Thanks for the link and the gentlemanly desire for discussion.
I don’t equate criticism of the Israeli government with antisemitism.
Perhaps you don't make that equivalency but in other quarters, it has hindered a frank discussion about a level of war atrocities that we haven't seen since the Russians in Syria.
But I do consider the keffiyeh a terrorist neckerchief.
Um, a keffiyeh (hattah) is a
head covering. Having survived a sandstorm in Arizona, I understand the practicality of wearing one. Jews used to wear it because sandstorms are ecumenical. That changed around 1947 for some reason.

Now you see kippahs flying in the wind unless there's a whole lotta hairpins holding it down.
Only hipsters in the US and UK wear a keffiyeh on their neck. They're also fashionable with the gay boys in London. It's the gay equivalent of Burberry.
And we know that, after October 7, 2023, there is no difference between Hamas and so-called Palestinians.
Just like after 20-Jan-2025, there's no difference between MAGA and Americans?
If you want to point fingers, point them at religious fundamentalists- in Palestine, in Israel and in Iran. The people of the middle east have spent millennia finding reasons to hate each other. They finally settled on religion as righteous justification for their battles over land, water and food. No one deserves a pass.
I am just struck with the Jew hatred on this thread.
You would have cite specific examples.
As Beinart expressed so eloquently, when the victims of historical pogroms and a Holocaust become the perpetrators and murderers of women and children in the name of a "Jewish State", they've lost the moral high ground they gained after WWII.
Other than America, they have few friends. And Americans are losing patience with their nonsense and the amount of money and munitions we have sent, only to see American treasure used to kill civilians, often with intention.