Stardreamer
auribus teneo lupum
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2010
- Posts
- 5,044
- Reaction score
- 6
- Points
- 38
- Location
- Over the Hedge and Under the Hill
Re: Star Wars: Episode Vll
SPOILERS
I saw it yesterday and something that bothered me is the film overall has a feel like someone watched the original trilogy but didn't really bother to try and understand the 'physics' of the fictional universe. Particularly in the use of the Force. Now the Force is this universe's version of magic but properly done magic in story universes needs to still be consistent and follow some rules. We have the main new Jedi character essentially learning how to use the force from a 'mindmeld' with the villain. The mind tricks shown before never equated to outright telepathy. Empathy, foreshadowing and increased sense of awareness yes but reading a stranger's mind was something even the Emperor and Vader could not do. If they could why bother with torturing Leia at all? And stopping an energy blast in mid-air?
SPOILERS
I saw it yesterday and something that bothered me is the film overall has a feel like someone watched the original trilogy but didn't really bother to try and understand the 'physics' of the fictional universe. Particularly in the use of the Force. Now the Force is this universe's version of magic but properly done magic in story universes needs to still be consistent and follow some rules. We have the main new Jedi character essentially learning how to use the force from a 'mindmeld' with the villain. The mind tricks shown before never equated to outright telepathy. Empathy, foreshadowing and increased sense of awareness yes but reading a stranger's mind was something even the Emperor and Vader could not do. If they could why bother with torturing Leia at all? And stopping an energy blast in mid-air?











....love it







