But I still think he did better than some of the others and he still needs work on connecting to the audience and telling us a story with his singing.

Still love my boo though

 

[FanofFiction]

Last night I actually, for the first time, enjoyed James Durbin.

Stefano was weaker than usual, I felt. But I hope he makes it another week.

 

[billybob109]

The judges are either being stupid or do not know what they are talking about. why dont they tell it how it is like simon did he would of bashed stefano on stage 20 episodes ago he did horrible tonight and the judges did not say that!

 

[slutte]

I think they'll use their save on Jacob. ew.

 

[Kigan2006]

I think they'll use their save on Jacob. ew.

What frightens me is that I know you are right.

They orgasm every time he performs. I'd probably walk off stage if I were set to perform after him last night. They sicken me to no end.

From the START I know they have the people they will save noted down, in priority. That talking of theirs is total BS.

Take Ashton, for example. Who in their right mind ACTUALLY thought they would save her?

Or Karen. The only one in her corner was Jennifer Lopez, who happily threw the others under the bus with "This was NOT unanimous" before telling her. Even though, for those of us paying attention, saying that gave her the answer.

If we were blessed to be rid of Casey or Paul FINALLY, they'd probably save them because they are driving nails into their coffins with Jacob Lusk and others.

Meanwhile, the beauty that is Naima performed amazingly, but you didn't see them getting worked up over her. Nope, she's not good enough to be their chosen one. And meanwhile VFTW is smoking something intense as they include her in the same area as Casey, Paul, and Jacob. I don't know what their issue is. Is it supposed to be some sort of support for the fact that she isn't their cookie cutter American Idol?

Bah! Sick of the crap. Sick of the obvious favoritism and forced Ryan-Randy banter. This show is stinking worse than Lusky Stank.

Naima is the full package. She's talented as a singer AND as a performer. I was dancing to the memory of her performance all through Durbin's performance.

 

[joesman]

I am on the "hate Lusk" train. He makes me want to stick nails in my ears. So you have a big voice but there are a trillion notes you miss and your clothes don't fit. Get a tailor.

 

[Callum]

So umm...I actually watched an episode...do the judges consistently say positive things? I didn't hear a negative comment...at all...and some of them were pretty awful. Especially the black chick from The Fifth Element.

 

[Tadaa]

So umm...I actually watched an episode...do the judges consistently say positive things? I didn't hear a negative comment...at all...and some of them were pretty awful. Especially the black chick from The Fifth Element.

I have feeling Howard Stern might be available next year. AI producers should snap him up.

 

[giftart]

I... SO WANNNA SEE PAUL make out with another GUY!. dammmit. Im sooo in love with him right now! <3

that smile of his. swoooon!

 

[Sgt Pepper]

I hope Stefano is safe. But I think J-lo will using her save for when he is in danger. She better....

I'd be shocked if Stefano ended up in the Bottom Three any time soon. And yeah, you know if he's ever eliminated J-Lo would use that save like it's never been used before. I just hope when she does, she tells Stefano, "You used to have a little, now you have a lot."

If I were Marc Anthony, I'd be very concerned.

 

[joesman]

Were it me and he ended up in bottom 3 and on the verge of elimination I would save him because I think he is quite good, and I thought he was quite good singing Hello. If he goes the Michael Buble route he will be popular, that's how I see his recording life and I would buy just like I buy some of Buble's stuff.

I absolutely hate Jacob Lusk. He's the only one that gets praise that makes my skin crawl because what he sings, how he sings it is awful, out of tune most of the time and always, always, always over sung to ear piercing horror.

 

[aijalon18]

I'd be shocked if Stefano ended up in the Bottom Three any time soon. And yeah, you know if he's ever eliminated J-Lo would use that save like it's never been used before. I just hope when she does, she tells Stefano, "You used to have a little, now you have a lot."

If I were Marc Anthony, I'd be very concerned.

Seriously, his wife has the biggest boner for a younger, cuter guy. That's gotta be awkward.

My little Stef was so cute when he was sad. I love his little speaking voice. I could talk to him on the phone all night like I was in middle school.

 

[aijalon18]

Were it me and he ended up in bottom 3 and on the verge of elimination I would save him because I think he is quite good, and I thought he was quite good singing Hello. If he goes the Michael Buble route he will be popular, that's how I see his recording life and I would buy just like I buy some of Buble's stuff.

I absolutely hate Jacob Lusk. He's the only one that gets praise that makes my skin crawl because what he sings, how he sings it is awful, out of tune most of the time and always, always, always over sung to ear piercing horror.

I don't see Stefano being like Buble. That would be interesting but I don't see it. He's too cute they'll prolly push him to be like Bruno Mars, to fit in with whats going on with music now.

And as far as Jacob Lusk, I know this isn't PC but to me he acts like a drag queen. He's just so extra. He exaggerates every note and every movement. It just really puts me off. You know when he's backstage, he puts on wigs and flips his hair all around.

 

[Sgt Pepper]

I don't see Stefano being like Buble. That would be interesting but I don't see it. He's too cute they'll prolly push him to be like Bruno Mars, to fit in with whats going on with music now.

Ooh good call! Stefano is totally a better looking Bruno Mars.

 

[Salemite]

What is the purpose of the judges on this show? They don't even judge anything. All they do is pimp who the producers tell them to pimp and praise performances that don't deserve to be praised...

"That was amazing! You're incredible! A real artist! I can't believe your talent!"

Seriously?

I don't think the judges gave a single negative critique last night. Not one.

Casey was awful. Jacob was awful. Stefano was awful. Scotty was awful. Naima was underwhelming. They all sucked but the judges acted like they had just given the performance of their careers. And Haley? She's one of the most annoying, unlikable people I've ever seen on this show. Everything about her makes me want to punch the TV screen.

I might have to skip tonight's episode.