joesman
JUB Addict
After sleeping on it, I'm going to have lean on the side that thinks this episode was a huge misstep. With only 3 and half hours left, we should be feeling more near to closure. But I feel farther away after last night. The episode seemed non-Lostian. They should have just left Jacob's and MIB's history to our imagination. If this is the only explanation of the smoke monster's origin we will get, I'd rather it also had been left to my imagination.
Damon & Carlton no doubt had alot of hate mail to wade through today for dropping the ball on this one, especially so near to the end. Instead of things coming together, they are still falling apart. It's starting to look as if our worst fears are getting realized; that they really were making things up along the way and Lost really did not ever have an underlying secret as we were lead to believe for six years. I'm a little less excited for the finale, and that's not a good thing.
In short, I think we may be getting the X-Files treatment here.
Truly as I was watching the show last night I felt totally detached from Lost. It so reminded me of an old Biblical tale - like Cain and Abel, the prodigal son, etc. When the show was over I didn't feel any more enlightened than I had before, just perplexed and feeling weird. It DID NOT feel like anything attached to the Lost I have loved and hated and praised and detested through these years.

























