Did anyone notice that on Tuesday the Judges said only 4 guys deserved to be in the top 12. That means they think all 8 girls should've been in the top 12 including Antonella and Haley. The 4 was probably Blake, both Chris's and Phil so they think Antonella and Haley are better than Jared, Brandon, Sundance and Sanjaya.
I commented from my favorite to least favorite.
1. Chris Richardson is the whole package. He’s extremely hot, he’s got one of the most beautiful voices I’ve heard in a long time, he’s a great, entertaining performer. There’s never been anyone like him on Idol. He’s never tried to be like Justin, just other people compared him to Justin, in his interview he said he didn’t want to be compared to everyone. People who don’t like him especially keep trying to bring the Justin comparison thinking that people who like him will start to like him less and vote for their favorite instead when it won’t happen. He can’t change what his voice sounds like.
2. Blake Is my 2nd favorite, no one on the show has ever been like him too. I especially liked his first 2 performances, the 3rd was just ok. He’s probably the most marketable and has the biggest chance of success.
3. Jordin is the best girl to be on the show in a long time. She can sing any style of music. She sung Celine’s song better than the original during her audition, she’s already sang popish, RnB, Rockish types of songs, she won’t have a problem with any category in the up coming weeks. She’s got a great personality too.
__________________________________________________________________
Some of the rest are good but none of them Wow me.
4. Phil is good but very forgettable. His performances are kind of boring. I’d listen to him but probably won’t ever go to one of his concerts.
5. Gina was OK
6. Brandon did terrible weeks 1 and 2 but his performance this week was ok. I thought Jared or Sundance should’ve made it instead of him.
7. Haley is very forgettable. Nothing special from her yet. She’ll probably be gone next week.
8. Stephanie, I do not need another Beyonce when I don’t even like Beyonce. She sounds exactly like Beyonce but looks like Fantasia.
9. Lakisha, how is she any different from Frenchie and Mandisa? You can find the same voice at any church, why is she so special? I think her background story is a big part on why people became her fans. All she does is stand there in her performances.
10. Chris S annoys the hell out of me. His jokes are so stupid and unfunny. He wants to be the next Taylor by being goofy and picking his group name as the “Fro Patrol”. His song choices were bad and his performances are plain and not memorable.
11. Melinda, I don’t get it. Why do people like her so much. I think her shy thing is an act. She even had a T-shirt that says “I am shy” in one of her videos. Every time the judges gives her a compliment, she goes all wide eyed and drops her jaws “Like oh my gosh” like a deer in headlights. It’s like she pretends that she’s surprised by their comments every time when she isn’t. Her voice is so loud and drags so long, I have to turn the volume down while listening to her. She doesn’t do much during her performance and her song choices are so old fashioned. She gives an average performance for her music style and everyone jumps up and down saying wow like they’ve never heard her voice a million times before. I don't like the gospel, Dreamgirls diva type of music
12. Sanjaya, too many better guys have gone before him. All the guys who left are better than him.
