No one is "crying foul" in the sense of people intruding in other's sex lives...all we are saying is people are adults....you give your little speeches and spills with the statistics and fact all day long, but do you really think that is gonna stop people from barebacking and doing what they wanna do anyway? If anything----when you're constantly shoving this down people's throats----they will rebel and revolt, in a sense. I am in no way supporting this or saying it is right.
The gay public is not educated about STDs and HIV. I have seen that over and over when talking to gay guys.
Gay guys 40-60 yo are much more well-informed and bareback much less. That has to do with the very hard-hitting HIV prevention campaigns of the 1980s/90s, and the zero tolerance climate in relation to barebacking that once existed in the gay community.
Consider this from one of the latest studies:
-- those who answered they engaged in unprotected sex "everytime" and "sometimes" was 11% and 35% for guys under 25 yo, but 2% and 10% for those over 40.
-- when asked if ads that would show the specific grim details of living with HIV would make them more likely to have use condoms: 4% said no, 60% said possibly, and 36% said yes.
-- 34% of guys under 25 yo thought that contracting HIV was no more serious than getting herpes or gonorrhea, while only 12% of those 40 agreed.
-- only 19% of those under 25 agreed with the statement that HIV is an illness with debilitating side effects that can reduce your life expectancy by an average of 20 years, while 66% of those over 40 yo agreed.
-- when asked what the greatest factor encouraging barebacking behavior was: the greatest category of answers was "bareback porn".
So, this shows very clearly:
1. people are not well educated about the facts.
2. between 36%-96% of these people might change if there were more information campaigns out there that were crudely blunt about HIV, instead of the usual "it's a good idea to wrap it up!" kind of bullshit.
3. and normalization of barebacking, through bareback porn and other tendencies, is contributing heavily to the rising HIV infection rates
You yourself, AllMan, are an illustration of the lack of information prevalent. You have repeatedly spouted nonsense about straights barebacking too, and that's how babies are made, etc. Completely ignoring the essential fact that anal sex is several dozen times riskier to transmit HIV than vaginal sex.
Your contention that discussing facts is going to lead to condom fatigue and lead to guys barebacking more out of rebellion is not supported by any study I have seen.
This is not going to get solved, as you suggest, by waiting for the dumb barebackers to die off. That didn't happen in the 80s when many more were dying at astounding rates. It isn't going to happen now. At this rate it will continue to be a continuing catastrophe for the gay community for generations, with 15-20% suffering from it.
So, it's either that, or we find ways to reduce barebacking. It can be done. I don't think doing nothing is an option.
On a personal level I have nothing to gain from this, as I have been in a monogamous relationship for several years... call me odd, but I give a fuck about other people.