I'd post the Survivor Sucks winner edgic charts, but posting images never seems to work when I do it. Here's the
thread which has the charts in the third post, though.
Looking at the winner charts, Tina's season had fourteen episodes. She was rated 1 or 2 out of 5 in visibility in only five episodes, and the first episode is an anomaly because Mark Burnett admitted that Tina was intentionally not featured in the premiere of Outback because Richard was featured so heavily in Borneo.
Tina's edit was pretty regular for a winner, as the editors showed that:
A) Tina was in an alliance with Colby and Keith pre-merge
B) Her alliance joined with outsiders Jerri and Lamber at the merge to combat Kucha
C) Tina, knowing Keith had previous votes, gave Keith the first individual immunity win, which guaranteed that Ogakor would be able to beat Kucha in a tie vote and proceed to pagong them
D) Tina was the cause of the "Good people need to win!" theory that led to Ogakor kicking out Jerri and Amber before Elisabeth and Rodger. It was also why Colby picked Tina over Keith.
The editors showed other instances of her thinking strategically, such as when she voted off her friend Maralyn early in the game, but Tina was still properly overshadowed by distraction characters like Jerri and Colby.
Brett, meanwhile, has never gotten higher than a 2 visibility in all of Samoa, and the only time he was shown strategizing was in this week's episode. His rating is usually UTR1 or INV1, which are completely toneless, irrelevant edits. I mean, hell, in last week's episode he said one word ("180!" at the auction) in the entire hour.